Buying newer homes to rent

Buying newer homes to rent

Real Estate Investor · Spring, TX · Member since 2013 · 34 posts · 7 votes

So my first rental home was an old beat-up home that wasn't worth much and not in a desirable area, but generally safe. It was a home that I aquired at a good price from family and started my rental career. I stil rent this home, wishing I could sell it for just what I owe on it, but I have made a lot of money off the deal over the past 10 years and this home is worth $65K and rents for $800. I cash flow $146/m with no turnover, no repairs, and I manage myself. But cost keep going up and I cannot push rents much higher.

Because of that home my next 8 rental homes were nothing like it. These homes were all SFH in good desirable neighborhoods, that I could sell on the MLS for retail anytime I wanted. (My exit strategy). The cash flow is fantasitic, the repairs are negligable, and the turn over is very low with an average turnover cost of $150 and 1 to 3 weeks. These types of homes are year 2000 or newer, 3/2/2, 1700-2700 sq ft and about $120 ARV.This method has made me a lot of money, with very little headaches.

So whats the problem?

First problem, Texas realesate is getting expensive. The low hanging fruit is gone.

Second problem, I can't find these types of homes with much of a discount. The typical investor tries to by homes 70% ARV. I have never been able to buy these preferred type homes at that price. I thought I was lucky to get them at 85% LTV some even above 90% LTV. I was able to get excellent financing on them normally 4% 30 year mortgages, but required a lot of money down. $25K per home. I am very good at keeping track of my numbers and my Cash on Cash ROI is amazing at 15%-25% ConC ROI.

So I am seeking some group advice. Should I continue to buy these premiem type homes that rent well and cash flow great but keeping dropping $25-$35K cash per home. I could only do about 2 a year at that cash flow rate.

Should I do what everyone else does and by older homes in less quality neighborhoods with no money down at 70% ARV? I could expand my homes a dozen or more per year?

I have spend a lot of time and money on marketing that has paid off, but never for the type of homes I prefer. I just don't think they are out there.

Whats your thoughts on newer SFR in great neighborhoods, compared to lower end homes at a bigger discounts? What has been your experience?

0Reply
32 views

9 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Lafayette/Baton Rouge, LA · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 915 votes
    12y
    I think you answered your own question. As market conditions change, you either change your strategy or change your expectations. You've had the lower price point experience and unless you're willing to deal with the conditions there, why go back? It'a not likely to be very different than the last time you tried it. Unless you use a different strategy?
  • Real Estate Investor · Member since 2013 · 866 posts · 487 votes
    12y

    @Greg Meech,

    You found a cookie cutter that works for you. Why would you not continue stamping out the cookies?

    You are almost to the point where you will have to change your financing strategy and either go with commercial or private financing. From what you have described here so far, I don't think you will have any problem putting together the needed documentation for either.

    You will also find, once you get into the commercial world, the 'down payment' becomes much less of an obstacle. That is one reason why I have never understood why investors are so afraid of going commercial other than a relatively small difference in the overall terms. Commercial typically will have a higher rate but lower entry costs and down payment requirements.

    But, if I were you, I'd keep stamping out those cookies. Even at just two properties a year for the next 10 years, you will do very well in retirement with those 30 houses.

  • Severna Park, MD · Member since 2013 · 7k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    12y

    They are out there , you just have to look harder , I buy in good areas , I am buying location first , the house is second . I look for cash flow AND appreciation . My last 2 purchaces were rough houses in good areas , I paid retail for both , only because they were sub dividable . On 1 I will get 1 additional lot , On the second I will get 5 lots .

  • Mike D'ArrigoPro Member
    Turn key provider · San Jose, CA · Member since 2010 · 4k+ posts · 3k+ votes
    12y

    @Greg Meech You left out some needed information.How much do you have to pay for the older homes and what is the ROI? I'm also confused as to why you are only getting $146/mth cash flow off $800 rent with no turnover, no repairs and no property management. Where are your expenses coming from?How much do the newer properties rent for and what is the cash flow on them? Need to know that to make an apples to apples comparison.

    Mike

  • Investor · Abilene, TX · Member since 2013 · 36 posts · 14 votes
    12y

    Its hard for me to justify spending the money on a newer home with the 25%-35% down and the increased amount in taxes. But those older homes are a bigger headache!

    Good Luck!

  • Landlord and Rehabber · Newton, MA · Member since 2010 · 2k+ posts · 877 votes
    12y

    I'm also curious how you are only cash flowing $146 on $800 in rent if you self manage and have long term tenants that don't have any maintenance issues.

    What do you cash flow on the nicer houses?

    Different strokes... Some people only want new properties in nicer areas to lessen the headache factor others are willing to chase higher returns by getting cheaper properties. If you are getting at least what your goal is on the nicer places for a return and you enjoy them more then that is your answer.

    As others have said at some point the banks will cut you off from traditional financing so make sure you think about that as part of your expansion plans. Otherwise buy what you like, is making you money and fits your model.

  • SFR Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2011 · 604 posts · 243 votes
    12y

    I buy properties somewhere between the 'older' home in less desirable neightborhoods, and the new houses. Most houses I own are built 78-88, have an ARV of $100-$110k,, rent for $1100-$1200 and I end up being "all in" around $80-$92k (lately around the $88-$92k mark).

    I buy in an area I know the schools, buy in neighborhoods that have few rentals and most have stable ownership. These neighborhoods/deals are hard to find, but I don't need 100 of them, just 1 at a time.

    As far as why the original poster has so little cash flow, its called Texas Property Taxes,,we have no income tax, but that $65k home could still cost $2k a year or more in property taxes.

    andy

  • Real Estate Investor · Spring, TX · Member since 2013 · 34 posts · 7 votes
    12y

    My first home I did a subject too, not even having a clue what that was, I just starting making mortgage payments so my Mom wouldn't loose her home when she had to move out for medical reasons and I moved in a renter. Later I changed the title over to me so there wouldn't be any issues when she passed away. I paid her $20K and in 2007 did a cash out refi at $85K mortgage and walk away with $35K cash. I put $12K back into the property for the rehab and moved in a real renter. I was estimating the numbers, but I looked it up and the rent is $860 and my totol mortgage payment is $710.20 leaves me $149.80.

    I did make money, so I proved that low income homes can work for me, but it was and is a pain in the but. I can't throw anymore money at it, because it's not in a nice neighborhood and I won't get it back. I can't attract any better tenant. And the home is now worth $65K. Wholley depreciating asset! Thats wha attracts me to newer homes in nicer areas. All of those homes have gone up in value and rents have gone up too.

    My last home I bought in March 2013 I paid 95% ARV for a 2004 year ARV $117,800 3/2/2. I thought it was going to be 90% but ended up being 95% ARV. I rented it in 1 day with no commissions signed a 2 year lease for $1400 a month. My total PITI&HOA&Liability total $786.21 which I cash flow $613.79 a month. Its pretty new so I haven't had any repairs at all this year. Cash out of pocket was $34K. Cash on Cash ROI was 17% for this year.

    But I can't find these homes better than a 90% ARV. Am I doing something wrong?

  • Real Estate Investor · Spring, TX · Member since 2013 · 34 posts · 7 votes
    12y

    "I cash flow $146/m with no turnover, no repairs, and I manage myself."

    Opps what I meant was that I get this cashflow IF no turnovers, no repairs, and I manage myself. One AC bill takes out my profit for 6 months or so and it will need a new roof soon. It's an older house so it needs a lot of repairs and it isn't the easiet to rent at $860. I have a long term tenant, so that is always late and is one paycheck from eviction. And when he moves out it's going to cost me a lot. Are all low income homes like this? What a pain. No wonder renting gets a bad rap.

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.