Flipper/Rehabber · New Orleans, LA · Member since 2019 · 18 posts · 4 votes
I don’t know where to start! For the past few months i have been educating myself on buy and hold properties. There is so much controversy on whether buying single family rentals is better than multi family, vice versa.
I’ve heard horror stories from both and also just as many success stories. Currently i have no rentals, but i have some fix and flips under my belt. I just want to try my best to start off on the right foot. Most people are telling me to start with single family just to get my feet wet, but these are also people with little to no experience as well, so that’s why i am here.
Should i start with single family since it’ll be my first rental? Or is it the same work with just a bigger dollar amount for multi family? If i do get multi family, i will be looking into a Property Manager after so many doors are in my portfolio. I’m looking forward to your opinion, thanks!
@Kirk Frickey my suggestion is just START! You seem to be going through a perfect example of analysis paralysis. Your first deal will more than like NOT be a grand slam. It is more important that you simply complete the first deal. Go small and complete a SFR. Get your jitters out. Then scale as fast as you are comfortable (or uncomfortable) doing. Take action brother. You got this.
Do your numbers and compare them side by side. A duplex to 4plex will usually have better cashflow (leveraged 25%) but I dont know your market.
I wouldnt tie up 85k to make 6-800 a month net unless you have more capital to keep flipping and ability to purchase if deals come up.
With multifamily(5+ units)id say stay away from anything under 10 units but again depending on your market. My market the cheapest rent is 1000 bucks for a studio/1300 for a 2 bed.
Keep in mind with multifamily loans your net worth has to surpass the value of the property and anything under 30 units wont cover management expenses too well. Also will need reserves you cant really touch (about 6 months piti usually)
If i were you i would do a side by side of your house all in 85k compared to a duplex financed 25% and see where you make more money. Keep in mind when you raise rents on a 2-4 unit 25-50 bucks it helps alot more than doing that with a sfh.
If i had to do it all over again id buy only duplexes + and scale to larger multifamily asap. I started in the construction side too. Huge edge doing my own inspection when i walk the property and offer no inspection contingency. Good luck.
@Javier D. My advice is start where a person can. I think the term MF is so broad that when mentioned one person thinks 50 units and another person thinks duplex. :)
I'm getting income from 30 plus SFH presently. If I would of waited to do a 20-30 unit apartment building I would still be waiting. I personally don't see 2-4 unit buildings as MF, whereas it is in the technical sense a MF. If Duplexes are the MF folks are talking then yes a beginner could probably take it down. If 50 unit plus is MF then it is not logical to expect someone with no solid income, funding, or experience to jump right into that arena.
Most new born babies learn to crawl before they run track.
I Use mulifamily as your base monthly cashflow ...and sprinkle it with single family with lease options / rent to own and seller financing to get max ROI
I disagree with you, I had no money, capital, or experience and I still bought a duplex. Duplex = multifamily = house hacking = best choice for a beginner landlord IMO. I gained equity, rolled it into another multifamily and I cut my living expenses in half. It's called BRRR - rehab multifamily houses and rent them out instead of flipping single family houses. You'll go broke just like 90% of the flippers on here who figured out flipping isn't a viable long term option.
Also, if you're going to give some random group $23,000 for something you can learn on your own or by googling it then you're better off giving it to me or use it as a down payment for a multifamily. By the way, I bought my first house for $22,500 all cash and made $30,000 in equity. Food for thought as you're writing a check to that group.
Go listen to the podcasts when they have grant cardone on the show. Despite my opinions about cardone that podcast really has made me think differently about a few things, one being multi family over single. Previous to this I would hear Brandon talking alot about scaling, but it never really resonated with me until listening to those two podcast. I belive they are episodes 108 and 250
@Brandon Shackelford I am in process of purchasing a single family home in the east. What part of the country do you get those kind of numbers for a multi family?
@Account Closed I wasn't just over broke. I had a full fledge fix and flip business working 4-6 flips at a time. But it was one big headache and stressful. To many variables to deal with. Not to mention the amount of time spent managing these projects. For me the transition was smooth as a value add investor. Just taking on many more units. Over the years I've been able to develop relationships with capital partners who would partner with me on fix and flips. We just simply transitioned to the multifamily space. But it wasn't overnight. Getting a solid foundation for education was key. We're closing on 88 units end of September.
@Nick Rutkowski I didn’t give some random group 23k. It appears you have made some good choices in real estate ;)
I think where the confusion is coming in to this discussion is the term MF being so broad. When I think MF I don't think duplex. If some people are getting a loan on a 1-4 unit then I guess they can brag about MF. If a SFH house is baby step then so is a duplex. I have made more off some of my SFH than I would with a duplex and I have one tenant that has been in place for close to 13 years.
My point was trying to show the stages of real estate are typically baby steps in the beginning. As far as your $22,500. all cash purchase on your first home that was a smart move, but still a baby step.
Your saying you transitioned into MF, that was the point I was trying to make. The gentleman that started this post has a total of two flips under his belt.
@Kirk Frickey it all depends on your end result, what is the lifestyle that you want? Single family properties may require majority of your time and multifamily properties will give you more hands off experience because of the management in place. For example to have 100 units in your portfolio, you will need 100 homes and that’s a 100 new loans, while multifamily, it could be just 1 property with one mortgage.
As many people have told you, there are many advantages to investing in multifamily over investing in a single-family home. Another advantage is that you do not have to use your personal income and personal debt to qualify for a loan. The property debt services the loan (exception is if you go to the local bank, they will do a global debt service). You still would need to qualify with your credit, credit scores and liquidity for the down payment, the closing cost, and reserves. If you are attempting to get a Fannie or Freddi loan, you will need your networth to be equal to the loan amount, ( Most lenders will not lend Fannie and Freddi unless the loan amount is $1MM+ )
@Kirk Frickey it depends on what your goals are. Do you plan to own apartment buildings in the future? If so, you don’t want to waste your time on single family rentals. The two businesses are very different and owning and managing a single family rental does not equate to being able to own and operate apartment buildings. I started with single family homes but once I switched to apartment buildings I realized that I would have been better off having started with apartment investing from the beginning.
@Kirk Frickey Hi Kirk, personally I started with SF homes, then transitioned into MF once I had built up a sizeable amount of capital. "Cash flow" didn't mean much to me when I had 20k to my name (ie 20k invested @ 10% = $2,000 yr or $166 a month). Big deal! For many years, I worked a full-time high paying job and did SF real estate deals while living on nearly nothing, as far as expenses go. At the point of gaining around 500k in investable cash....cash flow seemed much more intriguing (ie 500k invested @ 10% = $50,000yr or $4,166 a month). At that point, I started investing in apartment syndications for cash flow and the rest is history. Food for thought. Best of luck!