Hi I was hoping to get input from the forum about a question my FIL asked me.
He owns a SFH in Bay Area that he has owned since around 1980 with significant capital gains likely worth 1.1 mill and he paid around 72k for it. He doesn't live in the house and currently retired living off social security. The rental income from the house isn't that significant and its a headache to maintain so he wants to consider selling it. Whats the best way to sell a property like this to minimize taxes, his CPA has told him about Charitable investment trusts, his mortgage guy told him about reverse mortgage, and his financial advisor is trying to sell him on a Private REIT that he can 1031 exchange into so he's confused. I was wondering if people in similar situation have any input on trying to minimize taxes when selling a property like this.
He needs to get connected with someone that can ask him about his goals (including legacy planning), analyze his statement of net worth and tax situation, etc. Some of the preceding comments might work in part or entirely but as any CPA will tell you "it depends". It sounds like he has plenty of directions to go in which is a plus. Those professionals you mentioned should all be working together and not individually. Communication usually is the problem of why things do not get done properly as the smartest folks are not in the room at the same time to hash things out.
@Ali Arkam That's a lot of tax to leave on the table without a 1031 exchange. But definitely time to move into something that fits his position in life better. As @Taylor Dasch said, the 1031 is probably his answer. A charitable remainder trust is fine if he has a particular affection to a charity. But usually the financial difference in these is that the tax savings by doing them is offset by the gift. So it's the charity that really benefits. I highly doubt there is a reit that qualifies for 1031 treatment. But your friend is right to be looking that direction.
He could 1031 into some cash flowing rentals. They would give cash flow and depreciation.
Another option would to to 1031 into a syndication. Most syndications aren't set up to 1031 into but with 1M there are a few that will. I actually found one that'll take 100k. He'd have to understand a syndications and make sure he found a good seasoned syndication before he turned over that much cash.
If he's looking for another active investment - 1031 into a multifamily deal that he purchases on his own, and has to oversee.
If he's looking for a passive investment - there a few options. Some syndicators allow for 1031 funds into their deals, you will have to find one that does and generally they require large check sizes to do so . The other option is a DST. You can connect with a DST broker/provider and they will source deals and do the legal side of things to allow for a 1031 into a syndication style deal.
He needs to get connected with someone that can ask him about his goals (including legacy planning), analyze his statement of net worth and tax situation, etc. Some of the preceding comments might work in part or entirely but as any CPA will tell you "it depends". It sounds like he has plenty of directions to go in which is a plus. Those professionals you mentioned should all be working together and not individually. Communication usually is the problem of why things do not get done properly as the smartest folks are not in the room at the same time to hash things out.
I agree with all of the posts on here so far. as @Jeff Nash mentioned, it really it just depends on his goals. There are a lot of options, especially if he is charitable. I would probably look at a mix of 1031 and charitable options. For instance, he could look to 1031 into 2 or 3 DSTs and then gift one of the DSTs to charity and time the gift with other taxable events.