To Own or Rent: Combining the Best of Both Worlds! - Part 1

To Own or Rent: Combining the Best of Both Worlds! - Part 1

Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2015 · 35 posts · 18 votes

Is it possible to combine the benefits of owning a home with the benefits of renting?

At first glance most people would say no because these things seem to be at opposite ends of the spectrum. Personally I'm not convinced; and whoever comes up with a working model (not even the best model) and implements it correctly WILL be remembered as a trend setter in modern real estate.

This could change everything.

First off, what are the benefits of owning?

1. The perceived benefit of your primary residence being an incredible investment. This is an area of real estate where most people are believing and repeating a lie. Of course you CAN make a significant return off your primary home, but this is anything but a given. Sadly, in 2008 millions of Americans learned this in a jolting, financially crippling way. However, I don't want to totally discount this aspect of real estate ownership.

The model of the future will incorporate predictable and steady returns the way people currently hope things will work out.

2. Customizability. I want to make my home special and unique just the way I want it. However, most people don't really know what they want which is why we hire decorators and interior designers to educate us.

The model of the future will also incorporate the ability to customize your dwelling within reasonable parameters that offer guidance and help you make a decision that is best for your lifestyle.

There are obviously additional benefits of home ownership, but for the sake of my argument I'm going to stop with the above two which I think are the most important.

What are the benefits of renting?

1. Little to no financial risk. Because people do realize that real estate returns aren't always guaranteed, renting provides a hedge of protection against buying at the top of the market and selling at the bottom. Your landlord shoulders that risk.

2. Ease of use and upkeep. For many, maintaining your home isn't what we look forward to doing on our weekends. Not having to worry about the time or financial burden of maintenance is a HUGE benefit of renting a property.

3. Ease of movement. When you rent a property the only thing that ties you there is the length of your lease. If you hate it you can leave with very little financial risk or annoyance.

So how do you combine the benefits of both renting & buying? I have a model that I think would work and I'll post it tomorrow! 

What do you think though? Would being able to enjoy many of the benefits of both models be a real estate game changer?

0Reply
18 views

7 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    10y

    You missed the major benefit of owning:

    Stability.  Nobody can EVER kick you out of your house.  For families with children in school, this is often paramount.  

    Btw, life estates are a good middle-ground when both parties can meet their needs/goals.

  • Investor · Appleton, WI · Member since 2012 · 1k+ posts · 464 votes
    10y

    Seems as if the target market would be very narrow. If you have enough money then the benefits of renting are irrelevant. Many don't have the means to purchase much less customize a home purchase. So upper middle class would have to be the target market. They would have to make enough to pay the pemium to get some of the benefits of ownership you highlighted while still carrying the risk of renting in the stability aspect. To have a marketable product, they would also have to pay the premium for the extra services provided. If it is simple to explain and can pull on the heartstrings in someway it might gains some traction. It will be interesting to see your proposal....

  • Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2015 · 35 posts · 18 votes
    10y

    @J. Usually I find instability in a rental situation is 90% of the time on the head of the tenant. I've never arbitrarily excited someone or not let them renew a lease. I WANT them for as long as they want to stay and are an asset to my community. If you fall behind on rent you get evicted, but this is the same if you fail to pay your mortgage or taxes.

    Obviously if a landlord isn't doing what their supposed to do and maintaining a property that's a whole different issue; one I'm leaving out for the sake of this discussion. To create something that forces a large shift in this space you would have to have landlords taking care of and maintaining their properties.

    I don't see life estates in their current form becoming a widely used way to spread risk, save on taxes, etc.

    Thanks for your input!

  • Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2015 · 35 posts · 18 votes
    10y

    @Kyle. Even with plenty of resources I think the benefits of renting (particularly not having to be directly related to all upkeep and maintenance) still apply. I currently live in and own a condo; which is perfect for my present lifestyle.

    The goal of what I'd like to see is giving people the ability to have some of the customization and options that are usually only available to upper middle class to lower income segments.

    Is it possible? I'd like to think so!

    Thanks for your input!

  • J ScottPro Member
    Moderator
    Investor · Sarasota, FL · Member since 2008 · 18k+ posts · 17k+ votes
    10y
    Originally posted by @Christopher Gill:

    @J. Usually I find instability in a rental situation is 90% of the time on the head of the tenant. I've never arbitrarily excited someone or not let them renew a lease. I WANT them for as long as they want to stay and are an asset to my community.

    Does that mean that -- if your tenants want to stay -- you don't raise rent on them?  

    When renting, you get no benefit from an improved market.  If rents rise, tenants either pay more or move to someplace with a better value.  Only the landlord gets the benefit of the improved area/market.

    One of the benefits of owning a home is that, if the area improves, the homeowner gets all the benefits of the improvement without paying additional monthly housing expenses (the mortgage doesn't increase).  Homeowner takes the risk, but also gets the rewards.

    Does your idea take this into account?

  • Realtor · Charlotte, NC · Member since 2014 · 935 posts · 467 votes
    10y

    @Christopher Gill ok, it's the 27th.

  • Investor · San Antonio, TX · Member since 2015 · 35 posts · 18 votes
    10y

    See the second part of this discussion here!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.