Do they wear well or does the shine dull pretty quickly?

This isn't a big deal if you're already replacing the wall board and doing a new tile installation.I would avoid installing a fiberglass tub and surround in a rental because there's a pretty good chance that at some point a tenant will use an abrasive cleaner which will scratch and dull the surface making it look old and ratty pretty quickly and very prone to staining.

With a dull feeling to the group, taking over the reins shouldn't be too hard :)  Give folks a reason to go, and they'll start showing up.  

Never a dull moment in the world of real-estating!

Never a dull day!

Professional cleaning dulled it, but it is still the first thing you notice when you walk into the room.

@Matt Landau, @Trey Dulling and @Dan Oliver (will someone please @mention the first two for me, for some reason my @mention isn't pulling them up) Thanks! 

Feel free to reach out if you have any questions or just want to chat about the local market :)I am looking to do the same as the OP, except I'm looking into the Herndon/ dulles region.

I currently live in California and am looking at moving to Dulles Virginia area for work.

Even dull blades will cut grass, so that is just a line of BS.