Conundrum for the Knowledgeable

Conundrum for the Knowledgeable

Member since 2019 · 3 posts · 0 votes

Hey guys,

I'm a young starting RE entrepreneur, been studying and learning for years, and now I'm launching with a major Househack and would love some guidance. I just got approved for a 400k FHA loan, want to use it to its max because it will probbly be the cheapest I'll ever get (3.5% down) I just spent a few months looking and calling and analyzing and am currently looking at 2 deals:

- Deal #1: A 120 yr old gorgeous brick mansion, technically a 4 unit but it includes 14 bedrooms, current owner is renovating it and adding up to 16 bedrooms in it. He also has an entire sorority signed up with signed leases for the next school year starting this August (15 girls, 14 already signed) with me living in it (becoz FHA) it will start cashflowing 2100$/month , and it has HUGE potential for later as the basement can be redone to add units, same with a very very huge attic level, easily 3 or 4 more bedrooms, and there's an extra ADU/garage with a second story that can also be redone into smthg decent, all of these already have water and power set up to them.

Downside: Would have to live with 15 freaking 20 yr old girls (I'm a 31 yr old man), this property is 2,5 hours away from the cities (I'm in St Paul MN) or any major center of civilization, and all these improvements to add any units or rooms wld take laaarge sizeable investments I can't afford right now.

- Deal #2: Also Gorgeous large 4-unit Townhome in the heart of the cities. Each unit has 3 Bedrooms and 2,5 baths, and a 1 car garage. It was built in 2001, just had everything replaced and redone,very sizeable everything, it really is the perfect classic 4 unit townhome for house hacking.. current tenants are all Month-to-month, all but 1 have been there for 7+ years, 3 of them are section 8.

Downside: Property does NOT currently Cashflow with me living in it, however if section 8 tenants are raised up just to Current Market rents it will cashflow abt 300 easily, and if I rent by the room for a very conservative 600$/room it can go up to 1866$/month. There are a total of 12 bedrooms and 12 bathrooms so if i just bump it up to 650$/room we're immediately up to CF= 2388$, and this is without even considering AirBNBing some (or all) of them, or furnishing them or anything else to add value... Being as this is central in the Twin Cities and not in a far away college town, the demand is not the problem, just knowing to what extent it can rent to by the room.


Sorry about the long paragraph, I would love to know if someone has a seriously good way of knowing to what amount a room can rent for, and what I might be missing or not considering in this current choice. I have been all over Rentometer, Zillow, Craigslist, Roomies, all kinds of other posts or tools, but the resources for "by the bedroom" are not as precise or dependable, and I just don't feel confident enough about these would-be numbers to make a choice..


Feel free to voice any thoughts or useful advice, or point to any resource or hidden notion I'm missing that any experienced RE investor might be able to contribute :)



0Reply
101 views

Most Popular Reply

Tim SwierczekPro Member
Lender · White Bear Township, MN · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
6y

@Chafic El Amatoury sounds ridiculous.  If you like that deal buy it as a non-owner occupied home.  For deal number 2 you need to search as a by the room enter would search.  Try FB marketplace, roomster.com, housinganywhere.com, and www.livesomewhere.com/umn

There are more issues to renting by the room, you need to deal with personal conflict and you must have a great well thought out lease.  I personally think you are overcomplicating your first deal.  Buy number 2, raise rents, and learn to be a landlord before you start getting too cute.  I know the podcasts make it seem like everyone should live rent-free but there is something to keeping it simple to start and learning the ropes before you take the hard stuff.




See this reply in the discussion

9 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2016 · 254 posts · 228 votes
    6y

    Sorry is the "downside" for #1 really a downside? Haha.. 

    In all seriousness I'd recommend you do whichever is most sustainable over the longterm. Are you really going to last a year uprooting your life to move 2.5 hrs away to live with 15 college students, or do you think you'll quit after a few months? Also, managing a sorority over the long term seems really management intensive, extremely high turn over, college students fighting, etc, you'd have to find a management company very specialized in this niche. Thats not to mention a sorority doesn't seem like such a great option right about now given it is about the least recession/pandemic resistant investment possible.. 

    On the other hand, a 4 plex with 3br/2ba units that's sec 8 in the cities for <400k is a great deal, assuming its in decent shape. Just checked, payment standard for sec 8 in Minneapolis is $1,636 for 3br, even if you rented all 4 at $1,400 once you moved out you'd be at a rent/price ratio of 1.4, amazing. Also, safety wise sec 8 is about as recession proof as you can get. I'd go with #2 all day. 

    Hope that helps. 

  • Tim SwierczekPro Member
    Lender · White Bear Township, MN · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    @Chafic El Amatoury sounds ridiculous.  If you like that deal buy it as a non-owner occupied home.  For deal number 2 you need to search as a by the room enter would search.  Try FB marketplace, roomster.com, housinganywhere.com, and www.livesomewhere.com/umn

    There are more issues to renting by the room, you need to deal with personal conflict and you must have a great well thought out lease.  I personally think you are overcomplicating your first deal.  Buy number 2, raise rents, and learn to be a landlord before you start getting too cute.  I know the podcasts make it seem like everyone should live rent-free but there is something to keeping it simple to start and learning the ropes before you take the hard stuff.




  • Investor · Akron, OH · Member since 2016 · 2k+ posts · 4k+ votes
    6y

    I love old houses; I live in one but they are often money pits-- personally, I avoid them for investment properties.

    colleges may not open until winter with corona virus this year so you might need to carry that mortgage on your own. Also, i think you'd be putting yourself in a potentially difficult/compromising position if you actually tried to live in the sorority house.

    If you triy to rent it section 8 you'll be remediating lead, replacing windows, and possibly destroying much of the historic character in order to get it up to modern standards in a cost effective manner.  

  • Adam TafelBusiness Member
    Real Estate Agent · St. Paul, MN · Member since 2017 · 611 posts · 407 votes
    6y

    @Chafic El Amatoury - interesting stuff, to say the least... 

    We've all heard this a million times in podcasts, books and forums : the more uncomfortable you're willing to be, the better your househack returns will be. Move 2.5 hours away to a college town (Duluth?) into a 120 year old mansion, currently under contruction, sharing space with a sorority? That would probably be a historically uncomfortable househack. How confident are you that it will pass FHA inspection? Call the city, check with zoning to see if adding units would be possible. See if the ADU has an active rental license, if permits have been pulled throughout the years, things like that.

    I can't believe you found a 12/12 4 unit in Minneapolis for under 400k, that's a deal. Check with the HRA about their contribution limits, it's not always easy raising rents on section 8, it'll depend on the zip code. I'm not sure that renting 3 separate units out by the room (9 rooms total) will be worth the extra effort, managing strangers co-existing takes serious time and patience. 

    You've dumped a lot of into on us, these thoughts are just off the top of my head. To summarize:

    1. I think it's awesome how creative you are willing to be, and how clearly motivated you are to maximize income potential. Regardless of which property you buy, this mindset is going to get you far.

    2. Do your due diligence with zoning and inspection departments. 

    3. Focus on the long-term. Overreaching to achieve cashflow while occupying might not be worth it in the long run. You want a property that performs well, but you don't want self-management to be too labor intensive, assuming you have goals to buy multiple properties in the future.

    Best of luck, keep us up to date! 

    Upside Property Sales 4.9118 Reviews
  • Investor · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2019 · 129 posts · 210 votes
    6y
    Originally posted by @Adam Tafel:

    @Chafic El Amatoury - interesting stuff, to say the least... 

    We've all heard this a million times in podcasts, books and forums : the more uncomfortable you're willing to be, the better your househack returns will be. Move 2.5 hours away to a college town (Duluth?) into a 120 year old mansion, currently under contruction, sharing space with a sorority? That would probably be a historically uncomfortable househack. How confident are you that it will pass FHA inspection? Call the city, check with zoning to see if adding units would be possible. See if the ADU has an active rental license, if permits have been pulled throughout the years, things like that.

    I can't believe you found a 12/12 4 unit in Minneapolis for under 400k, that's a deal. Check with the HRA about their contribution limits, it's not always easy raising rents on section 8, it'll depend on the zip code. I'm not sure that renting 3 separate units out by the room (9 rooms total) will be worth the extra effort, managing strangers co-existing takes serious time and patience. 

    You've dumped a lot of into on us, these thoughts are just off the top of my head. To summarize:

    1. I think it's awesome how creative you are willing to be, and how clearly motivated you are to maximize income potential. Regardless of which property you buy, this mindset is going to get you far.

    2. Do your due diligence with zoning and inspection departments. 

    3. Focus on the long-term. Overreaching to achieve cashflow while occupying might not be worth it in the long run. You want a property that performs well, but you don't want self-management to be too labor intensive, assuming you have goals to buy multiple properties in the future.

    Best of luck, keep us up to date! 

     He said the property is 2.5 hours away from the cities and he is in St. Paul - I misread that at first too. I'm guessing it's in Duluth

  • Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2017 · 28 posts · 26 votes
    6y

    @Chafic El Amatoury congrats on finding what seems to be 2 great deals! Most people starting off have a hard time just finding one. I have a 113 year old property and there are definitely a lot of hidden costs that you would need to account for. To me it comes down to quality of life, if you can't stand the thought living in a sorority then don't. It also doesn't mean you have to pass up one of the deals, get creative and you may find a way to get your hands on both. Keep us posted, we'd love to hear how you make this work.

  • Flipper/Rehabber · Minneapolis, MN · Member since 2016 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    Deal #1 - Doesn't sound like it would qualify for an FHA loan... Also - do you think 15 girls would want to live in a sorority with 1 guy in it? Guessing the parents who may be cosigning the leases will have an issue with this...

    Deal #2 - Numbers provided look too good to be true especially if it was built in 2001...  If this is in an area you are comfortable living you may have to act fast.

    Sounds like you have done quite a bit of research, the first deal is a little more "complicated" from a management standpoint and renting rooms would also provide more complications.  If this is your first investment I would recommend starting out with something a little more basic, you don't have to hit a home run.  And it is OK to "pay rent" while you live there in a house hack.  If your endgame is to leave just make sure all the numbers work with your exit plan.

  • Realtor · Bloomington MN (bloomington, mn) · Member since 2016 · 451 posts · 263 votes
    6y

    @Chafic El Amatoury I know which deal you are talking about for the second deal. I believe it just came back on the market during the inspection so that raises some red flags for me. Also if It is the same deal I am familiar with it is in North Minneapolis, which a lot of people have a hard time with rentals in some of those neighborhoods. 

  • Philadelphia, PA · Member since 2017 · 824 posts · 1k+ votes
    6y

    Gosh, living with 15 college-aged women sounds like a great idea in theory, but 34-year-old Joe will have to pass. Not only because he's married, but because he can think of a million downsides that far outweigh the positives. What worries me most about the deal is the financial aspects and the property -- there's a LOT going on there.

    To me, simplicity should be everyone's starting point. You have a job, a family, a social life, activities, and you want to add a major move, huge property, no experience, and a sorority into the mix?

    Dude...CHILL. Find a way to nix your living expenses with deal 1. That's it. If you pay $1000 in rent today and you nix your living expenses, you can save $12,000 a year while someone else pays down your debt. If you can do better than that, great!

    I know 23-year-old Joe would love to live with 15 women...in theory...he definitely isn't as smart as 34-year-old Joe, though...

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.