SWFL Homeowner's Insurance/Broker Recommendations

[Emmanuel Sanchez]

Good afternoon,

Hoping someone can lend a hand here.

I am currently in the midst of getting a new homeowner's insurance policy for a LTR that I own in Cape Coral, FL... as my previous insurer is pulling their coverage in the state of Florida. 

The policy quotes I have received from two different brokers, are for insurers which do not have national name recognition (e.g., Cabrillo Coastal, Southern Oak, Cypress Property & Casualty Insurance). I did some research and their reviews are quite frankly not great (I get it, no one likes insurance companies). However, I read through plenty of clients complaining about horrendous claims process. 

I am Florida native and insurance decisions are critical, given we are prone to hurricanes.

Any investors or professionals in the SWFL area, that can recommend an insurer or broker that they have positive experiences working with. 

Many thanks,

Emmanuel