Looking for recommendations for liability insurance agent for NYC

[Caroline C.]

My State Farm personal umbrella liability insurance is lapsing b/c I now have 5 rentals and the maximum is 4. Rentals are owned personally, not as part of an LLC. They are financed at a nice rate, so I don't want to put them in an LLC and lose that financing. But I also don't want to forego liability insurance. So I need to find a personal liability insurance carrier that will cover my 5 rentals (and more as I am looking to continue to buy), plus my residence. Any recomendations for an independent agent in NYC? I got 2 quotes for an RLI umbrella but the max is 5 rentals on that so I'll do it if I can't find anything else, but ideally I'd rather go with a policy that will grow with my holdings. Thanks!