Purchased 1st Rental Prop. In Indiana - Choosing Property Man.?

[Beau Enslow]

I am a new investor located in Utah.  A few weeks ago I read Rich Dad Poor Dad and naturally found my way to BiggerPockets.  I have been working hard and just purchased my first rental property in Indiana.  Closed yesterday and am currently looking for a quality property management company.  How can I find a quality company?  Any suggestions on what to look for or specific questions to ask in order to avoid working with the wrong company?