Are SFHs worth keeping more than a few years

[Wade G.]

I have tried to figure this out but I get lost in the details.  I have a couple of houses that I have had for over 10 years and a couple for only a few.  I'm trying to figure out if its worth keeping them that long or if its better to sell them a after a couple of years of holding them as rentals and redeploying the capital.  A few details for this scenario:

- houses are bought with equity gains in the beginning

- all repairs (new AC, roof, paint, flooring, etc.,) is replaced at acquisition so house is in great condition

- no intent of ever paying off the house

- appreciation being normal at 3% for this scenario

- cashflow being $400 month, figuring $200 of the $400 for future repairs and vacancy

- sell and pay capital gains tax rather than 1031

So in my scenario I figure most everything has a 10 year life span...AC, faucets, dishwasher, water heater, will need all fresh paint inside and out, etc.  Basically in 10 years the house has to be rehabbed again and 10k -15k spent.  

Selling in a couple of years the house should still be in good condition, should get to keep more of the net cashflow since you only have one set of tenants and avoiding the future big expenses, and you get to redeploy the capital and capture more equity but pay more closing costs and probably some repair costs on new property.

Waiting 10 years you get more appreciation, more mortgage paydown, but more cashflow has to be saved for rehab.  Could probably refi the house and use that money for rehab to buy another property and capture some equity.

I realize there are many variables to this and I hope it makes sense.  I cant keep my thoughts straight when trying to figure it out.  Maybe its a wash when everything is considered.  In my thinking with normal appreciation, good tenants that dont destroy, it may be better to sell the properties after a couple of years and use that money to by another property but only if there is a huge equity gain.  If not buying for huge equity gains maybe just holding the property 10 plus years is the way to go.

[Jeff Brower]

I buy mine with the intention to hold forever. When you gain enough equity you can refi or get a heloc and that money is TAX FREE. Vs selling where you pay capital gains. 

Would you rather sell the goose and take a few golden eggs now or keep the goose that lays the golden eggs forever?