Poconos PA X Sullivan County NY

[Kiko Mattoso]

Hi! 

I am looking to buy my first home, an STR one, and I want one that is a max 2-hour drive from NYC and that I can rent on Airbnb 90% of the time and use 10% for myself.

I've been looking in the Pocono Mt area in PA and Sullivan County in NY. 

A lot of people told me Poconos are not a cool place to go but the area is extremely hot, homes for sale disappearing in a week. 

Considering how I'd use it, which area would you say has more potential for cash flow?

I thinking of a 200/280k property. 

Thank you for your time,