Neighbor not providing access even though easement is in deed

Neighbor not providing access even though easement is in deed

Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2019 · 20 posts · 2 votes

I purchased an investment condo in a 3 unit multifamily building located in Northern NJ. The layout of the condo is strange where the hotwater heater is located in the garage (which is deeded to another unit(unit 3)) and the water and HVAC system are located in a utility closet in another unit(unit 1). I recently had an issue where the tenants had a leak and I had to turn off the water, luckily the unit 1 owner who has the water shutoff in his utility closet was home. I had a plumber come to fix the underlying issue and the unit 1 owner was attempting to force me to work around his schedule, even though it was an emergency repair. My tenants had no water to do daily activities for many hours.  

When I closed on this condo, I was told I had an easement to the other unit (and garage) to access my utilities. It seems like the current unit owner is only comfortable to provide access when he's around. 

What can I do? 

I was thinking of asking for a key or having the unit owner sign a document releasing me from any liability or damage that is caused by my inability to access the utility room.  Is there a way to enforce my easement rights? 

0Reply
63 views

Most Popular Reply

Rockaway, NJ · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
6y

What is actually in his unit that you need access to? If it’s just the shut offs, you can have them installed your unit so you can shut it off yourself. It may require several shut offs depending on layout.

See this reply in the discussion

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Rental Property Investor · Member since 2019 · 75 posts · 54 votes
    6y

    Hey! Is he being reasonable about his schedule? Can you not accommodate his requested times? I am sure you can find a plumber who can fit those times?

    Unsure of the legal expectations of the easement and what you are or are not entitled to, but I would try to work amicably with the owner since it will probably come up again in the future, whatever happens, I would send him a thank you card and a little present when it is all over to smooth over the next issues for when it arises.

    Just how I would handle it. If he is waiting weeks I can see that as being unreasonable but if he is asking for an evening so he can be home I would say he is trying to accommodate.

    Hope this helps, best of luck

    Robert Webb

  • Investor · Columbus, OH · Member since 2017 · 861 posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    i agree with Robert above, hopefully just communication and kindness helps. Howerver I would probably also spend the ($300?) to have an attorney look the paperwork over and see what the entitlement really is. There may also be a property manager that has keys? 

  • Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2019 · 20 posts · 2 votes
    6y
    @Robert Webb
    Thanks for your feedback. The latest situation was my tenants had no water and the unit 1 owner was ready to go on vacation and was not comfortable providing access. Luckily, my plumber came in time but it was a close call.  There is no property manager for the building. 

    I'm just imagining a situation where he is not available and a quick decision has to be made. I don't like the feeling of being helpless, especially when I have tenants who depend on me. 

    Originally posted by @Robert Webb:

    Hey! Is he being reasonable about his schedule? Can you not accommodate his requested times? I am sure you can find a plumber who can fit those times?

    Unsure of the legal expectations of the easement and what you are or are not entitled to, but I would try to work amicably with the owner since it will probably come up again in the future, whatever happens, I would send him a thank you card and a little present when it is all over to smooth over the next issues for when it arises.

    Just how I would handle it. If he is waiting weeks I can see that as being unreasonable but if he is asking for an evening so he can be home I would say he is trying to accommodate.

    Hope this helps, best of luck

    Robert Webb

  • Colleen F.Pro Member
    Investor · Narragansett, RI · Member since 2013 · 8k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    6y

    I would try to come to some idea of his schedule limitations and try to work with them. I would also suggest discussing with him some options for access if there is an issue when he is out of town. That is your biggest risk. what if the HVAC quits when he is not home?

    Options if he isn't available: Allowing access to a specific plumber/hvac company you both trust or to you by use of an onsite lockbox. Him leaving a key with a trusted intermediary if he is not available. A more modern option might be if you pay for a modern lock that allows him to issue a code for a limited time if you need access. Now none of these solves the issue of access if he is not comfortable letting people in if he isn't home. You might point out to him that water damage could enter his unit if you don't attend to it in a timely way.  Of course see what the lawyer says. 

    Considering putting the water heater in your unit or using on demand if that could also be an access issue. not sure about HVAC

  • Rockaway, NJ · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    What is actually in his unit that you need access to? If it’s just the shut offs, you can have them installed your unit so you can shut it off yourself. It may require several shut offs depending on layout.

  • Brooklyn, NY · Member since 2019 · 20 posts · 2 votes
    6y

    @Andrew B.

    The water shutoff, HVAC system, air filters have to be replaced every three months.

    The water heater is located in the garage which is owned by another unit.

    In another property, I recently had an HVAC system blower fail in the middle of the night spewing black smoke into a bedroom. That property doesn’t have this nonsense and I could turn off the system myself.

    Imagine if that situation happened in this property.

  • Member since 2019 · 83 posts · 61 votes
    6y

    Depending on the property configuration, I would take two different courses:  A) reconfigure the utilities - relocate hot water heater, shutoffs, etc. to be under your control or B) Negotiate with the adjoining owners to get a key.  You simply cannot be subjected to their schedules for emergencies - I guarantee you in the event of a gas or water leak, for example, if the adjoining owner is at work or out of town, the gas or water company will turn off gas to the whole building if necessary, without their permission, so they might as well give you access to prevent a whole building shutoff for emergencies. Failing that, sell the unit as you cannot properly manage to protect your investment without controlling your utilities.  Next time, avoid properties without access to your own equipment and utilities. 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.