Breaking Lease- Mititgating this loss

Breaking Lease- Mititgating this loss

Dana Point, CA · Member since 2014 · 17 posts · 0 votes

I need quite of bit of help as this is the first time I'm dealing with a tenant breaking a lease, and I have a number of questions. (I'm a small time investor with only a couple of properties.) Tenant had been living there for over three years before signing a new one year lease and now want to break out after only a few months into this new lease.

My lease agreement basically stated that if tenants leave early, they would be held "liable for the balance  of the rent"  minus any rent I collected or could have collected from a replacement tenant by reasonably attempting to re-rent. Essentially, its the principle that the landlord should make a reasonable attempt to re-rent the place in order to mitigate the tenant's losses.

I know this won't end well and I'll probably end up at California Small Claims Court so I want to have all my bases covered and dot all my i's.

1) When should I start showing the place?

I'm concerned that even if the tenant says they'll move out nine months early and I find a replacement, what happens if the tenant doesn't move out so early? After all, the current tenant has already broken one written agreement so who's to say they won't also break that new date too?

To avoid that situation, should I market and show the place only after the tenant left? Or, will that violate the reasonable attempt principle?

2) Tenant has already started to show the place. How do I respond?

I just got an email today that they want to leave early and they said they had already shown it a few people already. (It turns out they put it up on Craigslist last week before informing me today they want to leave early and the only reason I checked Craigslist was because I wondered how they found somebody already). Basically, they said they found somebody who were 'very excellent candidates' and 'personable' who I would need to meet first. But, I don't even need to meet these candidates to know there's a bunch of red flags around them.


3) Do I need to accept the first non-bankrupt, non-felon applicant?

My attitude has always been I'd rather keep a place empty and wait for the best applicant. When I rented out to this current tenant, I had rejected four other applications who wanted the place even if it meant I could have rented it out earlier. (Two of those applications had obvious red flags, but the other two probably would have been accepted by some other landlords.) For the tenants who've lived there in the past 7 years, their credit scores were 700+ and incomes were more like 4X the rent. 


But, if I hold to those same standards and expect a replacement tenant with similar qualifications, can the tenant accuse me of not making a reasonable attempt to re-rent? When the first tenant that has a 600 credit score with no obvious red flags applies like felony or bankruptcy applies, can the tenant say that if I don't rent to that person then I didn't make a good faith attempt at re-renting the place?

4) What happens if I ask for higher rent from new tenant? Unreasonable attempt to rent?

When this current lease ended, I was expecting to significantly increase the rental price. For various reasons, their current rent is too low. (There's nothing wrong with the place.) Indeed, the tenants advertised the place on Craigslist for hundreds more than they are currently paying.

If I advertise it a higher price, can the tenant argue that I didn't make a reasonable attempt to re-rent the place because I made it more difficult by narrowing the pool of possible candidates at that price?

But, if I sign a new one year lease with new tenant at current price, then I lock myself into rents that are too low.

5) If I get higher rent, does tenant still have to pay for lost rent?

Is there a sneaky reason why the tenant is advertising it for hundreds more each month?

Let's say the current tenant's rent is $2000 a month, and new tenant's rent $2300. And, the place is empty for a month so that tenant would owe me $2000. But, if I rent it at $2300 for the next 7 months, will the tenant not have to pay that $2000 anymore because I made extra $300 for those 7 months to produce $2100 which would cover that $2000 loss?

But, what if I did a special where the new tenant got a discount for the months left in current lease where they paid current rent and then had to pay market rate for the rest of that one year lease?

6) For lost rent, do you take it from Security Deposit?

The security deposit is fairly large, but its still short by hundreds of dollars of the monthly rent.


7) What's upper limit for lost rent from Small Claims Court?

How many months would the court give me for lost rent?

This is probably the worst time to break the lease and find a tenant. If he broke the lease earlier or waited till next year, this wouldn't be such an issue. 

But, if I don't find somebody right away, then I can easily foresee it being empty for the rest of the year with dreaded November and December looming. One year, I had it for rent in November and didn't find anybody till January. 

And, even if I find somebody right now and avoid that scenario, a one year lease will hit end around Nov/Decemeber timeline the next time around. 

When I got the email today, I scheduled an appointment with the tenant this week to discuss this issue and wanted to avoid Nov/Dec by warning/scaring him that the place could easily be empty for those two months if he left now. 

But, since he's already placed an ad in CL, its probably too late for that conversation.

Sorry this was so long but this was my first lease break, and I had a lot of questions.

Thank you for your help.

0Reply
32 views

9 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Aiken, SC · Member since 2014 · 398 posts · 120 votes
    12y

    Sarah,

    Here's my take on the situation.  I'll try to answer your questions and number them how you have them.  Or atleast, I'll give you my opinion, take it for what its worth.

    1. I tend to start marketing a place shortly before the old tenants move out, depending on time of year and how much work needs to be done to get it rent ready.  We only show after the old tenants have moved out.  We try and respect their privacy & want to avoid them trashing the place, plus we do our final inspection to determine what needs fixed, cleaned, repaired, updated etc.

    2. Ask the tenant to remove the CL ad and remind them that they have no right to solicit new tenants or act on your behalf.   Tell them that you appreciate their efforts to get you a new tenant, but that is not their job & you will place an ad & look for new tenants once you have the place rent ready.

    3. No.  Don't accept the first tenant that comes along.  Never lower your standards.  What ever quality of tenant that you have decided that you will accept, stick to that.  If you have to, lower your price, but not your standards.

    Through out your post you are hinting at the fact that the tenants owe your the balance of the rent on the lease.   I ran into a situation a few years ago when a tenant threatened to break lease & move out.  She was upset that the roof got a leak after a tropical storm came through.  I had the contractor's & insurance folks out before it had even quit raining, so I asked her to re-read her lease, reminded her that she owed me the balance of the lease & I would see her in court if need be.  She decided to stay.  If she had moved, at most, I could only really go after her for rent until I found new tenants, or the difference if I had lowered the rent.  I didn't think it would really be worth my time.

    Generally, when I have a tenant break lease, I just remind them that they will lose their security deposit & wish them good luck.  I try my best to stay out of court as it can get expensive & some tenants will start lying like a cheap rug just to get sympathy from a judge, even though our land lord tenant act is more landlord friendly.

    4. If you ask for higher rent, then the only thing that should happen is you get it.  If you do pursue your old tenants in court, as has been explained to me by the lawyers, the best you can hope to get in judgement, is the lost time from the first tenants contract.  If the unit, under the old lease, was $2000/month and it sits empty of 2 weeks, the best you can hope to get would be $1000.

    Enter security deposit.  When the lease is broken, the security deposit is forfeited.  You can take the other tact, offer them cash for keys, just be careful about how to use the security deposit, each state has different rule on how it can be used.

    5. See #4.  Net tenant, new lease.  Unless the old tenant brings you a new qualified tenant to assume the lease.  

    6. Lease broken, security deposit surrendered to you.

    7. Not sure of the small claims court limit, varies state to state.  If you call a lawyers office their secretary should be able to answer that for you.  I think I hit most of your questions further up in other answers.  

    Yes, this is a bad time of year for vacancies, you can be creative, offer to let them leave at the end of the year with no negative consequences, ie you will not take them to court, but still hold on to the security deposit.  Also, remind them that the security deposit doesn't count as the last month's rent.

    Hope that answered your questions.  

    JW

  • Roy N.Pro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Fredericton, New Brunswick · Member since 2013 · 7k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    12y

    @Sarah Lewis 

    Upfront, let me acknowledge that a I not familiar with tenancy law in California

    The answers to many of your questions will depend on what is contained in your lease, and what the tenancy law in California dictates.  However allow me to attempt to provide some answers/observations.

    In our lease the tenant agrees that in a situation where they wish to break the lease, the landlord will be permitted to start showing the premises to prospective tenants immediately.  Reasonable notice will be given and the tenant also agrees to maintain the premises in a clean and orderly state to facilitate showings.

    We encourage tenants to use word of mouth and refer potential candidate to us, but are absolutely clear that any prospective tenant needs to pass through our application and screening process.   We do discourage tenants from advertising the unit on their own and remind them they cannot make representation with respect to rent amounts or lease terms.

    Your application process, screening procedure, and acceptance criteria should be define in writing and you should follow the same process for each complete application submitted.  Your screening process must not violate human rights legislation (Fair Housing Act I believe in your jurisdiction) and should be relatively transparent (read: defensible).   So no, you do not need to accept anyone who does not meet your criteria.

    You ask for higher rent.  Just let the existing tenants know you will be asking greater rent (you can let them know they have been paying below market rent as a concession for their long-term tenant status.  In this particular instance where the tenant is advertising the unit at a higher rent then they are paying, it would seem they are keenly aware of their rent is below market.

    Perhaps I am misunderstanding this question.   Whether or not you get higher rent when you relet the unit should have no bearing on the tenants obligation to pay rent (at their rate) until the unit has been filled.   Yes, the tenant could make the argument that it will take longer to fill at a higher rent, putting them on the hook for a longer period of continued rent payment {this may or may not be true, but again your present tenants are advertising the unit at a higher rent, so they really could not make this argument in good faith).

    The Security Deposit should be used for rent as an absolute last resort.  It is there to cover repairs, cleaning, outstanding utilities and other deficiencies when the tenant moves out.  If you accept to use it as rent, then you leave yourself exposed if the unit requires repairs once your current tenants leave.

    No idea for California.  Here it is $12K (use to be $30K)

    I hope you have saved a copy of the Craigs List advertisement your tenants are running.  It may be a useful reference as you move forward.

  • Huntington Beach, CA · Member since 2013 · 39 posts · 19 votes
    12y

    Jesse Waters & Roy N have posted some good advise.Being a So. Ca. landlord perhaps I can emphasize and fill in a couple of items.

    1)When should I start showing the place?

    When you get a candidate who passes your phone screening and if your rental agreement allows it, and if the current tenant is cooperating and if the current tenant has it in rent ready condition. Otherwise only after you get possession and have put it into rent ready move in condition.

    1A) I'm concerned that even if the tenant says they'll move out nine months early and I find a replacement, what happens if the tenant doesn't move out so early?

    To encourage him you might try an early lease termination fee of 1.5 months rent.

    Since he e-mail informed you he was moving out, write him a letter confirming the conversation, the move out date and offering him the opportunity to schedule a pre-move out inspection within 2 weeks of that date.

    1B) To avoid that situation, should I market and show the place only after the tenant left? Or, will that violate the reasonable attempt principle?

    Since he has not yet moved out, you have no damages to mitigate hence you are under no obligation to make a reasonable attempt at anything.

    2)Tenant has already started to show the place. How do I respond?
    Thank him for his efforts and remind him that any applicants have to pass your phone screening, fill out an application, pay an application fee, be credit checked, criminal background checked, be bad check checked, have documented verified income, be employment checked and meet all your rental criteria.Have the tenant tell the applicants to phone you to start the process.

    3)Do I need to accept the first non-bankrupt, non-felon applicant?
    Nope, you can accept an applicant who best qualifies, even if this means the place stays vacant.

    4) What happens if I ask for higher rent from new tenant? 

    You ask for what you consider market rate rent.Don’t worry about any argument of unreasonable rent.Tenants already acknowledged his current rent is unreasonable.

    5) If I get higher rent, does tenant still have to pay for lost rent?

    Assuming you sue for a money judgment and not just possession, the judge will probably grant you a maximum of 1 month rent.

    Is there a sneaky reason why the tenant is advertising it for hundreds more each month? Sure, he wants you to be eager to accept someone willing to pay more rent than you are now getting.

    6) For lost rent, do you take it from Security Deposit?  

    If he moves out, doesn’t pay the rent and you get a judgment, that’s what you can deduct from the security deposit as well as repair costs to return the unit to the condition it was when he rented it.

    7) What's upper limit for lost rent from Small Claims Court? $7500

    How many months would the court give me for lost rent?

    Probably a maximum of 1 month.

    Don’t over think this, its not rocket science

  • Residential Real Estate Broker · Chicago Suburbs, IL · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 594 votes
    12y

    I would have thought that you would need to find a replacement tenant that meets your same current written criteria, for the SAME rent, for it to hold up in court if you go after them for unpaid rent during the time it took to get the property leased.

  • Investor · Aiken, SC · Member since 2014 · 398 posts · 120 votes
    12y

    @Kimberly H. This is just my personal opinion, but I wouldn't really want to go after a tenant in court, unless its a high rent property & you have longer turn around time.  I might consider it if they trashed the place beyond what the security deposit would cover.  You also have to look at what it would cost you to get that money in legal fees, court cost & your own time.  I am not saying don't do it, just saying that I wouldn't under normal circumstances.  I would (and have), however, threaten to take a tenant to court if they are threatening to move out.  

  • Residential Real Estate Broker · Chicago Suburbs, IL · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 594 votes
    12y

    @Jesse Waters 

    I wouldn't want to have to go after a tenant in court either. But who's to say a x-tenant wouldn't take me to court if I was making them pay for time the place wasn't rented while I was trying to get MORE rent than the lease contract I had with that X-tenant...I doubt that would hold up in court.

  • Real Estate Investor · Carmichael, CA · Member since 2013 · 111 posts · 16 votes
    12y

    I would say don't go to the court route. It's timing consuming and stressful. 

    Tenant helping to find replacement is ok, but u can tell them they need to meet your screening. 

    Just accept the rent in their lease. It's low, but, that's what is agreed. If u want a much higher rent, and couldn't place tenant, I don't think you have any solid ground in court.

  • Dana Point, CA · Member since 2014 · 17 posts · 0 votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Jesse Waters:
     
    Don't accept the first tenant that comes along.  Never lower your standards.  What ever quality of tenant that you have decided that you will accept, stick to that.  If you have to, lower your price, but not your standards.

    Generally, when I have a tenant break lease, I just remind them that they will lose their security deposit & wish them good luck.  I try my best to stay out of court as it can get expensive & some tenants will start lying like a cheap rug just to get sympathy from a judge, even though our land lord tenant act is more landlord friendly.

    I'm not planning on accepting that first tenant, but I wonder if the courts would agree with that.

    Will the courts say that I should have accepted that first applicant, and thus I can only collect the lost rent from when my tenant left to when the rejected applicant could have moved in?

    If my written criteria is that the replacement tenant must have at least a 700 credit score, will the courts say that's too high and that I should have accepted an applicant with a 650 credit score?

    Unfortunately, my security deposit is about $500 short of a month's rent so I am reluctant to let the tenant walk away from their lease with just the loss of their security deposit. (Moving forward, my security deposit will always match a month's rent.) And, on top of it, I'm looking down the barrel of my rental sitting empty through January so I'm looking at a serious loss of rent that a security deposit can't cover. 

    If the tenant wasn't walking away during this time of the year when I knew it wouldn't be as difficult to find a new tenant, then I could be more willing to avoid going to court and let them walk with just the loss of their security deposit as reimbursement. 

  • Dana Point, CA · Member since 2014 · 17 posts · 0 votes
    12y
    Originally posted by @Jesse Waters:

    @Kimberly H. This is just my personal opinion, but I wouldn't really want to go after a tenant in court, unless its a high rent property & you have longer turn around time.  I might consider it if they trashed the place beyond what the security deposit would cover.  You also have to look at what it would cost you to get that money in legal fees, court cost & your own time.  I am not saying don't do it, just saying that I wouldn't under normal circumstances.  I would (and have), however, threaten to take a tenant to court if they are threatening to move out.  

    This would be the first time I went through the small claims court process so I could be wrong and I'm probably underestimating the process.

    But, its my understanding that you cannot bring a lawyer into that venue. So, I wouldn't have to pay lawyer fees, which would quickly add up, and it wouldn't be one of those Pyrrhic victories where any money I won just ended up in the lawyer's pockets. And, I know the tenant has the money so I could collect the money if I won; it wouldn't be like those cases where you're not going to collect money from a deadbeat even if you win the case in court. 

    Other than the court fees, what are the financial costs that I'm not factoring? If I lose, then I don't lose anything. But, if I win in court, then I can win an amount that more than compensates for my time.

    Going to small claims court is a hassle and I have tons of other things I'd rather do. But, isn't it only going to cost me just one day in court to take care of this?

    Hopefully, this threat of small claims is enough to stop the tenant from moving out. If I'm busy, then I know the tenant is even busier and wouldn't have the time to deal or prepare to deal with small claims court.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.