Should I sell and do a 1031 or refinance?

Should I sell and do a 1031 or refinance?

Investor · Bountiful, UT · Member since 2015 · 2 posts · 0 votes

I am trying to decide if I should sell my rental or keep it and refinance it?  Here are the details of the property.  It's a twin home that I bought 9 years ago.  It is currently cash flowing $300/month.  If I were to refinance it, the cashflow would go to $680/month.  And if I do a cash out refi, pulling out about $15,000 the cashflow would be $540/month.  Or I can sell it and have about $65,000 to use as a down payment for another rental.

I am really struggling on what to do, because almost every investor that I have heard says the one thing that they wish they would have done different was not sell anything and buy more.  So I am not sure if I should just hold on to this forever and keep it for the cashflow.  Or sell it and try to "upgrade" to something bigger/better.  The problem with selling it is finding a deal within the 45 days allowed for a 1031 exchange.  And if I can find a deal it will most likely be cashflowing less per month than what I would be getting if I refinanced it. 

I know there is no right answer, or one size fits all.  But I am looking for opinions from other investors that have been down this road.  Do you wish you would have never sold a property?  Or are you glad you did, so that you could buy another one?

0Reply
39 views

5 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Winter Garden , FL · Member since 2014 · 72 posts · 27 votes
    9y

    Is your rate that high where you would save $380 by doing a refi? What is the value of the home?

    Its all about opportunity cost and time frame. If this is a property you're set on keeping for several years, a cash out refi may be best as you can pay down the closing costs you incur with principle pay downs (and hopefully appreciation). But if you have additional money on hand to scale up and get into something larger, that allows you to consolidate maintenance (i.e. a multiplex in a area giving you a higher return with more simple repairs to the roof and structure) it may be worth it to sell. 

  • Investor · Winter Garden , FL · Member since 2014 · 72 posts · 27 votes
    9y

    Cash out refi is a no brainer as well vs a traditional refi. It would take almost 10yrs to make back the $15k you would pull out from cash flow

  • Investor · Bountiful, UT · Member since 2015 · 2 posts · 0 votes
    9y

    Hey Jeremy, thanks for the response.  Yes, our rate is pretty high for today's standards.  It's at 6.75%.  The home is worth $200,000 now.  I do have a balloon payment that is due this summer, so I either need to sell it or refinance it.

    I'm not really set on keeping it, although it has been a great rental in a high demand area.  I could go either way really.  Unfortunately, I do not have extra cash to pool together and buy something bigger.  Although that is a great idea and something I can do in the future.

    I was thinking the same thing, if I do go the refi route then I think taking some cash out would be the best idea.

  • Investor · Winter Garden , FL · Member since 2014 · 72 posts · 27 votes
    9y
    Gotcha, yea historically that's not a bad rate. In my opinion, I'd ask myself how long it would take to make up the monetary difference between the cash out refi and selling it between all of your sources of income, job, rent etc. If it's going to take a while to get there then I'd look elsewhere at properties for how you can make your money work for you. I like to hold on to properties where I can through any combination of appreciation, forced appreciation, and principal pay down recoup my potential selling fees. Once I do that I'm looking at an apples to apples comparison of where my money could better be used. I just did a cash out refi on one of my SFHs instead of selling it. Rents are increasing, it was a flip that sat on the market for a long time and I've had 0$ in maintenance in 2.5 years with great tenants, so I decided to hold on to it for a while longer vs selling it.
  • Investor · Winter Garden , FL · Member since 2014 · 72 posts · 27 votes
    9y
    Also, there's worse things you could do than take out higher debt and lock in at these rates.
Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.