Hello,
Im looking for honest advise positive or negative please. Im in my late 20's college grad with a 70K income. I'd like to start investing and possibly pick up my first rental property.
My situation:
As I mentioned I have a great stable job at 70K a year with a nice 401K growing. I still have some student loan debt, Auto loan, and some credit card debt. This 7K I refer to investing is my entire savings. I currently rent at about $700 a month and next year my rent will decrease to around $600.
Im looking for advise as to what direction I should go with investing. Should I try and purchase a rental property now or build up a stronger savings / emergency fund before jumping into investing?
I have lots of research to do I am completly aware but I am just looking for experienced opinions to my current situation.
Thanks!
It sounds to me like you don't have $7k to invest, at this point I'd say you don't have anything to invest. If that is the entirety of your savings you need to work on saving more. If you used that money as a down payment on an investment property and you need to make repairs prior to renting how do you fund that? If you have a major $4k plumbing repair pop up the first month you have it rented how do you pay for that? If you have a big personal expense come up and you suddenly have no savings how do you pay for that?
It sounds like you have a reasonable income so if you work to cut back on your expenses to save as much as you can you can be on the road to investing soon. I wouldn't even recomend an owner occupied multi family right now because you just don't have the cash resererves to do it safely.
Don't get yourself into a situation that you're not going to be able to afford to get out of by investing before you're financially ready. Instead take the time to do research and even start looking to see what's out there so when you're ready you can jump right in.
My opinion is that you should be conservative. That means that you pay off your debt before investing. I would even consider stopping payments to your 401K or at least reducing them to the amount that is matched (if any) until the debt is paid off. You are making $70K, keep your expenses low.
I might add that this method works 100% of the time.
Good luck.
Bill
My advice would be to build up your cash reserves. While you do not need 6 months of living expenses as a emergency fund, you do need some put back.
The only exception I can see for the time being, is if you were able to find a turn-key duplex, triplex or 4plex where the mortgage payment (PITI) would be $700 or less and live in one of the units. That way you have not increased your monthly expenses, and can utilize the rent from the other unit(s) for repairs, expenses with the property and savings.
@N.A N.A , Welcome to BP. My advice is to ramp up your savings and paying off debt. However there is no reason you cannot begin exploring the rental market around you right now. Start looking for what you want to buy, start comparing prices. Learn your market. That takes time. Invest that time now so you are ready to pull the trigger. You will qualify for buying at 3.5% down or possibly less so you are getting close to your goal. Read up on renting, screening tenants, determining cash flow, etc. It will take you a few months to be ready education wise, so keep saving up. When you get to where you have enough for a down payment and 6 months of payments and living expenses you should be ready. Good luck
@N.A N.A I recommend sitting tight. I would keep the 7k and build on it while knocking down the higher interest debt (6%+ rate). While you build the cash reserves and pay down the higher interest debt, I would learn all you can about investing. You can do a TON of the work to buy a place NOW. Then, once you're ready it will be a much smoother and quicker transition.
It sounds to me like you don't have $7k to invest, at this point I'd say you don't have anything to invest. If that is the entirety of your savings you need to work on saving more. If you used that money as a down payment on an investment property and you need to make repairs prior to renting how do you fund that? If you have a major $4k plumbing repair pop up the first month you have it rented how do you pay for that? If you have a big personal expense come up and you suddenly have no savings how do you pay for that?
It sounds like you have a reasonable income so if you work to cut back on your expenses to save as much as you can you can be on the road to investing soon. I wouldn't even recomend an owner occupied multi family right now because you just don't have the cash resererves to do it safely.
Don't get yourself into a situation that you're not going to be able to afford to get out of by investing before you're financially ready. Instead take the time to do research and even start looking to see what's out there so when you're ready you can jump right in.
I was in a similar situation when buying my first home, but, less cash reserves, and slightly lower income. I also received the 8k credit so that helped me make the leap with low reserves. I also made sure to buy a turnkey home. I literally had less than $1k maintenance/improvements in 4 years. I suggest looking for an owner/occupy duplex deal, lowering your car payment, paying off all credit card debt. I disagree with changing your 401k withholding, if your employer is matching 3%. That's 3% free money. Save up 3 months living expenses, 3.5% down on that duplex, then pull the trigger. With how prices have spiked back up, I would take my time and try to find a deal off the MLS.
I agree with Shane. Find a turnkey duplex and live in one side. I wish I had done this 15 years ago when I got out of the Navy. Your rent payment is being thrown away now. I agree to keep the 401k going for the free match. If you are going to pay down debt, start with the credit cards. Don't hurry to pay down the low rate stuff. Since the duplex will be your primary residence, you can get a very low down payment conventional rate mortgage, then you are building equity vs. throwing away rent. In a couple years when everything has settled in and you are comfortable with the land lord game, find another duplex and move into that one and keep the original as a full rental. Rinse and repeat.
Good luck!
@N.A N.A: with your good income and low rent you should be able to save up enough for a down-payment and purchase your first investment property in a lower-priced (but good) market. I would save up as much as you can, as quickly as you can, along with some reserves, then start your selection process on a property.
Continued success!
Normally I'm always the first person to say 'buy now' because of rising prices and hence decreasing returns across the nation, but with that amount of money I'd say sit tight. You'd have to spend the majority, if not all of that, on a down payment and closing costs so you'd have no emergency funds. I personally know the world about needing emergency funds (unfortunately), so unless you have a credit card or something you could put an emergency on, I wouldn't do it. I have always tried to keep a separate "personal savings" and a "rental properties account" just so my rental property emergencies aren't digging into my personal savings. So if you were to follow suit, you currently short an extra savings account.
But you'll get there. Sounds like you have a good head on your shoulders and you'll do great! Just save a bit more.
Lots of advice to sit tight and save more before jumping in. I will respectfully disagree and say that while such savings is low, I started with none at all and look where I am today. So long as you have the education and knowledge behind you, there is no reason to sit tight and wait for more savings, simply buy creatively, use a portion of that savings for direct marketing and get yourself a great deal.
As far as paying off debt, while I agree that is always a good use! The rate of that debt does come into play. If the rate of interest is lower than the rate of return you can get from buying an asset, I say buy the asset and use the returns to pay off the debt, not vice versa. If the rate is higher, then of course pay off the debt first.
How much is the Credit Card debt and what is the rate?
How much is the Car loan and what is the rate?
How much is the Student Loan debt and what is the rate and amortization schedule on it?
If you make minimum payments and only fund the 401K up to whatever the company match is how much extra do you have each month to save or to pay down these debts?
Why is your rent going to go down by $100 at some point? If you have this potential why can't you do it now rather than next year?
How's your credit if you want to buy something?
There aren't really any clear cut answers without some of this kind of information.
How in general I would think:
- Keep the 401K up to the match. That is a 100% ROI, pretty hard to beat that.
- Pay off the Credit card debt. Unless you have some really great rates it is probably double digits interest and likely pushing 20%.
- Car loans are often cheap. I hate them but might not be a smart business decision to pay it off to fast.
- I know student loans have become a big issue for recent grads. Though I still have the impression that the rates are good like still under 4% with the interest being tax deductible. I know mine is cheap and will almost be sad when it is paid off as it is SO cheap. :)
BTW I assume this is still the case but you can get a payment on a nonstandard amortization. When my wife was dirt poor right out of school she got hers set up on a 30yr am schedule. If you can lock in a <4% rate for 30 years with tax deductible interest that will beat even the best owner occupied mortgage.
As far as paying off debt, while I agree that is always a good use! The rate of that debt does come into play. If the rate of interest is lower than the rate of return you can get from buying an asset, I say buy the asset and use the returns to pay off the debt, not vice versa. If the rate is higher, then of course pay off the debt first.
I'd agree with Will and Shane, buy a MFH now with 3.5% down, build a decent reserve, pay off all debt, buy more properties, in that order.
Yup keeping 401k up to match only. Money that can't be taken out until 70's doesn't do you any good. I have a 401k too, but I hope that I don't have to count on my 401k for retiring.
Shaun has a good point. Still a lot of missing information. I don't know your situation. But I can speak about my first home purchase experience (in St Pete, FL).
I bought when I made less than that... I didn't have any emergency fund, and I borrowed money from my parents for the downpayment. It was my "2nd mortgage". And I guess they were my emergency fund too? haha.. There was a studio addition to my house, and I rented out an extra room in my unit as well. I just made sure that I can pay the mortgage even without a tenant.
The result? I bought it before the housing crisis! BUT it's being rented out... lost money, but learned a lot and I barely had to pay much of the mortgage... anyway, I still have it. I don't think the market will crash as much it did in 2007.
One thing though, I've never had credit card debt!! Pay that off first!