Just Jump: A story on our 'first' deal in St Louis

Just Jump: A story on our 'first' deal in St Louis

Investor · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 21 votes

Hello BP Community!

I'm writing this post to begin chronicling the learning experiences we've had so far in the purchase, renovation, refinance, and renting out of a multi-family property in the city of St. Louis. I'm hoping that others of you who are considering jumping in can learn something from our learnings and from our mistakes. And of course advice or "hey that happened to me too" is always appreciated!

My brother and I have each individually owned single family properties for several years now in the St. Louis area. After both of us got hooked on BP, we decided to join forces and start looking to BRRRR it up. We both are professionals with full time jobs, so for the time being - this is a second job. We both own single family rental homes in nicer (ie more expensive) areas of St. Louis County, and they all cash flow decently - but after listening and reading from this community, we decided we probably could do better. St. Louis City (the area roughly 10 miles South, West, and North of the Arch) has a plethora of housing for sale that could use some improvement - so opportunities to build some equity! The biggest problem is finding therightarea. One street can be prime and a great opportunity in a growing area that is hot for millenials, the next street could be a D-class slum.

There is one overwhelming and repeated piece of advice we (and likely you) hear on this forum. Borrowing from old Nike slogans, "just do it." Borrowing from Steve Harvey, just "Jump." Pick your inspiration - the point is that in order to get action, you have to take action. So we started getting our ducks in a row to take action. But where do you even start?

We started driving the streets. Looking for neighborhoods and streets that we felt like we could handle. There are areas of St. Louis that are chocked full of Multi-Family properties so those were our focus areas.

If you know the city, we landed on areas around Tower Grove Park South. The properties could be acquired for between $75K-$200K and many have improvement opportunities to build some immediate equity. It's also an area hot for renovation. It doesnt take much driving to see a dumpter full of house guts from an active reno. They're everywhere.

OK, neighboorhood in our sights. Tons of stuff for sale, so now it's time to focus. We started an LLC holding company in preparation for acquiring properties.

The next step was to set our goals. What did we want? We both had experience with single families (both of us kept our previous primary residence as rentals), but we started to believe what we read/hear/see on BP that multi-fam is where the money can be made. So we knew we wanted multi-fam, but how big? I posted a question to BP with some great responses - do we look for small apartment complexes, or start with 2-4 unit multi-fam? Answers to that question were all over the board, but the best advice we thought we heard was to start with 2-4 unit. Get our feet wet with a small multi first before diving into true commercial-class apartments. We set our goals on finding a multi-fam with opportunity for moderate rehab where we could achieve a $20K immediate profit in ARV (after repair value) compared to purchase price + renovation costs, with a total budget of approximately $125-150K. We are looking to hold and rent out, with intent to cash out most of our initial investment in a refinance.

OK, so now we have our general geographic area and general goals for the property. We had started working with an agent who has a bunch of C-class rentals of his own, so he knew what to look for and what not to look for. Sort of. We scoured the MLS daily, and visited many a house. Some were turn-key, ready for renters... but those aren't quite what we were looking for. In others, you could quite literally see sky when you walked in the front door. Those were more than we were willing to bite off for the first project. We were looking for something where we could gain some equity with renovation.

Before I go any further, here's the biggest challenge we realized, and frankly are still struggling with. Everyone talks about needing a “team” – a group of professionals to help you with your goals. We had an agent, but we needed a contractor (or contractors) we could trust. This has turned out to be our biggest challenge. Frankly, unless you have family in the business – you need a project in hand in order to start finding and vetting contractors. We started reaching out to various contractors prior to having a project, and if they responded at all, it was generally a “call me when you have a project and then we’ll talk.” I mean that makes sense, they’re busy and don’t have time to shoot the **** with n00bs about hypothetical properties. The problem is that it’s tough to do good rehab estimation without having someone in your back pocket. More on contractors later. We just decided to get the project first, then we’ll find the contractors.

So we found a property. It was a doosy all right. Two unit multi-fam in the city on a big street called Kingshighway Blvd with a nice size, detached 2-car garage with separate doors (monetizable!). One unit was occupied, the other was open and “recently renovated.” We were not allowed to see inside the occupied unit until a contracted was accepted. We ran the numbers on a nifty estimation spreadsheet I built:

Purchase Details Financing Details
Purchase Price $ 90,000.00 % Down 25%
Esitmated Closing Costs $ 1,000.00 Down Payment $ $ 22,500.00
Estimated Repairs $ 33,984.00 Loan Amount $ 67,500.00
After Repair Value (ARV) $ 145,000.00 Loan Points 0
Total Project Cost $ 124,984.00 Loan Fees $ -
Potential Upside $ 20,016.00 Amortized Over (Years) 30
Interest Rate 4.75%
Total # of Payments 360
Monthly P&I $352.11
Total Cash Needed to Close $ 57,484.00
Cash Flow Details
Income Future Assumptions
Unit 1 Monthly Rent $ 850.00 Annual Income Growth 2%
Unit 2 Monthly Rent $ 850.00 Annual Prop Value Growth 2%
Unit 3 Monthly Rent $ - Annual Expense Growth 2%
Unit 4 Monthly Rent $ - Sales Expenses 7%
Additional Revenue $ -
Total Monthly Revenue $ 1,700.00
Expenses Expense Forecasts
Insurance / Month $ 100.00 Vacancy Rate (%) 5%
Monthly Taxes $ 91.50 Maintenance (%) 10%
Water/Sewer $ 69.70 Cap Ex Savings (%) 10%
Waste Removal $ 57.08 Property Management (%) 10%
HOAs $ - Vacancy Rate ($) $ 85.00
Electricity $ - Maintenance ($) $ 170.00
Other Monthly Expenses $ 50.00 Cap Ex Savings ($) $ 170.00
Description of Other: Lawn Mowing Property Management ($) $ 170.00
Total Operating Expenses $ 963.28 Net Operating Income (NOI): $ 736.72
Total Monthly Expenses: $ 1,315.39
Monthly Cash Flow: $ 384.61
Summary
Monthly Income $ 1,700.00
Monthly Expenses $ 1,315.39
Monthly Cash Flow $ 384.61
Annual NOI $ 8,840.64
Purchase Cap Rate 9.82%
Pro Forma Cap Rate 6.10%
Total Cash Needed $ 57,484.00
Cash on Cash ROI 8.03%
Rules of Thumb
Total Monthly Cash Flow using 50% Rule $ 497.89
1% Rule (Revenue >1% of purchase price) Pass
2% Rule (Revenue >1% of purchase price) Fail
Monthly Revenue as % of Purchase Price 1.89%

Note – numbers above assume refinancing, maintaining 25% equity.

It was immediately apparent upon walking into the unoccupied unit that the “recent renovations” were simply some lipstick trying to cover a pig in hopes we wouldn’t see. Odd fresh paint, some clearance mosaic tile slapped haphazardly behind the kitchen counter, and some paneling in the bathroom with a clawfoot tub and a strange smell of mold.

The owner started out by asking $149K and after 2 months had dropped the price to $129K. After looking at the property, we came up with our number. We negotiated and got an accepted offer at $105K.

Lesson #1: Cash is king. By offering to pay cash with quick close, the seller turned down other financed offers of more money for our cash offer. We got a good deal just by offering cash.

We weren’t willing to pay a penny more, someone else could deal with the headaches for that. The property was “as-is” but we made sure to have an inspection clause. Scheduled, done (building and sewer). We also finally got access to the occupied unit. When we walked into the occupied unit, the smell of pot was rough. And we noticed a few cockroaches, but didn’t stick around long enough to count them.

The building inspector showed up and within 2 minutes before even going inside, pointed down the side of the building. “See anything odd there?” The 2-story brick wall along the building side was very clearly not as straight a wall should be. The back corned was at a bit of an odd angle. Structural problems.

Our agent pulls us aside and says “the first sign of structural problems, I say run.” We asked the inspector – “If you wrap it up now, what do we owe you?” He said “I only do 1 inspection a day, so if I do the inspection or not it’s the same fee.” Ok hell, finish the inspection then.

He wraps up the inspection, and the list of issues is substantial. One corner of the house has a serious foundation issue, main stack should be replaced, flat roof needs serious work, major leaks in that moldy smelling bathroom (we found gym shorts wrapped around the toilet drain and subsequently sprayed with flex-seal, OMG). Serious cockroach infestation, substantial tuckpointing needed, 2nd story porch that is starting to fall away from the house, bad windows, multi-tapped breakers with evidence of arcing, and the list went on. The big ones to us were the foundation issues and the main stack. Against our agent’s recommendation, we saw those as big ticket opportunities for price reduction. Those are items that scare people away – including current owners. Maybe we can use it to our advantage.

So we call a structural engineer to evaluate the foundation, and 7 different plumbers to come bid the plumbing work. Structural engineer says it needs helical piering, likely 3 but worst case scenario as many as 7. We take the worst case scenario, multiply by $1500 per pier and start with an immediate reduction in our bid by $10,500. Plumbers came back with estimates ranging from $4,700 to $18,000. I think some of them just didn’t even want the job. Roof repair needs $1,000. So we use all of this to go back to the table, saying “this place needs a ton of work. Here are the estimates we have so far. We’ll give you $85,000.” We settle on $88K and the roach motel is ours.

Lesson 2: Get multiple bids, use them to re-negotiate the price. Be prepared to walk if the repair costs are more than the seller is willing to reduce.

The day of closing was a monster rain storm. We paid cash for the property, left the title company and head straight over to the property. We go inside to find a 2 foot chunk of ceiling fell off the second floor unit ceiling due to roof leaks and water was coming through at a substantial rate. Great. We own the place for 20 minutes and already found a new problem.

We convinced the first floor occupant to get the hell out, so within 2 weeks of closing he was out as well. And he was kind enough to leave a dumpster worth of **** behind in his unit.

Lesson #3: It’s worth every penny to find some crew on Craigslist to come empty out and clean a unit trashed by a renter.

We paid some guys $300 to come empty out the unit and haul off all the trash. They did. Now that the place was empty, we could better evaluate the condition of the unit. And oh my God, the roaches. It makes me shudder just reliving the roach horror. The tenant was so sloppy, he would leave months of takeout containers piled up in the fridge and layer upon layer of food slop on the stove, on the floor, being the cabinets, everywhere. And the roaches loved it. I moved the refrigerator, and at least 1,000 roaches from under the fridge scattered like teenagers at a kegger busted by cops.

We got some roach bombs, but they just laughed at us. We then said screw it, and tore out all of the cabinets and hauled them to the front yard. Doused them with Raid and posted them for sale on Craigslist. Ripped them out of the second floor unoccupied unit for good measure too.

Lesson 4: You’d be amazed what people will buy on Craigslist. Posted the cabinets for a few hundred bucks, and they were gone in 24 hours. When the person came to buy them, we watched a roach the size of my thumb crawl out of one of them and into her baby’s car seat. OMG.

After tearing out the cabinets, we started tearing out all of the wood paneling in the bathrooms… only to realize the roaches were there too. Tore the bathrooms down to studs and got rid of everything. Started tearing stuff our from everywhere in the house. Ripped out a “partially finished basement” that was really just drywall covering up a black moldy mess of a stone foundation.

Lesson 5: You’d be amazed at how quickly a dumpster fills up. We got a 30 yard dumpster expecting to only need 10. We filled it to the top, and over-shot our weight quota by 2 tons. Wow.

We started interviewing contractors at this point. We got bids from general contractors, renovation companies, and flippers. Numbers were all over the place – ranging from $30K to $80K for roughly the same scope of work. Now we had to find a contractor that we could trust to do good work but not gouge us on price, but someone who could also get the work done in a reasonable time so we can get it occupied and refinanced and move on.

We found a guy who does general contractor work, focusing on flips in St Louis (if you’re from STL and want to know the name, send me a note). His prices were pretty good, and he took me to 3 different projects he had ongoing to show me the quality of his work. It all seemed on the up and up, and his quality was good. But there was 1 major problem. My brother/business partner is an attorney. His instincts were to check into lawsuit history, and he found multiple previous lawsuits against this man for unfinished work. We confronted him about this, and he told us what seemed to be an honest story. E used to be an alcoholic and, while he delivered on hundreds of projects, there were a small number that he let get the best of him. He claims to be sober 18 months now, and these problems are in the past. He also claims to have since made amends with those inividuals.

I called several of his references, and they had nothing but positive comments on the guy.

We decided to take the gamble and negotiate a contract with the guy. The contract stated that the work was to be completed in 5 weeks, and we would withhold 10% of the total cost until the building passes occupancy inspection. He let us know he’d be going on a 2 week vacation the week after we signed the contract, but his crew would be there no matter what to get the job done. To cover ourselves, we ensured the contract stated that he would reduce total project cost by $500 per week after the 5 week timeframe was up.

Within the first few days, his crew had all of the windows ripped out and new windows in. The new cabinets were already delivered. We were elated – could we have found just the kind of guy we need on our team?

Well, then he went on vacation. Pace of progress came to a crawl. For the 2 weeks he was on vacation, very little work was done. We could tell people were coming over still, as random little things were done, but progress was painfully slow.

After the guy returned from vacation, he waited an additional 3 weeks to even get the permits in place. Once the permits were approved, progress did seem to pick up again. Tomorrow is the final day of week 8, so we’re already 3 weeks past his anticipated deadline. We’re still making progress- main stack has been completely replaced and new rough in plumbing is done, tubs are in, lots of plaster work done, but there is still a ton more work to do. I’ll be honest, we’re concerned about the job getting completed. It’s been a bit of a nightmare. Our only solace is that there are tons of materials at the place, work is getting done, and his price was still a few thousand less than the next lowest bid. So while time is money and delays are preventing us from getting the place rented out in a timely manner, we’re willing to be a little tolerant of delays given the job cost is still cheaper than the next cheapest bid and we’re getting $500/week off the project cost. Still, going with the cheapest isn’t always the best idea.

I’ll keep this posting updated with the renovation progress. Hoping it will be complete by end of week 10.

Lesson 6: Pay attention to legal history of contractors. Cheaper isn’t always better, and you can’t teach an old dog new tricks.

Now that we're getting closer to job completion, however, it's time to start working on the refinance. We learned something from a recent BP podcast that made us both a little concerned, something we didn't previously know. While we paid cash for the property, we were unaware that we couldn't refinance the property for 6 months after closing (at least not with Fannie Mae). That is going to put a bit of a strain on our hope to cash-out refi as quickly as possible in order to BRRRR. Coupled with that, we are also owning the property under the name of a property-specific LLC and that is owned by a holding company LLC. We're also trying to identify lenders that are willing to lend to an LLC as opposed to individuals. We are trying to avoid the quit-claim issue that others have discussed out of concern that the loan could be recalled once interest rates start to rise.

So, that’s where we are today. We did it – we pulled the trigger and bought a property that needs work. We’re trying to get that work done, and struggling to get our team of contractors, lenders, and professionals together. We knew building this team would be a challenge, but we didn’t quite realize how big of a challenge it would be. 

How do you do it, those of you that have been successful in similar stories? Tips for building a team?

Stay tuned for further updates…

14Reply
290 views

Most Popular Reply

Rental Property Investor · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2016 · 50 posts · 30 votes
9y

Solid post @Scott Schaecher - this brother of yours sounds like a smart, handsome dude. 

Do your diligence folks.  It's amazing what you can find on or about contractors, tenants, handymen, etc. we hemmed and hawed over whether to role the dice on this guy.  If it went as promised - we found our guy for the next few deals. If it fell apart, we arranged the contraxt where if the contractor flaked on us, we wouldn't be too far behind on finishing costs when we hired another contractor (unless the materials disappeared with our original guy).  For now, we're somewhere in the middle, the things he promised are getting done, but slowly, so we're frustrated we don't already have tenants in there. Most people don't know that in many counties and states, civil court records (usually not the documents involved in the lawsuit) are easily accessible online to the public. So do your homework - a little extra effort now can can save a lot of time and expense later.

Scott also didn't point out that we're both married with little ones and while our wives have not been directly involved in the day to day of this project, they're extremely supportive of efforts and have gotten into listening to the podcasts etc. That support and joint interest has made this a lot easier. Plus, if my wife says "wow, that's ugly." I can just say "Scott did it." 

@Jason Chen Not trying to be defensive on our numbers, neither of us will call this anything close to a home run or a big win.  (Debacle, sh** show, quagmire are words that came to mind at various times.) And when I was reading this for the first time I was thinking "please tell them we didn't end up paying $105!". But you make great points and the education has been worth every extra penny. We did make a few upgrades that may not have been necessary if we were going to flip it and chose more tenant proof products. We consider ourselves pretty handy and have been around a decent amount of construction in our few years, so maybe we were over confident but there were tons of things we didn't see or thought were salvageable that we'll know to be looking for in the future. And I think this is also the value of having an experienced partner that we hear on the podcasts. These are all things they might've been able to point out.  But, like we learned from G.I  Joe: Now we know. And knowing's half the battle."

Stay tuned. Hopefully Scott's next post will be about a great finished product, an intact relationship with a contractor we'll use again, a better profit than we anticipated, and most importantly how he refrained from murdering his little brother during the project. 

(Sorry for any autocorrect typos)

See this reply in the discussion

28 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Washington, MO · Member since 2015 · 30 posts · 14 votes
    9y

    Wow! Awesome post. Love the writing... "scattered like teenagers at a kegger busted by cops."...Made me literally laugh out loud. I too have been wanting to get into a rehab but haven't pulled the trigger. Reading this definitely makes me nervous but at the same time excited. Makes me motivated to just jump into it too. Hopefully once everything is completed you will be able to refinance so your cash on cash goes way up. Maybe check out smaller local banks for the refinance. I know on the podcasts they always talk about how local banks are much more willing to negotiate and work with investors. 

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Clarksville, MD · Member since 2014 · 85 posts · 66 votes
    9y

    @Scott Schaecher - great story and my biggest complaint is we don't know how it ends!

    We're currently in the middle of our 2nd rehab purchases from a foreclosure auction, and its taking quite a bit of time (our first was quick and profitable).  For this one we had to work with an architect to change the roof and add some sqft to the house by turning it into a colonial. Its been a lot slower than expected.

    Probably the biggest difference is we (1) cash buyers so no interest payments and (2) we're partnering with a contractor who gets paid only from the profits.  That slows things down quite a bit as he has to do his other contracts to pay the bills, but our interests are aligned quite well in terms of saving as much money doing the job.

    Wish you the best with this house and please keep us updated!

  • Investor · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 21 votes
    9y
    Thanks! Quite literally just got off the phone with one local bank and calling others today. If you take anything away from my post, it shouldn't be that you should be scared. Quite the contrary. Go into it with eyes wide open that your first project will be a learning experience. Don't be afraid to jump - use your first project as an opportunity to start building that team. I may need to go back to the drawing board and find a new rehab contractor though, not sure this guy is someone I want to continue doing business with if he has any more delays.
  • Investor · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 21 votes
    9y

    @Khaled Helmi I like the agreement to share profits with the contractor, at least in that it better aligns your incentives. Clarifying question... you said you are cash buyers with no interest in payments. Can I ask why? At 4.5% ish for financing, isnt your cash better served acquiring more properties with a much higher cash-on-cash return than 4.5%? At least that's our current thinking. We currently own the property outright, but want to refi to pull our money out to do it again.

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Clarksville, MD · Member since 2014 · 85 posts · 66 votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Scott Schaecher:

    @Khaled Helmi I like the agreement to share profits with the contractor, at least in that it better aligns your incentives. Clarifying question... you said you are cash buyers with no interest in payments. Can I ask why? At 4.5% ish for financing, isnt your cash better served acquiring more properties with a much higher cash-on-cash return than 4.5%? At least that's our current thinking. We currently own the property outright, but want to refi to pull our money out to do it again.

    That's an excellent question and its simply specific to us and our investors as the way we operate is to do deals without debt. Yes you're right the returns per LLC-dollar are going to be less, but our risk is also less as our holding costs are practically nil (utilities & prop taxes) and in a bad market we have the leeway to sell at whatever price we need (i.e. the bank wont take it away from us).

    But again that's simply a rule we have with our investors where we are cash buyers and do not take on debt/leverage.

  • Tampa, FL · Member since 2017 · 240 posts · 153 votes
    9y

    Perhaps I'm reading something wrong here, so correct me if I'm wrong.

    My general impression upon the numbers you provided at first had me thinking that you need to have bigger profit numbers for this to be really worth it. It's your first deal so I understand things aren't going to be perfect.

    Then I read about five paragraphs into the inspection stage, and I started to get kind of worried for you because I think you might've overpaid on this property tremendously without realizing it. I didn't even want to read the rest in-depth so I scanned it.

    When a property is in need of very serious rehab and repair like this one, and you plan on flipping it, you need to make the numbers make sense. A great flip would've been if you had gotten the property for a ridiculous deal, because the deal just has to be like that to be very workable. This might slightly shock you, but I believe you overpaid by about 80% more than what you really should have paid. I think a purchase price of $50,000 would've made more sense and would've given you the necessary cushion to make what you really should make. I hope things turn out well for you and you at least make $5,000 in profit from the flip.

    The problem with major structural problems is that when you sell it, the next potential buyer who previews your property will think "this structure has had structural issues, and it has been fixed. however, there is a similar equivalent property nearby selling for the same $145,000, and it has never had major structural issues that needed to be remedied. why should i buy yours?". And the problem of the issue could potentially arise again even though it's been fixed.

    By the end of the day, I take a step back and ask myself, did the buyer win here, or did the seller win? I believe the seller has won in this situation by more than a small margin. He had a property in obviously terrible shape, and was able to sell it for more than just pennies. He's probably pretty happy with the sale right now because he knows how much it would really cost him to fix it (or perhaps he doesn't have a good clue). At under $50,000, I would say that you guys have the upper hand, and it's all about having the upper hand in every deal.

    When rehabbing properties such as this, the main objective is to buy them for pennies on the dollar. Even lower than $50,000 would've been great, even if the owner would've had a 99.9% chance of rejecting it. You just gotta walk away from that deal. The owner is also kind of silly for listing his distressed property for basically $149,000 which is $5,000 above your ARV. I hope your ARV was excessively conservative because then this deal at least would make more sense.

    Please keep us updated and tell us how things go. This is an exciting thread.

  • Investor · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 21 votes
    9y
    Jason Chen very astute observation on the financials. Yes we agree this wasn't a killer deal. We are confident we won't lose money, and we feel pretty confident in that $20k profit. I neglected to clarify that we used the foundation work to negotiate $12k off the purchase price but it only cost us $3000 to remediate that issue. But your point is spot on - we learned something through this process that will certainly be applied to our next deal.
  • Tampa, FL · Member since 2017 · 240 posts · 153 votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Scott Schaecher:

    Jason Chen very astute observation on the financials. Yes we agree this wasn't a killer deal. We are confident we won't lose money, and we feel pretty confident in that $20k profit. I neglected to clarify that we used the foundation work to negotiate $12k off the purchase price but it only cost us $3000 to remediate that issue. But your point is spot on - we learned something through this process that will certainly be applied to our next deal.

     Ok, the deal can still technically work then. The profits just won't be as fat or ridiculous as the typical "yo i bought a house for $100k, put $30k into it, and sold it a few months later for $200k after listing it for $225k" kind of deal you read on here.

    Even if you manage to make $5000-$10,000, the experience you got from this is worth far more than that, and you got to make money at the same time. What do you think you will LIST the price as when you sell it, and you do plan on using a realtor right?

  • Investor · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 21 votes
    9y
    Jason Chen we aren't flipping - we are holding for long term rental (or maybe mid term to 1031 it up in a few years). I'm conservatively estimating an appraised refinance value for cash out at $155k, but there is potential for surprise upside with appraisal closer to $170 due to recent comps. I'm keeping my estimates conservative at $155k, and we are projecting all in investment at $135k.
  • Tampa, FL · Member since 2017 · 240 posts · 153 votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Scott Schaecher:

    Jason Chen we aren't flipping - we are holding for long term rental (or maybe mid term to 1031 it up in a few years). I'm conservatively estimating an appraised refinance value for cash out at $155k, but there is potential for surprise upside with appraisal closer to $170 due to recent comps. I'm keeping my estimates conservative at $155k, and we are projecting all in investment at $135k.

     Thats even better then. How come you didnt purchase a much cheaper duplex somewhere else? Distance?

  • Investor · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 21 votes
    9y
    In St Louis, any multi fam cheaper than that is probably not something I'm interested in owning or at least something that will take more rehab effort than we are currently prepared to handle. We needed a learning project first.
  • Rental Property Investor · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2016 · 50 posts · 30 votes
    9y

    Solid post @Scott Schaecher - this brother of yours sounds like a smart, handsome dude. 

    Do your diligence folks.  It's amazing what you can find on or about contractors, tenants, handymen, etc. we hemmed and hawed over whether to role the dice on this guy.  If it went as promised - we found our guy for the next few deals. If it fell apart, we arranged the contraxt where if the contractor flaked on us, we wouldn't be too far behind on finishing costs when we hired another contractor (unless the materials disappeared with our original guy).  For now, we're somewhere in the middle, the things he promised are getting done, but slowly, so we're frustrated we don't already have tenants in there. Most people don't know that in many counties and states, civil court records (usually not the documents involved in the lawsuit) are easily accessible online to the public. So do your homework - a little extra effort now can can save a lot of time and expense later.

    Scott also didn't point out that we're both married with little ones and while our wives have not been directly involved in the day to day of this project, they're extremely supportive of efforts and have gotten into listening to the podcasts etc. That support and joint interest has made this a lot easier. Plus, if my wife says "wow, that's ugly." I can just say "Scott did it." 

    @Jason Chen Not trying to be defensive on our numbers, neither of us will call this anything close to a home run or a big win.  (Debacle, sh** show, quagmire are words that came to mind at various times.) And when I was reading this for the first time I was thinking "please tell them we didn't end up paying $105!". But you make great points and the education has been worth every extra penny. We did make a few upgrades that may not have been necessary if we were going to flip it and chose more tenant proof products. We consider ourselves pretty handy and have been around a decent amount of construction in our few years, so maybe we were over confident but there were tons of things we didn't see or thought were salvageable that we'll know to be looking for in the future. And I think this is also the value of having an experienced partner that we hear on the podcasts. These are all things they might've been able to point out.  But, like we learned from G.I  Joe: Now we know. And knowing's half the battle."

    Stay tuned. Hopefully Scott's next post will be about a great finished product, an intact relationship with a contractor we'll use again, a better profit than we anticipated, and most importantly how he refrained from murdering his little brother during the project. 

    (Sorry for any autocorrect typos)

  • Investor · Collinston, UT · Member since 2015 · 53 posts · 28 votes
    9y

    Great story @Malcolm Smith thanks for post. 

  • Investor · Foristell, MO · Member since 2017 · 9 posts · 5 votes
    9y

    Great post @Scott Schaecher. I am a new investor with just two SFR deals under my belt. I love to see posts with real numbers and summary details. I look forward to hearing how it ends.

  • Rental Property Investor · Denver, CO · Member since 2017 · 70 posts · 28 votes
    9y
    Great post! Thank you so much!!!
  • Robb AlmyPro Member
    Investor · Fredericksburg, VA · Member since 2014 · 125 posts · 65 votes
    9y

    This post is fantastic as well as the comments. Thanks for generously sharing your experience- the good, the bad, and the ugly. Best wishes. I hope everything works out well for you two. 

  • Rental Property Investor · Chandler, AZ · Member since 2017 · 39 posts · 9 votes
    9y

    Great post @Scott Schaecher, thanks for sharing your post. I wish you brothers a successful project outcome. 

    Me(OOS) and my brother lives in St Louis are planning to do similar Buy and Hold or BRRRR strategy for MFH for cash flow.

    Keep us updated on your project.

  • Investor · St. Louis, MO · Member since 2009 · 153 posts · 44 votes
    9y

    any update available?

  • Investor · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 21 votes
    9y
    George Moehlenhoff I've been thinking about writing an update. We'll, the project is still ongoing. The contractor is still moving ever so slowly and has given us the excuses recently that: - he underbid this project - he managed to get 4 contracts signed simultaneously which has affected his ability to get things done on time The plumbing and electrical are just about done and the kitchen cabinets have been assembled. But these guys decided to paint walls and assemble cabinets (leaving them exposed on the floor) while carpentry work and electrical / plumbing are ongoing. It's amazing how poorly planned this guy is. I called him yesterday to say that his *** hats installed drywall in the shower that will be tiled. Not acceptable. He said greenboard is OK and I said "first of all, half of it is not greenboard it's standard gypsum board and second of all, even greenboard is not ok for showers. Get it out." We have started hiring other contractors to do some other work at the property that is not in scope for the original contractor, trying to test them out to find one/some that we like. We're giving them smaller jobs like installing glass block windows and re-doing a front porch and some brick work. Figured we should test guys out with smaller jobs before hiring for big jobs like we did the first guy. Problem is that we've paid the first contractor 2/3 of the total, so we are reluctant to fire him yet... we'll never get that money back. But we are setting a deadline that if substantial progress (like all of the doors) isn't made this week, a law suit may be forthcoming.
  • Investor · St. Louis, MO · Member since 2009 · 153 posts · 44 votes
    9y

    Way to power through it Scott!!!!  

  • Contractor · Pensacola, FL · Member since 2017 · 329 posts · 157 votes
    9y

    Don't pay another dime until the contractor finishes.  If you have to cut him loose, that's the breaks.  But he's ahead of you if you are worried about that.  I'm a novice investor, but I built homes for a while before my current job. 

    Anyway, I am interested to know what happened regarding the refi?  You said you can't refi for 6 months after purchase?  I didnt' know that.  So what is your plan?

  • Investor · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 21 votes
    9y
    Absolutely not paying another dime until the project is finished. I stopped by yesterday and saw more work had been done including replacing the drywall in the bathtubs with cement board and the entire basement stone foundation had been drylocked. Still lots to go but it was progress nonetheless. Will keep you posted! As for refinance, we haven’t refinanced yet as we need the rehab to be complete first. Need that rehabbed valuation! So at this rate our 6 months will be up before we even worry about refinancing. It’ll be 6 months since purchase at the end of October.
  • Investor · Northern, VA · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 904 votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Scott Schaecher:

    Hello BP Community!

    I'm writing this post to begin chronicling the learning experiences we've had so far in the purchase, renovation, refinance, and renting out of a multi-family property in the city of St. Louis. I'm hoping that others of you who are considering jumping in can learn something from our learnings and from our mistakes. And of course advice or "hey that happened to me too" is always appreciated!

    My brother and I have each individually owned single family properties for several years now in the St. Louis area. After both of us got hooked on BP, we decided to join forces and start looking to BRRRR it up. We both are professionals with full time jobs, so for the time being - this is a second job. We both own single family rental homes in nicer (ie more expensive) areas of St. Louis County, and they all cash flow decently - but after listening and reading from this community, we decided we probably could do better. St. Louis City (the area roughly 10 miles South, West, and North of the Arch) has a plethora of housing for sale that could use some improvement - so opportunities to build some equity! The biggest problem is finding therightarea. One street can be prime and a great opportunity in a growing area that is hot for millenials, the next street could be a D-class slum.

    There is one overwhelming and repeated piece of advice we (and likely you) hear on this forum. Borrowing from old Nike slogans, "just do it." Borrowing from Steve Harvey, just "Jump." Pick your inspiration - the point is that in order to get action, you have to take action. So we started getting our ducks in a row to take action. But where do you even start?

    We started driving the streets. Looking for neighborhoods and streets that we felt like we could handle. There are areas of St. Louis that are chocked full of Multi-Family properties so those were our focus areas.

    If you know the city, we landed on areas around Tower Grove Park South. The properties could be acquired for between $75K-$200K and many have improvement opportunities to build some immediate equity. It's also an area hot for renovation. It doesnt take much driving to see a dumpter full of house guts from an active reno. They're everywhere.

    OK, neighboorhood in our sights. Tons of stuff for sale, so now it's time to focus. We started an LLC holding company in preparation for acquiring properties.

    The next step was to set our goals. What did we want? We both had experience with single families (both of us kept our previous primary residence as rentals), but we started to believe what we read/hear/see on BP that multi-fam is where the money can be made. So we knew we wanted multi-fam, but how big? I posted a question to BP with some great responses - do we look for small apartment complexes, or start with 2-4 unit multi-fam? Answers to that question were all over the board, but the best advice we thought we heard was to start with 2-4 unit. Get our feet wet with a small multi first before diving into true commercial-class apartments. We set our goals on finding a multi-fam with opportunity for moderate rehab where we could achieve a $20K immediate profit in ARV (after repair value) compared to purchase price + renovation costs, with a total budget of approximately $125-150K. We are looking to hold and rent out, with intent to cash out most of our initial investment in a refinance.

    OK, so now we have our general geographic area and general goals for the property. We had started working with an agent who has a bunch of C-class rentals of his own, so he knew what to look for and what not to look for. Sort of. We scoured the MLS daily, and visited many a house. Some were turn-key, ready for renters... but those aren't quite what we were looking for. In others, you could quite literally see sky when you walked in the front door. Those were more than we were willing to bite off for the first project. We were looking for something where we could gain some equity with renovation.

    Before I go any further, here's the biggest challenge we realized, and frankly are still struggling with. Everyone talks about needing a “team” – a group of professionals to help you with your goals. We had an agent, but we needed a contractor (or contractors) we could trust. This has turned out to be our biggest challenge. Frankly, unless you have family in the business – you need a project in hand in order to start finding and vetting contractors. We started reaching out to various contractors prior to having a project, and if they responded at all, it was generally a “call me when you have a project and then we’ll talk.” I mean that makes sense, they’re busy and don’t have time to shoot the **** with n00bs about hypothetical properties. The problem is that it’s tough to do good rehab estimation without having someone in your back pocket. More on contractors later. We just decided to get the project first, then we’ll find the contractors.

    So we found a property. It was a doosy all right. Two unit multi-fam in the city on a big street called Kingshighway Blvd with a nice size, detached 2-car garage with separate doors (monetizable!). One unit was occupied, the other was open and “recently renovated.” We were not allowed to see inside the occupied unit until a contracted was accepted. We ran the numbers on a nifty estimation spreadsheet I built:

    Purchase Details Financing Details
    Purchase Price $ 90,000.00 % Down 25%
    Esitmated Closing Costs $ 1,000.00 Down Payment $ $ 22,500.00
    Estimated Repairs $ 33,984.00 Loan Amount $ 67,500.00
    After Repair Value (ARV) $ 145,000.00 Loan Points 0
    Total Project Cost $ 124,984.00 Loan Fees $ -
    Potential Upside $ 20,016.00 Amortized Over (Years) 30
    Interest Rate 4.75%
    Total # of Payments 360
    Monthly P&I $352.11
    Total Cash Needed to Close $ 57,484.00
    Cash Flow Details
    Income Future Assumptions
    Unit 1 Monthly Rent $ 850.00 Annual Income Growth 2%
    Unit 2 Monthly Rent $ 850.00 Annual Prop Value Growth 2%
    Unit 3 Monthly Rent $ - Annual Expense Growth 2%
    Unit 4 Monthly Rent $ - Sales Expenses 7%
    Additional Revenue $ -
    Total Monthly Revenue $ 1,700.00
    Expenses Expense Forecasts
    Insurance / Month $ 100.00 Vacancy Rate (%) 5%
    Monthly Taxes $ 91.50 Maintenance (%) 10%
    Water/Sewer $ 69.70 Cap Ex Savings (%) 10%
    Waste Removal $ 57.08 Property Management (%) 10%
    HOAs $ - Vacancy Rate ($) $ 85.00
    Electricity $ - Maintenance ($) $ 170.00
    Other Monthly Expenses $ 50.00 Cap Ex Savings ($) $ 170.00
    Description of Other: Lawn Mowing Property Management ($) $ 170.00
    Total Operating Expenses $ 963.28 Net Operating Income (NOI): $ 736.72
    Total Monthly Expenses: $ 1,315.39
    Monthly Cash Flow: $ 384.61
    Summary
    Monthly Income $ 1,700.00
    Monthly Expenses $ 1,315.39
    Monthly Cash Flow $ 384.61
    Annual NOI $ 8,840.64
    Purchase Cap Rate 9.82%
    Pro Forma Cap Rate 6.10%
    Total Cash Needed $ 57,484.00
    Cash on Cash ROI 8.03%
    Rules of Thumb
    Total Monthly Cash Flow using 50% Rule $ 497.89
    1% Rule (Revenue >1% of purchase price) Pass
    2% Rule (Revenue >1% of purchase price) Fail
    Monthly Revenue as % of Purchase Price 1.89%

    Note – numbers above assume refinancing, maintaining 25% equity.

    It was immediately apparent upon walking into the unoccupied unit that the “recent renovations” were simply some lipstick trying to cover a pig in hopes we wouldn’t see. Odd fresh paint, some clearance mosaic tile slapped haphazardly behind the kitchen counter, and some paneling in the bathroom with a clawfoot tub and a strange smell of mold.

    The owner started out by asking $149K and after 2 months had dropped the price to $129K. After looking at the property, we came up with our number. We negotiated and got an accepted offer at $105K.

    Lesson #1: Cash is king. By offering to pay cash with quick close, the seller turned down other financed offers of more money for our cash offer. We got a good deal just by offering cash.

    We weren’t willing to pay a penny more, someone else could deal with the headaches for that. The property was “as-is” but we made sure to have an inspection clause. Scheduled, done (building and sewer). We also finally got access to the occupied unit. When we walked into the occupied unit, the smell of pot was rough. And we noticed a few cockroaches, but didn’t stick around long enough to count them.

    The building inspector showed up and within 2 minutes before even going inside, pointed down the side of the building. “See anything odd there?” The 2-story brick wall along the building side was very clearly not as straight a wall should be. The back corned was at a bit of an odd angle. Structural problems.

    Our agent pulls us aside and says “the first sign of structural problems, I say run.” We asked the inspector – “If you wrap it up now, what do we owe you?” He said “I only do 1 inspection a day, so if I do the inspection or not it’s the same fee.” Ok hell, finish the inspection then.

    He wraps up the inspection, and the list of issues is substantial. One corner of the house has a serious foundation issue, main stack should be replaced, flat roof needs serious work, major leaks in that moldy smelling bathroom (we found gym shorts wrapped around the toilet drain and subsequently sprayed with flex-seal, OMG). Serious cockroach infestation, substantial tuckpointing needed, 2nd story porch that is starting to fall away from the house, bad windows, multi-tapped breakers with evidence of arcing, and the list went on. The big ones to us were the foundation issues and the main stack. Against our agent’s recommendation, we saw those as big ticket opportunities for price reduction. Those are items that scare people away – including current owners. Maybe we can use it to our advantage.

    So we call a structural engineer to evaluate the foundation, and 7 different plumbers to come bid the plumbing work. Structural engineer says it needs helical piering, likely 3 but worst case scenario as many as 7. We take the worst case scenario, multiply by $1500 per pier and start with an immediate reduction in our bid by $10,500. Plumbers came back with estimates ranging from $4,700 to $18,000. I think some of them just didn’t even want the job. Roof repair needs $1,000. So we use all of this to go back to the table, saying “this place needs a ton of work. Here are the estimates we have so far. We’ll give you $85,000.” We settle on $88K and the roach motel is ours.

    Lesson 2: Get multiple bids, use them to re-negotiate the price. Be prepared to walk if the repair costs are more than the seller is willing to reduce.

    The day of closing was a monster rain storm. We paid cash for the property, left the title company and head straight over to the property. We go inside to find a 2 foot chunk of ceiling fell off the second floor unit ceiling due to roof leaks and water was coming through at a substantial rate. Great. We own the place for 20 minutes and already found a new problem.

    We convinced the first floor occupant to get the hell out, so within 2 weeks of closing he was out as well. And he was kind enough to leave a dumpster worth of **** behind in his unit.

    Lesson #3: It’s worth every penny to find some crew on Craigslist to come empty out and clean a unit trashed by a renter.

    We paid some guys $300 to come empty out the unit and haul off all the trash. They did. Now that the place was empty, we could better evaluate the condition of the unit. And oh my God, the roaches. It makes me shudder just reliving the roach horror. The tenant was so sloppy, he would leave months of takeout containers piled up in the fridge and layer upon layer of food slop on the stove, on the floor, being the cabinets, everywhere. And the roaches loved it. I moved the refrigerator, and at least 1,000 roaches from under the fridge scattered like teenagers at a kegger busted by cops.

    We got some roach bombs, but they just laughed at us. We then said screw it, and tore out all of the cabinets and hauled them to the front yard. Doused them with Raid and posted them for sale on Craigslist. Ripped them out of the second floor unoccupied unit for good measure too.

    Lesson 4: You’d be amazed what people will buy on Craigslist. Posted the cabinets for a few hundred bucks, and they were gone in 24 hours. When the person came to buy them, we watched a roach the size of my thumb crawl out of one of them and into her baby’s car seat. OMG.

    After tearing out the cabinets, we started tearing out all of the wood paneling in the bathrooms… only to realize the roaches were there too. Tore the bathrooms down to studs and got rid of everything. Started tearing stuff our from everywhere in the house. Ripped out a “partially finished basement” that was really just drywall covering up a black moldy mess of a stone foundation.

    Lesson 5: You’d be amazed at how quickly a dumpster fills up. We got a 30 yard dumpster expecting to only need 10. We filled it to the top, and over-shot our weight quota by 2 tons. Wow.

    We started interviewing contractors at this point. We got bids from general contractors, renovation companies, and flippers. Numbers were all over the place – ranging from $30K to $80K for roughly the same scope of work. Now we had to find a contractor that we could trust to do good work but not gouge us on price, but someone who could also get the work done in a reasonable time so we can get it occupied and refinanced and move on.

    We found a guy who does general contractor work, focusing on flips in St Louis (if you’re from STL and want to know the name, send me a note). His prices were pretty good, and he took me to 3 different projects he had ongoing to show me the quality of his work. It all seemed on the up and up, and his quality was good. But there was 1 major problem. My brother/business partner is an attorney. His instincts were to check into lawsuit history, and he found multiple previous lawsuits against this man for unfinished work. We confronted him about this, and he told us what seemed to be an honest story. E used to be an alcoholic and, while he delivered on hundreds of projects, there were a small number that he let get the best of him. He claims to be sober 18 months now, and these problems are in the past. He also claims to have since made amends with those inividuals.

    I called several of his references, and they had nothing but positive comments on the guy.

    We decided to take the gamble and negotiate a contract with the guy. The contract stated that the work was to be completed in 5 weeks, and we would withhold 10% of the total cost until the building passes occupancy inspection. He let us know he’d be going on a 2 week vacation the week after we signed the contract, but his crew would be there no matter what to get the job done. To cover ourselves, we ensured the contract stated that he would reduce total project cost by $500 per week after the 5 week timeframe was up.

    Within the first few days, his crew had all of the windows ripped out and new windows in. The new cabinets were already delivered. We were elated – could we have found just the kind of guy we need on our team?

    Well, then he went on vacation. Pace of progress came to a crawl. For the 2 weeks he was on vacation, very little work was done. We could tell people were coming over still, as random little things were done, but progress was painfully slow.

    After the guy returned from vacation, he waited an additional 3 weeks to even get the permits in place. Once the permits were approved, progress did seem to pick up again. Tomorrow is the final day of week 8, so we’re already 3 weeks past his anticipated deadline. We’re still making progress- main stack has been completely replaced and new rough in plumbing is done, tubs are in, lots of plaster work done, but there is still a ton more work to do. I’ll be honest, we’re concerned about the job getting completed. It’s been a bit of a nightmare. Our only solace is that there are tons of materials at the place, work is getting done, and his price was still a few thousand less than the next lowest bid. So while time is money and delays are preventing us from getting the place rented out in a timely manner, we’re willing to be a little tolerant of delays given the job cost is still cheaper than the next cheapest bid and we’re getting $500/week off the project cost. Still, going with the cheapest isn’t always the best idea.

    I’ll keep this posting updated with the renovation progress. Hoping it will be complete by end of week 10.

    Lesson 6: Pay attention to legal history of contractors. Cheaper isn’t always better, and you can’t teach an old dog new tricks.

    Now that we're getting closer to job completion, however, it's time to start working on the refinance. We learned something from a recent BP podcast that made us both a little concerned, something we didn't previously know. While we paid cash for the property, we were unaware that we couldn't refinance the property for 6 months after closing (at least not with Fannie Mae). That is going to put a bit of a strain on our hope to cash-out refi as quickly as possible in order to BRRRR. Coupled with that, we are also owning the property under the name of a property-specific LLC and that is owned by a holding company LLC. We're also trying to identify lenders that are willing to lend to an LLC as opposed to individuals. We are trying to avoid the quit-claim issue that others have discussed out of concern that the loan could be recalled once interest rates start to rise.

    So, that’s where we are today. We did it – we pulled the trigger and bought a property that needs work. We’re trying to get that work done, and struggling to get our team of contractors, lenders, and professionals together. We knew building this team would be a challenge, but we didn’t quite realize how big of a challenge it would be. 

    How do you do it, those of you that have been successful in similar stories? Tips for building a team?

    Stay tuned for further updates…

    That's a solid post.   I haven't read all the responses as your post took half an hour to read, and I have to hurry back to Facebook and argue with strangers so a little short on time. LOL

    Quick question to you. Why did you decide to use GC? Since you  paid cash for it and didn't have mortgage payments, could you have afforded to sub the work yourself, that way you can not only pocket the profit that GC is making (and not delivering) but also have better control over things? As far as pulling the permits, licensed subs can pull them too.  You don't need a GC for that.

    Is this something you would entertain going forward?

  • Loveland, CO · Member since 2017 · 55 posts · 3 votes
    8y

    Fantastic post @Scott Schaecher. Thank you so much for sharing. Curious if you have any updates from the last 60 days. 

  • Investor · Saint Louis, MO · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 21 votes
    8y

    @Joshua Tikal Thanks for reminding me to come back and continue this post.

    So the drama continues, and we have learned yet another very important lesson.

    Lesson #7: Fire quickly and move on. This is one we learned the very difficult way. If a contractor is not living up to expectations, do not wait and hope that things will get better. The amount of time and lost rent we wasted on waiting on our contractor to deliver was foolish. We finally decided to fire him in November, nearly 6 months after he started the project. What was supposed to be a 5 week project was not only not finished after 6 months, but the quality of work was so poor that we are now having to go back and re-do many, many things.

    We found plumbing in walls that had not been soldered.

    We found a bathtub that had not been installed with any support framing.

    We found electrical running to nowhere, and full circuits non functional.

    We found incorrect grout used in bathrooms that was already cracking.

    We found sewer PVC fittings in walls not glued.

    We found shower valves installed too far back in walls and then tiled over so the hardware could not actually reach the valves, requiring us to rip into walls to re-do plumbing.

    We found they absolutely destroyed the wood floors.

    We found brand new bathtubs had been scratched, chipped, and gouged because they were not protected and people had been standing in/on them and dropping tools in/on them.

    We found exterior walls without insulation.

    We found numerous doors hung crooked or even hinge bound so they didn't swing smoothly.

    We found ceiling electrical just boarded over and hidden.

    We found double tapped circuit breakers.

    We found vinyl flooring laid right over screws sticking out of the old floor, so the vinyl plank flooring had bumps in it clear as day. I mean they couldnt have not noticed it.

    We found the brand new, nice cabinets had been assembled and piled up - unprotected - before demolition had even started. Needless to say, they were not well cared for. Many scratches and gouges.

    We found so much stuff wrong, it would blow your mind. I mean they had to have intentionally done some of the stuff they did. It would have taken effort to do things so incorrectly.

    So the takeaway here is that our denial cost us dearly. We were in denial that we were getting screwed. We had high hopes that something would get better, and work would get completed. 

    So now, we're in a situation that no contractor wants to come in behind someone and be responsible for the unknowns. We have been forced to hire subs and handymen by the hour to come in and address issues, not to mention us having to pour in many hours of our own time as well.

    Things are coming around, we are nearing completion. But we still have probably 2-3 weeks left before we can truly call it ready for occupancy inspection. Absolutely ridiculous. We should have cut our losses and moved on very early on, writing off the losses as we realized them.

    I hope to post a follow up to this story in the next few weeks once we have occupancy inspection completed and we have tenants occupying the units. Stay tuned!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.