Which city in San Francisco bay area should i start

Which city in San Francisco bay area should i start

San Francisco, CA · Member since 2017 · 18 posts · 16 votes

Hello bay area dwellers,

I have been thinking of getting started in real estate by investing in a (MFR) in the bay area. I crunched some numbers to come up with cities that offer highest rent/price ratio (in theory) when looking from high level.

I have only included BART cities in the east bay to limit my search to fewer markets. I have not included Oakland as I think that it's own beast with may sub-markets. Following is a compilation of data I came up with by using city-data.com.

Pittsburg, Richmond, Hayward, Concord and San Leandro seem to be viable options for cities with median price ratio below $500,000, with Pittsburg offering highest rent/price ratio and no rent control. Rent control rules for all these cities are as follows:

Pittsburg - None

Richmond - Multi-unit homes (including duplexes) built before 1995 are rent controlled. Single family homes, certain small second units (“granny units”), and rental of a room within a home are NOT controlled.

Hayward - A landlord must own at least five units in the City of Hayward for the Hayward Rent Ordinance to apply. a tenant who rents a single family home after January 1, 1996 cannot be covered by the rent protection

Concord - No

San Leandro - No rent control. But rent review board ordinance applies to complexes with three or more units

Of course, good and bad deals can be found in each of the above cities. But, would love to know what others think on the ease of finding good MFR deals in any of the above markets? Any suggestions on how to chop up Oakland neighborhoods will also be appreciated so I can add it to the table above.

Thanks much!!

8Reply
329 views

Investor-friendly agents in San Francisco, CA

See the agents BiggerPockets members work with in San Francisco, CA.

Most Popular Reply

J. MartinPro Member
Rental Property Investor · Oakland, CA · Member since 2011 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
9y

@Atish Shah,

With your target GRM and desire for low-crime, good-school district areas, you sort of want the best of both worlds - high cash flow, and a good area likely to have strong single family home appreciation. And I want to be rich and famous. But we both have to struggle with reality hehe You would either need to go somewhere else, or decide which is more important to you (or at least compromise).

Like @Brian Burke is saying, you're looking at single family home prices, but trying to buy more than one unit. You probably need to go even further than what Brian is saying, and compare how much in rents you can get with $X00,000 of a multi-unit building in city 1, vs city 2, vs city 3, etc. Or just call up an agent that deals with them, and they should be able to give you a range of GRM's. CBRE and other commercial real estate brokerages also publish data on GRMs for large multifamily in different cities. You will have a higher GRM for 4-unit buildings and under than for large multifamily, but I think the proportions across different cities will be similar - as a place to start.

If you can get a vacant 4 unit in Richmond, you might be able to get close to 1% / 8-9 GRM(ish). Maybe in Vallejo also, but that's getting further out, and the city's all f**ked up after the BK and high taxes. (Richmond could be going that way too though! lol) @Diane G., play nice with the other kids in the sandbox ;) Atish is trying to learn. I could still buy under a 10 GRM today (especially after some transitioning). @Arlen Chou did the same last year in Oakland, when everyone said it couldn't be done.  Given, they aren't in Silicon Valley... 

@Arlen Chou

See this reply in the discussion

57 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2016 · 338 posts · 444 votes
    9y

    @Amit M., @Account Closed, As with many other things, I prefer to have a blend of various mortgage products. There are certainly a lot of players out there who don't believe in ever having a fixed rate, but I think their perspective comes from the time before there were these historical low rates (so interest rates could always drop instead of just go up). I've got a couple of 30-year rates (residential) that I locked in at 3.5% because... well, what are the chances you're ever going to see that again over the next 30 years? And it's just as good or better than a lot of commercial fixed rates.

    I do tend to be a conservative (I like to think disciplined) investor, but regarding the 10-year scenario you mentioned, Amit - I gotta believe that if you go 10 years in the Bay Area, your rents will be more than enough to cover the transition to variable. If not... that sorta says that RE here was never a good investment to begin with, right? 

    Also, I can confirm as Minh said that the cap is typically +6% (9.5%-10.5%) right now. 

    I'm thinking a little more about the portfolio loans that folks here are talking about. What gets me about those products is the inflexibility. If things go bad in the market, I like to know I can exit each property separately. Sure, you can negotiate with the banks... but don't you worry that if you're in the position where you HAVE to negotiate, you're already at a disadvantage with them? I could possibly see putting a portion of my holdings into portfolio financing, especially if those are the buildings I know I'll be keeping forever. 

  • Rental Property Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    @Account Closed basically just about anyone with a due ballon loan from 2008-2011 was in serious trouble. I personally knew a few people who lost their MF's in Oakland, and there were many others too throughout the Bay Area. If they had a non portfolio loan they were in a significantly different position, as they weren't required to negotiate with their bank. 

    So sure non portfolio loans are safer. But as I said, you still have to deal with the rate issue 3,5,7,10 years down the line. If you get stuck in an increased rate environment, then all those rent increases you enjoyed may be significantly reduced. That is a long term risk a 30 year fixed 2-4 loan doesn't have. 

    As for future rent speculation, unless we have a sustained and robust general economy, I don't expect Bay Area rents to go up much over the next several years. We had incredible rent increases the last 5 years (basically Christmas came early for landlords :) So I could see a scenario several years from now where rents are marginally higher than today. 

    As for the $1mil in the bank, I don't think that will mean jack sh*t to banks if they don't want to lend because liquidity is tight.  But it may mean that you could pay off your note and save your building. Of course if you aren't forced to negotiate with a bank and the market softens, you'll have cash to make some good purchases.  Though someone else not needing to grow their portfolio may prefer to own the building debt free. It really depends where you are in the arch of your portfolio. 

    As you know Minh, there is no free lunch (but there are good deals and smart in investments to be made :)  You are optimized for MF, adding value, working the loans, and getting cash out. And that's a great play for you. But don't forget that there are other good plays out there as well. For instance WRT residential loans, I happen to think that they have great advantages over commercial. Basically the government is willing to absorb the interest rate risk for you, for an incredible 30 years!  I don't think there is another country on earth that allows for that. Plus the rates are good, again basically a gov subsidy to help people buy homes (and shrewd investors buy 2-4's.) And there are all sorts of creative ways to deal with qualifying for the loans. I think that if you're not trying to build a huge portfolio, are investing in higher end prime assets, and keeping for the long term (forever), than the 2-4 play has a lot of advantages. For even with a PM, the more buildings and units you own, the larger the headaches. I'm trying to simplify going forward, not push for more units. It makes life easier as I spend more time out of the country (like I am now.)  Cheers. 

  • Investor · San Jose, CA · Member since 2012 · 2k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    9y

    @Amit M. and @Robert C.,

    Looks like both of you haven't dealt enough with commercial loans to know the delicacy of them. Inflexibility? These loans are more flexible than anything else. We can almost literally underwrite our own loan terms. Can you do that with Fannie/Freddie loans?

    I was going to let you guys have the last words, but the teacher in me suggests I should share it so others can benefit so here it goes ;)

    If history is any indication, rents and housing prices tend to rise first followed by interest rates. Interest rate increase tend to be a correlation of taming down inflation likely due to the hot economy. Thus, interest rate is a lagging indicator. 

    For rents to stay flat or trend down while interest rates move higher, this condition tends to be short-lived. As we enter the recession, rents and housing prices tend to get soft, and interest rates would follow and drop shortly after. For anyone to argue otherwise, they're arguing against history.

    I'm an avid student of history and have benefit from it so I respect it. My thesis has been that we would see lower interest rate after the next recession. I wouldn't be surprised to see 30-year fixed mortgages in the 2%ish. I have shared my thesis with @J. Martin and @Johnson H. since we first knew each other several years ago. Thus, I believe getting 30-year fixed mortgages may not be a prudent move given the premium in rates.

    With respect to liquidity, say the building is worth $1M and we obtain a 70% LTV in today. When the 10-year balloon comes due, the loan balance is about $550k. God forbid the building is worth $700k when the loan comes due. Did you know you can actually go to the bank and negotiate for a 75-80% LTV and put 5-10% of the liquidity in the reserve account until the building reaches the desired LTV? Once the desired LTV amount has reached, the reserve will be released. $1M in liquidity is huge in this scenario. Can you do that with residential loans when your LTV is not there when you want to refinance because interest rate is at 2% instead of 3.5%? This happened during the GFC. Many people wanted to refinance to lower their mortgage payment but couldn't because they had no liquidity and the property value wasn't there.

    Johnson and I chat on a regular basis. He has watched how I've continued to modify my acquisition and loan strategies through the years to adapt with the market conditions at the given time. Johnson is always there to be sure I don't stretch myself too thin or do anything stupid. I'm going to continue to invest and finance based on my thesis while I suggest you do what you feel comfortable with. There's really no right or wrong answer.

    Someone reached out to me yesterday due to my post on this thread. He's been a 2-4 unit investor in the Bay. He recently got into 5+ unit and forced appreciate 50% on his recent acquisition just in a few months. He felt it was like cheating. He wish he got into commercial years ago. It goes back to the lack of knowledge that scares others. 

    I won't try to convince anyone to get into commercial. Do what you're comfortable with as you're the one living with the consequences. This reminds me of the quote "Our lives are a direct result of our choices. If we don't like our lives, it's time to make better choices."

    Enjoy your time in Tel Aviv. See you in October at J's Summit in Oakland? Hey, have to make a plug for the brother. ;)

  • Investor · Los Altos, CA · Member since 2014 · 942 posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    @Account Closed I guess I am still trying to figure out my niche.  I am playing both sides of this discussion with both types of loans, but I definitely have way more to learn about commercial loans.

    Minh, are you seeing CAP rates starting to decompress and how do you or do you even have to deal with that when negotiating commercial loans in the future? Have you been able to negotiate the CAP rate used to value your property?

    Thanks,

    Arlen

  • Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2016 · 338 posts · 444 votes
    9y

    @Account Closed, Appreciate the feedback, and I don't mind at all that you're keeping the conversation going. Please continue! 

    I don't think you and I are disagreeing on most of your points. Probably our biggest difference in terms of our financing strategies is whether or not to do portfolio loans. But don't get me wrong, I do plenty of commercial loans and having that relationship with banks is a NECESSITY in order to negotiate down rates. Keep a large deposit with certain banks and build that relationship with the gate keepers - of course! I've also been able to do things like get 75% - 80% LTV with cross collateralizing or reserve (as you mentioned). These are great options to get certain deals closed based on available liquidity!

    Two things, though, which maybe I wasn't as clear on in my last post:

    1.) It's great to be able to negotiate those commercial rates. But I remain cautious on some level because I think banks are totally happy to compete for our business when the market is booming, but they're not necessarily going to be that agreeable when the market changes, unless you are SO big a customer that losing you would be detrimental. In the bay area, those customers are like in the 100s of millions net worth or even billionaires. That's just my interpretation based on anecdotes I've heard from the GFC. 

    2.) I think my blending of loan products is also influenced by how much financing I'm willing to do across my whole portfolio. This is probably different for you, but even though I maximize financing on specific properties, I keep my portfolio-level market LTV no more than 50% (including the house I live in). So since that's my limit, at a certain point you're picking between different options. Should I lock a rate on my residence/sfh, or should I take out more commercial financing on a multi-unit? Advantages of primary residential loans: no prepay penalty, no points... so even if I lock in that 3.5% which is great today, I can also refi at anytime if what you say happens and the rate drops to 2%. OR, if the banks won't let me refi on residential because of a financial crisis, then I can flip the switch to commercial, negotiate, and get enough additional capital to invest in something else or pay off that 3.5% residential (or both) - change my blend so to speak.

    You're right, there's no one strategy, and we all have our own perspective/crystal ball, but that's why these discussions are great, because maybe we hear something new that will tweak our game plan!

    Oh, and forgot to mention. Interest rates don't always go down during a market crisis. People in the 80's had to deal with massive interest rate increases because the Fed was trying to combat inflation.

  • J. MartinPro Member
    Rental Property Investor · Oakland, CA · Member since 2011 · 3k+ posts · 2k+ votes
    9y
    Originally posted by @Account Closed:

    @Amit M. and @Robert C.,

    Looks like both of you haven't dealt enough with commercial loans to know the delicacy of them. Inflexibility? These loans are more flexible than anything else. We can almost literally underwrite our own loan terms. Can you do that with Fannie/Freddie loans?

    I was going to let you guys have the last words, but the teacher in me suggests I should share it so others can benefit so here it goes ;)

    If history is any indication, rents and housing prices tend to rise first followed by interest rates. Interest rate increase tend to be a correlation of taming down inflation likely due to the hot economy. Thus, interest rate is a lagging indicator. 

    For rents to stay flat or trend down while interest rates move higher, this condition tends to be short-lived. As we enter the recession, rents and housing prices tend to get soft, and interest rates would follow and drop shortly after. For anyone to argue otherwise, they're arguing against history.

    I'm an avid student of history and have benefit from it so I respect it. My thesis has been that we would see lower interest rate after the next recession. I wouldn't be surprised to see 30-year fixed mortgages in the 2%ish. I have shared my thesis with @J. Martin and @Johnson H. since we first knew each other several years ago. Thus, I believe getting 30-year fixed mortgages may not be a prudent move given the premium in rates.

    With respect to liquidity, say the building is worth $1M and we obtain a 70% LTV in today. When the 10-year balloon comes due, the loan balance is about $550k. God forbid the building is worth $700k when the loan comes due. Did you know you can actually go to the bank and negotiate for a 75-80% LTV and put 5-10% of the liquidity in the reserve account until the building reaches the desired LTV? Once the desired LTV amount has reached, the reserve will be released. $1M in liquidity is huge in this scenario. Can you do that with residential loans when your LTV is not there when you want to refinance because interest rate is at 2% instead of 3.5%? This happened during the GFC. Many people wanted to refinance to lower their mortgage payment but couldn't because they had no liquidity and the property value wasn't there.

    Johnson and I chat on a regular basis. He has watched how I've continued to modify my acquisition and loan strategies through the years to adapt with the market conditions at the given time. Johnson is always there to be sure I don't stretch myself too thin or do anything stupid. I'm going to continue to invest and finance based on my thesis while I suggest you do what you feel comfortable with. There's really no right or wrong answer.

    Someone reached out to me yesterday due to my post on this thread. He's been a 2-4 unit investor in the Bay. He recently got into 5+ unit and forced appreciate 50% on his recent acquisition just in a few months. He felt it was like cheating. He wish he got into commercial years ago. It goes back to the lack of knowledge that scares others. 

    I won't try to convince anyone to get into commercial. Do what you're comfortable with as you're the one living with the consequences. This reminds me of the quote "Our lives are a direct result of our choices. If we don't like our lives, it's time to make better choices."

    Enjoy your time in Tel Aviv. See you in October at J's Summit in Oakland? Hey, have to make a plug for the brother. ;)

     Minh,
    I agree that 30-yr rates will likely be lower at some time the next down cycle. It might be another question as to where banks are at on lending, where the person is at in their personal life/wealth/cash flow/documentation, etc. e.g., When I got my last 30-yr fixed, I was a working stiff that had great salary documentation. Now I'm traveling the world running my biz. And not all lenders look at that the same way. Lending terms are definitely different now than they were in 2010-12. Including in commercial loans. And there were a lot of losses on commercial loans also. I was one of the regulators in those banks looking at the individual deals and policy underwriting criteria (in addition to exceptions.)

    I go back and forth on the fixed vs variable. The fixed rate premium I see essentially as an insurance policy. I'm not super wealthy, so I like the insurance (as long as that premium is not too high. I think it was 75bp on residential last time I looked, but probably bigger spread for commercial) As long as I can pay my insurance and Prop-13-capped taxes, it doesn't matter what happens to market prices, lending/bank terms, personal circumstances, documentation, etc. Just pay the bill as it comes in and you don't have to worry about any of that. For those that are wealthy and better financial standing, their personal strength and overall LTV might better support lending in most or nearly all environments. But even very wealthy people ran into issues in the crisis. So never say never.

    In regards to term/length of loan, the bullet payments present some of the same risks (due in 10 years). The refinance depends partially on internal (you) factors and partially on external factors (bank lending terms, RE market price changes, personal financial turmoil, etc. ) - specifically at the time you are trying to refinance. 

    On the multifamily vs 4plex.. I probably should have got into multifamily earlier. But 2-4 units were still more heavily discounted at the time. And I was definitely influenced by the 30yr fixed. Maybe partially because I saw so many people get burned during the GFC due to the clock running out rather than being on a fully amortized term. (back in bank regulation days.) It's like growing up during the great depression.. sticks in your mind.. 

    I agree, there's really no right or wrong. 
    But I think with 2-4 unit prices no longer providing the same market appreciation ride from the bottom, there is a lot more proportional opportunity in the 5+ unit buildings you can force appreciation on. And the fixed vs variable is more of a personal wealth/insurance issue, IMHO. 

  • Rental Property Investor · San Francisco, CA · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    9y

    Hey guys, great discussion and input from all. Few points:

    Minh, for the record, I did have a commercial loan from 2005-2013. It was 9 units (2 buildings, side by side, 3 and a 6 plex) whereby I did a lot split with my partner and I kept the triplex. Back in 2005 it was easy dealing with commercial loans. We got ours from chase and had a 1 year adjustable rate (libor) because we knew we would refi after the lot split. Since we didn't have a ballon due we were safe during the Great Recession. But definitely many people who *had* to refi 2008-11 were in serious trouble. You really had to be an active investor during those times to feel the weight of the adversity you faced. Just about every RE investor suffered during those times on some level, and those who's loans were called were at serious risk. So that's why I personally avoid portfolio loans unless I know I'm refying out of them with a specific game plan in the near future. 

    I say this because I sense that we are headed into a new global era. Brexit and the trump elections are a result of these changes, and not the cause of them. Also technology is a factor. For instance, rogue groups and terrorist organizations are much more powerful today due to tech. We don't know what the backlash against immigration will be. Looming trade wars are possible. These are things that run counter to the 1990-2010 world we grew up in. And tech such as driverless cars, robotics, AI will make a huge impact over the next 20 years. (Of course so far the stock market is going gangbusters, but that can easily change.) Automation, etc. may propel the global economy to new heights, but social strife due to inequality (who benefits from the changes) may also tear things apart. But whatever the upshot of all this uncertainty, it will undoubtedly effect long term interest rates. 

    I think all of us in this discussion developed thoughtful investment plans, although we do things differently. Some are all commercial, some a blend, and some non commercial. Each approach has its strengths. And only time will tell how the future will impact each of us. Hopefully we will all do well!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.