Just closed on St. Croix USVI rental property!! Vacancy fear :(

Just closed on St. Croix USVI rental property!! Vacancy fear :(

Member since 2018 · 125 posts · 21 votes

This might be just the pandemic affect but I'm concerned that there might not be enough renters at the $3000/month price point on St. Croix. We need at least $2500 to cover costs. So we are seeking a $500/month cash flow.

The house is a 4 bedroom in a private neighborhood. Half an acre land with some fruit trees. Washer and drier. Thing is, not a lot of high paying jobs on St. Croix I presume. I'm not really sure what the size of the market is there. How many properties are being rented for $3000 or more? Who is living in them?

I keep searching for listings but what I find is limited or inconclusive. They may not be listing properties where I'm looking. Who knows.

Any tips on the best way to get a tenant soon? A GOOD tenant. lol I was to do Air BnB but Covid changed that.

0Reply
30 views

Most Popular Reply

Real Estate Investor · Palm Beach County, FL · Member since 2017 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
6y

All the questions you're asking are things you needed to research and answer before buying the property. 

What made you pull the trigger without having any market knowledge and without doing any due diligence prior?

See this reply in the discussion

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Investor · Palm Beach County, FL · Member since 2017 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    6y

    All the questions you're asking are things you needed to research and answer before buying the property. 

    What made you pull the trigger without having any market knowledge and without doing any due diligence prior?

  • Member since 2018 · 125 posts · 21 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Brian Garrett:

    All the questions you're asking are things you needed to research and answer before buying the property. 

    What made you pull the trigger without having any market knowledge and without doing any due diligence prior?

     Remember, the point was Air BnB. Covid has killed that. So now my hand is being forced to adjust my business model. What is happening now is unprecedented but we have to get creative and adjust.

  • Property Mgmt/Investor · Marietta, OH · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 13 votes
    6y

    Congratulations Orlando!

    We’ve been on St Croix since 2016 and experienced 2 bad hurricanes in two weeks in 2017 we never thought we’d see.  So be prepared best you can. 

    With that devastation brought lots of assistance and FEMA and contractors that needed accommodations and thankfully we could happily provide. There are still recovery people around there.

    In2016, the bankrupt oil refinery was taken over and is being rebuilt and is about to start production. That has added jobs. Still lots of hurricane recovery work to do but it should be better built for the future. 

    Lots of cool history there and frozen drinks!  If you’re not on island, You need a property manager.  Be glad to chat more sometime.

  • Member since 2018 · 125 posts · 21 votes
    6y
    Thank you! Gotta love 2020 though. I literally closed the week before my contract ended unexpectedly. So on top of everything else, I'm now an unemployed new home owner with no tenant! :)

    We tried to work with Remax but I'm not sure I trust them. I know property management is ripe with a LOT of bad people in the USA, so who knows how it is on the island. They actually discussed $4100/month rent through corporate contracts. So perhaps some of those workers you discussed. A corporation doing work on the island might need housing for several workers. They would stuff 4-5 workers in our house. Charge us $1000/month and charge maybe $3000 every time we get a new tenant. After I asked them some probing questions, they seemed to have gone silent. They also require we spend some maybe $4000 for multiple AC units. So we would be looking at $7000 on top of all the money we just spent on flooring and other work. That might be very close to all our first year profits.

    I'm now considering looking for short term rentals too. No reason to completely abandon the original plan. If there are people looking for short terms, I'll provide it. I'm just not very optimistic about that market.

    BTW, a lot of the opportunity you mentioned is related to what is happening now. What happens when all the work is done and the contractors leave the island? Will I have trouble finding $3000/month tenants? LOL...I just thought to myself "You mean like I'm having right NOW??". LOL

    Originally posted by @Mike Hinton:

    Congratulations Orlando!

    We’ve been on St Croix since 2016 and experienced 2 bad hurricanes in two weeks in 2017 we never thought we’d see.  So be prepared best you can. 

    With that devastation brought lots of assistance and FEMA and contractors that needed accommodations and thankfully we could happily provide. There are still recovery people around there.

    In2016, the bankrupt oil refinery was taken over and is being rebuilt and is about to start production. That has added jobs. Still lots of hurricane recovery work to do but it should be better built for the future. 

    Lots of cool history there and frozen drinks!  If you’re not on island, You need a property manager.  Be glad to chat more sometime.

  • Property Mgmt/Investor · Marietta, OH · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 13 votes
    6y

    Yeah I know   Been there and put in some big $. If you put in ACs, control your electric costs somehow. Meter reads is best. Hoping the work force stays strong until tourists and ships come back strong. I think it will. 

  • Member since 2018 · 125 posts · 21 votes
    6y

    I wonder if there is some kind of online community like this for people in the USVI or maybe Caribbean? Someplace I can speak with many other local landlords. Any ideas?

  • Property Mgmt/Investor · Marietta, OH · Member since 2017 · 29 posts · 13 votes
    6y

    Not that I'm aware.  You can find owners on their vrbo sites.  You're the first STX owner I've seen on BP as a matter of fact.  

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.