Rental Property Investor · Saint Paul, MN · Member since 2020 · 11 posts · 6 votes
Hey, I am starting too look at investing in the Twin Cities as I am from here and don't have a desire to start long-distance investing yet. Considering the past few months in the cities, the neighborhoods near downtown multi-family properties are still selling quickly, over-asking. You can still find cash flowing investment deals in the mix, but Im curious if other investors in the area are selling and waiting for what happens in the next 12 months or still buying with the low rates. I look at these multi-family duplex units selling for $340-$400 and it seems crazy to me. I would love to hear any local investors thoughts. Take care.
You are quoting a housing and anti eviction organizer to form your opinion of the stability of an area to own rentals? His actual job is to advocate for renters/home ownership for those with less. It's a great mission but most in that sphere can not afford to buy. Anyone can have an opinion and get it printed-
@Brittany Shearer I think it's hard to argue that the twin cities isn't a great rental market if you can get into it, has great fundamentals, it's appreciating while having the stability of a midwestern market. Getting in is the tough part. From what I've seen anything on the MLS below 90k a unit is absolute trash, and at that price you're already getting into bad neighborhoods. I really believe at this point you need to look for off market, I recommend Brandon's video: 27 Ways To Find Real Estate Investment Deals.
If you're wanting to stick with the MLS, you might consider nearby St Cloud which can work and has a university, etc.
Trying to find a small multi family in one of the desirable areas like NE, uptown, etc would be akin to trying to do that in the Bay Area, which is to say a near impossibility.
I would read up on the local renter protection ordinances that were just passed. My personal opinion is that inside the Twin Cities is far less attractive for investment than it was before these went into affect. I haven't sold anything recently, and instead I'm holding pat on my investments in Minneapolis and Saint Paul.
@Noah Chappell thank you I appreciate your recommendation and I will take a look at brandons link you sent to me. Iv been reading many books and listening to podcasts, we are ready to go, but I just don’t know if now is the right time. I have been doing my own hunting and had some success finding potential sellers, but nothing that’s been a deal worth diving into. Working with an agent that also specializes in multi-family and bring some leads off the mls, but everything has been expensive and sellers have the upper hand 100% right now agent or no agent, they know they can list it themselves of Zillow or mls and still get multiple offers.
@David Barnett thank you, yes Iv been reading and talking to a few local property management companies and it sounds like St. Paul is now enforcing many of these renter friendly laws now too. That’s part of the reason I am a little nervous to make the jump into investing in the twin cities. To think about buying and holding a property for 15+ years is a little scary in the cities with how quickly things have changed in just a few years. We have family in Iowa that are big developers and apartment investors in Ames, IA and although it’s not ideal for us to do the landlord thing a state away, their laws are more landlord friendly, and it may be something we should consider more. Thanks again!
@Larkin Adey thank you! I totally agree, it is a crazy time to dive in and thats why I’m being cautious jumping in. Im an impatient person, so it’s hard for me to not just want to jump in when we have the resources and time to do it, but I don’t want to be dumb. The few people I know who are even part-time investors of a few properties are sitting on the sidelines right now waiting for 2021 to see how it all plays out. Appreciate your insight!!
I think the Minneapolis and Saint Paul have their attractions for reasons stated above (great appreciation, strong job market, high desirability). But also as others have stated high price points, and increasing tenant "friendly" laws are reason that I am not looking for pure investments in minneapolis or saint paul. I am still considering house hacking (if I can get my damn financing straightened up) as a way to live in the area for cheap and build equity. Hope that helped and would love to chat more over zoom or coffee.
@Brittany Shearer You're right it's absolutely a seller's market and even the off-market "deals" are priced high right now. That being said, I personally (no crystal ball) don't see the Twin Cities market taking a huge hit given all the reasons @Account Closed is still buying this year, there are still opportunities. Best of luck to you!
We worry less about the "timing" but rather is this a good place to own rental property. We keep coming back to-YES. So we continue to buy, selectively sell, and later this year build another triplex.
Have there been some changes to rental rules. Yes, does it impact me, not hardly at all. I still do my criminal background checks and use credit worthiness to approve potential tenants. I just follow the rules but still can be judicious.
There are still deals out there whether on the MLS or off market. If it's not a good deal, offer less. I just got a property for $40,000 less than asking and got another after someone offered about $30,000 more than asking than slammed them with $25,000 in reductions from the inspection- seller walked right back to me.
It's easy to find reasons not to buy and you shouldn't buy if you feel this isn't a good market but MPLS still has some of the lowest vacancies rates in the country. We strategically only buy high quality properties in high quality areas. The prices are more but we still make a return and we insulate ourselves from the places that will be affected most by Covid/unemployment ect.
I should add, I primarily own almost all of my rentals within 2 miles of my house as well- I don’t understand buying something a state away because it has less restrictive rental rules. Just thinking it’s a lot easier to manage your property when it’s close by and not hours away? I also realize my strategies aren’t for everyone
Minneapolis appears to be going off the deep end in many respects. I'd be leery about investing in light of the activism for renter's rights and snowballing government oversight and intervention. The Twin Cities is a sprawling area with much opportunity, so staying out of Mpls. proper may be a good idea. As your post identified the "Twin Cities" as your area of interest, I'm assuming you mean the region, including suburbs. I see some other posts from those enjoying success in Mpls., but for someone starting out, not so sure. A recent editorial in the Star Tribune written by Owen Duckworth of the Alliance for Metropolitan Stability regarding evictions in MN ended his piece by writing, "And to cure chronic housing inequity, we need systemic changes that put power and ownership in the hands of tenants, not private landlords." Whenever I hear the phrase "systemic changes", I listen very carefully.
You are quoting a housing and anti eviction organizer to form your opinion of the stability of an area to own rentals? His actual job is to advocate for renters/home ownership for those with less. It's a great mission but most in that sphere can not afford to buy. Anyone can have an opinion and get it printed-
When looking at and considering investing in the Twin Cities market, if your meaning of "Twin Cities" is Minneapolis then look no further than Mr @Bruce Runn, he is what I would say a very definitive Minneapolis investor success. If you can't grasp or understand what Mr Bruce states in his post's then Minneapolis/ St Paul investing is probably not for you.
Now if by Twin Cities your speaking the Mpls/St Paul surrounding, well then it's like saying does Bridgeman's have a decent ice cream? (fyi there is 84 flavors). Without doubt there is a good deal area in the Twin Cities for literally every and any strategy at any given time, only question is are you going to know how to do it, find it and complete it. The Twin Cities is one of the biggest metroplex's in the country yet I hear these foolish questions as if it's some podunk town of 10k. There is literally about 4 million people in the Twin Cities, Chicago is 2.7 million, to help put things into relativity.
So please understand, asking a singular question about the Twin Cities like is it a good place to invest is just ridiculous and impossible to answer, it's YES, NO and all points in between. Try picking a little more focused area, say 1 million or less people for starters.
Bruce, I guess the thrust of my point was concern about the prevailing winds and rental climate in Mpls. Doesn't seem to be going in the right direction for the landlord. That said, thanks for your reply and I wish you continued success in the City.
I enjoyed your comparison to Bridgemans ice cream 🤣 it’s very true. Yes, I get your statement and really I just wanted to ask the question and get a discussion going as I haven’t found much on BP discussing the recent months of chaos in the cities. If you want exact I would say northeast, west 7th and south east pockets of Mpls close to the river, which are all holding strong from what I see. If you have areas I should be considering I would love to learn.
@Bruce Runn thanks Bruce, you must be well respected as so many enjoy your feedback. Would love to hear where you like to buy. I appreciate your feedback all great 👍. The changes in the laws are not scaring me away, but I definitely want to know what I’m doing before jumping in. How many units do you own and do you self manage? It sounds like you do but just thought I would ask. Is there a certain criteria you like to see on your analysis of a property before pursuing? I’d be curious to learn more. I’m just glad to hear from some of my fellow Minnesotans!
I'd recommend connecting with Alyssa and Scott Hoefler with the Millennial Investor Focus Group on Facebook as they do a great job putting on Meet ups and I'm impressed with both of their knowledge they have of the market. If you join that group, you can see the video of the August meet up I did a couple weeks ago. I try to share what I do/have learned and give some bio info
I've been doing this for 10 years and self manage all my properties as that is how I advocate that most should learn how to do this business as you get to know your properties much better if you tag along/see the issues first hand. You also get to know your tenants much better and establish a relationship/can talk directly with them to solve small problems. My main criteria for buying is cash flow as that solves most issues. We always look to add bedrooms/expand the rent/fix up as that is part of my "value add" I can do. I realize that is not as easy for everyone but it's the main way we have gotten to appreciation-buying properties that need a lot of TLC and doing it ourselves. That then makes it an attractive asset and allows it to cash flow/get renters much easier.
Is Minneapolis really that crazy of a market? No there aren't any 1% deals available on the MLS, but Zillow represents just 0.001% of the properties available for you to buy (not real statistic haha). Unless you've sent mailers out to owners of vacant properties, walked most of the neighborhoods looking for distressed houses and reached out to owners, etc, I don't really think you can determine what type of market this is. I lived in Boston for many years, and by comparison Minneapolis is a sea of opportunity..
Is Minneapolis really that crazy of a market? No there aren't any 1% deals available on the MLS, but Zillow represents just 0.001% of the properties available for you to buy (not real statistic haha). Unless you've sent mailers out to owners of vacant properties, walked most of the neighborhoods looking for distressed houses and reached out to owners, etc, I don't really think you can determine what type of market this is. I lived in Boston for many years, and by comparison Minneapolis is a sea of opportunity..
Not looking to pick a fight, and I think Minneapolis and Boston are very different markets (coming from someone that lives in the Boston area and invests in the Twin Cities). The price points are very different and my sense is that Minneapolis is much more of a mom and pop landlord area than say Boston where there are a lot of institutional investors and foreign investors that are parking their money in the U.S. (not to mention a lot of foreign investors that buy a property cash for their kid to live in while they attend college). I have a hunch that the Boston market is going to be taking a bit of a dive due to a lot of the college/universities moving to remote learning, tanking rental demand. I suspect there will be a few areas of Boston (Allston, Brighton, Mission Hill) that are going to be largely vacant and it's going to get very competitive with landlords so they don't have vacant properties for ~ 4 months.
Thank you Brittany for starting this thread. I, too, am already invested with my vacation house and am looking at picking up at least one more property hopefully by the end of this year. I was seriously looking at Uptown but the new laws and of course we know nothing of how the police situation will be handled makes me sit on my hands for now - at least for the TC.