Rental Property Investor · Vineland, NJ · Member since 2018 · 19 posts · 10 votes
I am a relatively new landlord (1.5 years) and encountering my first major issue. I bought a duplex January 2021. The first floor unit had oil heat and I wanted to change it to gas. There was nothing wrong with the heater but it was old and I wanted to get a more efficient source of heat for the unit. I was already contracted to get the heater replaced, just waiting for parts and permit processes.
I guess to keep this short, my major issue is the heater that was in the unit just completely broke and can not be fixed and there is no way to fix it anytime soon. May even be 2 weeks. I brought over electric space heaters as soon as I knew it was dead. However tenant is saying it’s still too cold in the place.
I tried researching for what my options and obligations are but all I could find is lawyer forums for “when your landlord refuses to fix the heat”. And how it should be fixed in 24 hours or “reasonable amount of time”.
So what do you do when you can not fix the heat in a reasonable amount of time?
There's a big difference between "Landlord refuses to fix heat" and "Landlord tries to fix heat but can't find a contractor for two weeks, so he provided me with space heaters."
You don't control when things break or when contractors are available. Do the best you can. In the meantime, keep your tenants warm.
I would continue calling around. Vendors have appointments drop and someone may be able to squeeze you in faster. They would rather do a single large job like replacing a furnace than six small repair jobs.
@Shawn Stiteler You have the right idea with the space heaters, just get one for each room maybe? They should make it warm enough to get by a couple weeks.
If you cant get it warm enough to be habitable, you should put the tenant up in a hotel/airbnb. You could also offer to refund rent for the days heat isn't working, and if they agree, they can go find a place to stay with friends/family.
There's a big difference between "Landlord refuses to fix heat" and "Landlord tries to fix heat but can't find a contractor for two weeks, so he provided me with space heaters."
You don't control when things break or when contractors are available. Do the best you can. In the meantime, keep your tenants warm.
I would continue calling around. Vendors have appointments drop and someone may be able to squeeze you in faster. They would rather do a single large job like replacing a furnace than six small repair jobs.
You've put yourself in a tough situation. Hindsight being 20/20, here's two things you should have done: 1) do your Cap-X immediately after closing. 2) Put your team together before, or as soon after buying properties as possible. The team clearly needed to include a HVAC company that could respond quickly.
If your electrical system can handle it, buy more electric heaters. Do some research and only get the safest ones, least likely to start a fire. Get enough of them so the tenant can adequately heat the apartment.
Talk to your insurance agent about what, if anything, your insurance will cover for temporary lodging for them.
Call all the local HVAC supply houses until you find one that has a suitable furnace in stock rather than wait for one that won't arrive for two weeks. With enough phone calls, you might be able to find a supplier/contractor who can respond faster than two weeks.
You may have to lower the rent for a month and/or help cover lodging.
Clearly communicate all that you are doing, and what the problems are to your tenant so that they don't thing you aren't doing anything and just don't care.
Old homes and space heaters don't always mix well, be careful of this solution. Putting a space heater in every room can be very dangerous on the electrical systems.
@Shawn Stiteler You need to get on the phone and start calling every HVAC company you can find. You should be able to get someone in faster than two weeks, but you may need to pay a premium.
As far as landlord responsibility, you are responsible for keeping the heat operational to a reasonable temperature. I would say 68F in every room is reasonable. One way to apply common sense to "reasonable" is "what would I or my family be willing to tolerate". Never do less for your tenants than that. This may involve temporary heat as you wait for the service call. I am not sure what kind of space heaters and how many you brought over. You may need to buy better or more. Also keep in mind, the extra strain on the electrical system needs to be safe and the extra electrical cost needs to be considered. It will cost far more to heat the property with electricity than oil, so you may need to reimburse the tenant the difference.
The law requires heat, but there is a difference between safe and comfortable.
Tenants will get demanding if they are cold or hot. You just need to explain you are doing everything possible to get the problem fixed. Ask for their patience.
Heat pump window units are your best bet in this situation. Place one in each occupied room and once your issue is solved, keep them in storage or sell them.
From experience I agree with the electric heater fire hazard/electrical o/load issues. We had to replace several 15amp 14/2 outlets burned out completely from o/loaded electrical loads from heaters.
Assuming the electric heater(s) solution works out you may also want to pick up their electrical bill for the month.
And when you talk to them, don't be a Sad Sack about it, instead, seem upbeat about how nice and cozy the NEW Nat Gas heat will be FOR THEM in a few days vs the old radiator system.
Focus on telling them how much they are going to LOVE it.
It will make the waiting time easier for them if you can change their focus.
Depending on the size of the home and the size of the family, I would offer to put them up in a hotel for the time the heat is off if you cant get the needed living spaces warm enough. You can suggest they close off unneeded rooms and put towels under doors etc to keep cold air out.
You should consider paying their electric bill for the time space heaters are needed if that is the route you go. Also I would deduct rent for the time they didnt have heat.
If this is a one bedroom apartment this will be an easy fix. If this is a 4bedroom, 4 bath huge home it will be much more challenging.
Also agree call every HVAC company in your area. Someone will be able to fit you in sooner.
I can't imagine that you can't get it replaced sooner? Call a few HVAC companies. Surely someone can replace the unit sooner.
My HVAC contractor is 2 days out on new units that they keep in stock. If I wanted something fancy, then they would have to special order, but that's not what you want for your rental.
I ask because I mandate renters insurance. Our lease explicitly states I expect their renters insurance to pay for lodging for any unexpected failures that temporarily make the unit uninhabitable. If they do not have renters insurance when it was mandated, then it is on the tenant (I say this but I have a wife that is a softy and typically helps the tenants beyond our obligation).
As others have stated, call many/all HVAC contractors looking for quick options (but verify their feedback on reputable sites - you do not want your haste to result in a subpar contractor).
These types of failures can happen to anyone. If it is not the HVAC it is a major slab leak, or a fire, a gas pipe that is leaking, a tree falls on house, etc. It is why it should be covered in your lease.
BTW I have one property (4 units) that has been red tagged by the gas company 4 times in the last ~1.5 months for 4 100% unrelated but real items (the tags are legit, not nitpick items). It happens. You have a unit without a heater, I have 2 units without a heater and one of those units is without a hot water heater (no gas to that unit - both the heater is out and the gas is off for unrelated item (a leak)). Where this unit is located, a heater is not really a necessity but a hot water heater is. One unit has a gas leak where the gas comes into the structure and a crack in the furnace box (crack in furnace box red tagged when turning gas on after termite treatment, gas to unit turned off yesterday due to unrelated gas leak recognized by the smell). Another unit also has a crack in the furnace box. This is after I already addressed a hot water heater red tag about a month ago (when they were turning things off for the fumigation).
The 3 tagged items still to be addressed will not be fixed this week (probably none of them).
BTW none of my tenants have requested I pay for their lodging elsewhere. Unfortunately if they asked the wife, she probably would provide them some assistance.
@Shawn Stiteler Things can always be worse. At my six unit the boiler just died and can't be fixed. There isn't another unit for 4-6 weeks and the winters here in Wisconsin are pretty cold. 19k to replace and I just had it fixed last winter for 8k. There isn't enough whiskey to ease my pain.
We had a power issue with a house in the middle of December, and of course it took like a week to fix, and FYI these tenants are 70-90 age range.
1) Call every single HVAC company you can find, offer to pay a premium, also check FB marketplace, you can sometimes find independent people who like to do side jobs!
2) Give them space heaters, decent ones, not the tiny crappy ones, but ones that can potentially do the job. I also like @Zee Abbas suggestion of a window unit with heat, not a bad idea-- and if it has cooling can help in the summer when an AC unit dies.
3) Regarding actual heat, find a local motel that you could put them up, and offer to pay that they go there (ours was like $50/night), as if they are paying rent -- they are paying you to make sure they have a livable/habitable place. The other option is instead of paying the hotel, tell them you can pay them instead that $50/night, or whatever pro-rated rent per day off is when they have heat. That's IMO the fairest and best option, and watch them start having more patience and understanding when they know they aren't paying rent. It's all about money, and at that point-- it's THEIR choice.
Our tenants picked the 2nd option and stayed with a friend, and enjoyed the discount. Don't stress yourself out, do it step by step, document everything and you'll get through this. As long as they know you care, and are dealing with the situation the best you can, it will be fine-- but make sure they are getting $$$ pro rated rent back for the inconvenience or put them in a hotel.
We just had a snowstorm here in Md . I got a no heat call , then they told me the electric was out too . ( face palm ) . I tell them when they fix the wires it will come back on . The tenant asks " what about a generator ?" . I told them that they can go buy one if they want . But its on their dime .
One thing you learn when you are landlording long enough is to be proactive. Looking back on my first few properties I only fixed what was broken. I did not concern myself with the design life of things: every component has a life expecatation before it needs replaced. 30 year roofs last 25 years and you can wait until you have water damage or do something before. We dealt a lot with plumbing issues on 1960's properties, fixing one leak at the time, and again and again - which is both agrevating and expensive.
Eventually I arrived at the conclusion that it is long term better (and less expensive) for me to just replace the whole plumbing during rehab top to bottom. It's better to have it all pex than deal with issues and expensive service calls.
Same goes for heating and cooling. We are in Milwaukee so we have cold winters and it gets hot in the summer - contractors are alwasy super busy the first few weeks after it hits 80F in the summer and the first few weeks after temps drop below 30F in winter.
Yes, you might be able to squeeze another year out of old equipment, but I'd rather shop for the best deal and upgrade HVAC when I have time, perhaps in the HVAC off season which is late spring or early fall when contractors have time - instead of scrambling in January and paying a premium for the repair and a hotel for your tenant!
Only your Insurance Carrier can make a determination of whether or not a loss is covered by the policy. Check with your agent to see if it is worth submitting. My guess is, unless you have equipment breakdown coverage as part of the policy (an option from some carriers), that this will not be covered but your agent will know your coverage better. Unless it is a covered loss, the loss of rents are normally not covered. That means what you choose is out of pocket.
If the electrical heaters are going to be a risk of electrical problems or fire, compare the lost rent or hotel costs against your deductible. Better to pay for them to stay else where than deal with a fire claim or an electricians bill
Lots of great advice here. The only other thing I would add is to keep a paper trail. Document everything that you're doing, communicating, or offering to the tenant via email. Even if you have a phone call or face-to-face chat, follow up with an email recapping everything you just discussed. It sounds like you are being proactive, but just in case a legal issue did arise, you want to have that paper trail in place.
Depending on temperatures in you area, this may not rise to level of "emergency" maintenance. For example in North Carolina, broken heater or AC is only considered an emergency if temperatures drop below 55 or rise above 85. The climate in your area may give you a bit of buffer on the "is this legal or not" question.
But as @Nathan Gesner mentioned, there's a big difference between offering space heaters as a temporary solution and "not fixing the heater." You should be fine.