Accept/Decline Tenant? BP SmartMoves vs. Intuition?

[Joshua D.]

So, I recently ran a background/credit check on an interested tenant. BP Smartmoves recommends to decline this tenant, but on their payment history, they've literally never missed one payment. However, their partner's credit is awful with tons of late payments and collections. They both got declined. Bottom line, do you always go by BP's recommendation through SmartMove? Tell me how you make the call. Thank you.