Homeowner · Brampton, On · Member since 2013 · 72 posts · 8 votes
Hi all,
Newbie question: since there seem to be many areas in the US where houses cost $20-100,000 and there are several government financing programs that let people put down very little as downpayment (less than 10%), why do so many people rent rather than just buy?
I'm from the Toronto area in Canada. Toronto has average house/condo price of $550,000 and many people can't afford to buy at those prices. I honestly don't understand the psychology of the masses of renters in US. The reason I go out on a limb with such a naive question is because not understanding the psychology is seriously holding me back from investing.
There are obviously people who have various life problems (criminality, poor credit, poor life skills) who might not have it together to buy a house. But most of BP landlords don't want to rent to those people anyway.
There are some who need to frequently relocate and can't settle down. But there are millions of family people with the American Dream of owning a home who rent. Why?
I probably have some wrong preconceptions and a world view limited by my own experience. Go easy on me and share your view point.
Thanks,
I think its a very serious error to think that renters are making or have made some sort of mistake, as many of the replies and even the original question seems to assume. I strongly believe that for many people renting is the correct way to have a place to live. There are many, many people who have bought a house only to end up being financially damaged by that decision. Many folks who bought during the bubble have had their entire lives devastated by that decision. Some will NEVER recover back to the point they would have been had they avoided.
Even without the bubble, owning a house is generally a poor investment. Americans have been convinced by vested interests that they should subscribe to the "American Deam" of owning a "home". People are told to compare the value of their parents home 30 years ago to the value now. Great investment, right? The biggest "investment" you'll even make. The truth is its the biggest doo-dad most people will ever buy. If you add up the true cost - purchase price; 30 years of insurance, taxes, and routine maintenance; major improvements; etc. - and compare it to the true value - what you could sell it for less the exorbitant costs of actually selling it - it is, at best, a crummy savings account. In many cases, the net is negative.
If you buy into the "starter house", "move up house", "mini-mansion", "downsizing house" scheme that's also promoted you're almost certainly negative. You're paying all those exorbitant transaction costs every time you move.
Now, thats OK. You have have a place to live. If you compare ownership to renting the cost could go either way. But in many areas and for many lifestyles renting is the cheaper alternative.
Yes, there are places where houses are dirt cheap. I have a house in one of those area that I bought in 2006 for $11,000. Many people don't won't to live in those places. The small towns around that area where I grew up are sad places. Boarded up and empty stores. A proliferation of antique stores. Limited employment opportunities. Few of the amenities people in cities take for granted. Heck, something as simple as a 24 hour pharmacy can be 50 or 100 miles away.
Owning a house locks you down. I've read analysis that claim higher-than-historical home ownership contributed to the recession. People were stuck in a house that they couldn't get rid of in an area where there were limited jobs. Had they been renting they could have packed up and moved somewhere with better prospects.
Many desirable areas are very expensive to buy but fairly cheap to rent. That $550K condo is expensive, but Toronto is a nice place to live, from what I hear. At one point in my day job we acquired some technology from a company based there and hired two of their employees. We tried to get them to come to Denver or the bay area. No luck. They absolutely wanted to stay in Toronto. I suspect the rent on that condo is quite low from. Maybe $2500 a month. Probably not $7500 a month like an investor would need for a profitable rental. So paying $2500 a month to live where you want is the right choice for many people.
For many people housing is just a place to live. Its not a "dream". Its just a roof and walls. Many folks just don't care that much about the specifics.
There's no attraction to owning such an expensive toy as a house. They like the flexibility of being able to move around, even if its just to another area of town. There's lots of other things to spend money on and some are satisified with a cheaper place than an expensive house.
Fortunately for us buy-and-hold investors, the average American doesn't really save any substantial amount of money and more or less live paycheck to paycheck. Saving up $10K for a down payment might not seem that crazy when you're used to seeing prices in the 500K range, but typically people that live in areas with 20K - 100K properties are probably making south of 50K a year and likely supporting a family or a paycheck-to-paycheck lifestyle.
I actually market almost all of my rentals to students and people in transitional states of their lives (young professionals mainly). These people are looking to live in the same place for 1-4 years, but don't have any long-term commitment tieing them to the area.
I don't even bother trying to get in the mind of my tenants that could be a dangerous place.
I would have to say my guess is financial apathy. Numbers, saving and investing is boring, it is much more fun to spend and buy stuff like a new big screen to watch the Walking Dead or Dancing with the Stars. Although I think my generation is seeing the benefit of remaining mobile especially since they have the student loan ball and chain they are carrying around with them. Anyone want to pay $200k for an accounting degree?.
The exact reasons vary, I am renting right now and own a rental as well, just does not make sense right now in my life to buy here in Orange County and I just moved down here and still am getting to know the area. I am a landlord's nightmare, a tenant that owns income property.
I would say the reasons are broad (just as with those who decide to purchase). From my experience, the majority seem to be people in a "transitional" life stage, (i.e. empty nesters, students, newlyweds, just graduated, relocated for job, etc.) as Michael mentioned.
Also, as Chad touched on, with the general population having massive student loan debt, general spending debt, or those who are still recouping after the recession, renting allows them the time to build/re-build credit, savings, etc.
Thanks Michael, Chad and Jay,
I can understand the people in transitional life stages. I suppose I might be underestimating the number of people in student debt, and general debt.
Most people cannot manage their finances well enough to save for a down payment. Let's say you want to buy a $100,000 house and you need to save $3,500 in order to do that. If you save $100 per month, you'd need 35 months in order to get to a down payment amount which is almost 3 years.
It sounds silly, but there are many people who would rather save for 6 months and buy a flat-screen TV than save 3 years to buy a house.
Plus there are cell phone bills, Facebook games to buy, etc. that take away from the money people could be saving to buy a house.
I have two good friends renting for 20 and 30 years respectively. When you talk to them they just can' t get motivated to do anything else. It is easy to rent and much harder to plan for the future. The first one grew up in an apartment in the same town he lives in now. I don't know his finances but I do know to decide not to rent would mean deciding something. The other couple is in their 70's and are classic paycheck to paycheck people. Life has dealt them a lot of hard blows and although they don't do the flat screen TVs they just could never get out from under. They also live in one of the more expensive areas of the country but even so they it wasn't a goal they seemed to move toward. My brother was much the same way, it was painful trying to get him to apply for a mortgage to buy the family home. It is just plain immobility for those long term renters.
I think its a very serious error to think that renters are making or have made some sort of mistake, as many of the replies and even the original question seems to assume. I strongly believe that for many people renting is the correct way to have a place to live. There are many, many people who have bought a house only to end up being financially damaged by that decision. Many folks who bought during the bubble have had their entire lives devastated by that decision. Some will NEVER recover back to the point they would have been had they avoided.
Even without the bubble, owning a house is generally a poor investment. Americans have been convinced by vested interests that they should subscribe to the "American Deam" of owning a "home". People are told to compare the value of their parents home 30 years ago to the value now. Great investment, right? The biggest "investment" you'll even make. The truth is its the biggest doo-dad most people will ever buy. If you add up the true cost - purchase price; 30 years of insurance, taxes, and routine maintenance; major improvements; etc. - and compare it to the true value - what you could sell it for less the exorbitant costs of actually selling it - it is, at best, a crummy savings account. In many cases, the net is negative.
If you buy into the "starter house", "move up house", "mini-mansion", "downsizing house" scheme that's also promoted you're almost certainly negative. You're paying all those exorbitant transaction costs every time you move.
Now, thats OK. You have have a place to live. If you compare ownership to renting the cost could go either way. But in many areas and for many lifestyles renting is the cheaper alternative.
Yes, there are places where houses are dirt cheap. I have a house in one of those area that I bought in 2006 for $11,000. Many people don't won't to live in those places. The small towns around that area where I grew up are sad places. Boarded up and empty stores. A proliferation of antique stores. Limited employment opportunities. Few of the amenities people in cities take for granted. Heck, something as simple as a 24 hour pharmacy can be 50 or 100 miles away.
Owning a house locks you down. I've read analysis that claim higher-than-historical home ownership contributed to the recession. People were stuck in a house that they couldn't get rid of in an area where there were limited jobs. Had they been renting they could have packed up and moved somewhere with better prospects.
Many desirable areas are very expensive to buy but fairly cheap to rent. That $550K condo is expensive, but Toronto is a nice place to live, from what I hear. At one point in my day job we acquired some technology from a company based there and hired two of their employees. We tried to get them to come to Denver or the bay area. No luck. They absolutely wanted to stay in Toronto. I suspect the rent on that condo is quite low from. Maybe $2500 a month. Probably not $7500 a month like an investor would need for a profitable rental. So paying $2500 a month to live where you want is the right choice for many people.
For many people housing is just a place to live. Its not a "dream". Its just a roof and walls. Many folks just don't care that much about the specifics.
There's no attraction to owning such an expensive toy as a house. They like the flexibility of being able to move around, even if its just to another area of town. There's lots of other things to spend money on and some are satisified with a cheaper place than an expensive house.
I am a landlord's nightmare, a tenant that owns income property.
Why would you be a landlords nightmare? You obviously have your act together, pay rent, and understand what its like to rent to someone, so you more than likely wouldn't trash the place. Sounds like a great candidate..
I think a big part of it is the loss of the family unit. I have had one first time married couple with kids. They were great tenants but moved after a year, maybe two and bought a house (later got divorced lost the house and now both rent). Other couples are on 2nd marriages with blended families which causes financial hardship. Others are single parents, actually more single fathers than single mothers. Also recently divorced causes many to choose renting oit of necessity.
Poor financial skills and planning in general is another big factor as others have mentioned. It is easier to get a newer car than purchase a home. With poor financial skills or situation many folks will finance large purchases that are able to be financed and cost them more.
The last side of it is that people just don't want to own. They want to be ableto go out to eat and shop than work on their home. Lots of buyers want ahouse that is completed and they will not have to touch. The average homeowner doesn't want to change a toilet or faucet or ceiling fan much lessa larger more involved job. There are many homeowners in old but nice areas of town that have lots of old mechanicals in their home and deferred maintenance because lots of people just don't want to deal with it.
@Jon Holdman while in many ways I agree with you I would say that renting doesn't make people more flexible. I am a mover , I have lived in several states and would easily considering moving again. I know other people who are place bound. They would not go across the country even when they were out of work. It didn't matter if they were month to month or had a mortgage or lived in an expensive state and could move to a cheaper one. Other people I know picked up and moved from another country , they owned houses and had local family but that was who they were. I don't begin to analyze the recession, but I would say that even when people can move many don't they build a bigger hole where they are because that is who they are and it has nothing to do with renter vs house buyer.
I'm a mover as well. I've moved between continents, States, cities and across town. It's gotten to the point where I could not imagine spending several years int he same place - maybe it's the 'grass is greener' syndrom? I've lived in so many houses that I renovated, that I wouldn't want to be finished renovating with one house and then I'm stuck - lol.
Now that I'm in the SF Bay area, I can rent much cheaper than I could buy. I look at it this way: If I wanted to buy a 500K house, I'd have to come up with 100K cash as down payment. My overall mortgage, tax, insurance payments would probably still be around 3K.
Or...I could take that same 100K and buy and renovate (5) 3/2 houses in Atlanta and rent each out for $ 600-650 and then rent that 500K house in the bay area for $ 2,000.
I am a landlord's nightmare, a tenant that owns income property.
Why would you be a landlords nightmare? You obviously have your act together, pay rent, and understand what its like to rent to someone, so you more than likely wouldn't trash the place. Sounds like a great candidate..
Yeah, we get along great and my wife is too much of a clean freak to trash a place. We joke about tenants and trade ideas.
I think there is a lot of money to be made in buying and selling homes and it is a very emotional decision for most. This makes the subject way oversold in my opinion. There are lots of articles saying the "American Dream" is dead but when things pick up in the retail market people will change their tune.
I really enjoy the high level of conversation here and especially people's take on personal freedom and the issue of the "family unit".
@Jon Holdman thanks for commenting. I do see that my house is a doodad and does cost more than renting, but when the time came to turn into a family unit, I did what I was conditioned to do - I bought a house and started baking to make it smell like home. I guess I was underappreciating people's need for freedom.
@Dawn Anastasi - you mentioned that people would rather save for a TV rather than a $100,000 house. But I also get the idea that family-type properties in your area are approx 30,000. Would you care to comment on what type of people you have as tenants - students, retirees, singles or families? Do you think it's freedom they want even though they could have some walls to call their own for $3000?
Most of our tenants are military members. The houses although nice, are located in towns that most people have no desire to live in once this tour is over. Plus many members were burned in the bubble.
@Michaela G. yes you seem like a mover and it looks tike most investors you are looking at the numbers and I can see good reasons for you liking the current better money scenario.
I am not sure people looking at their place of residence weigh the numbers as much as most of us do but maybe they should. buying isn't for everyone and not everyone who says they want to buy really does want to.
In the end there is a lot more to the psychology of renting then money or flexibility. In some ways I think it is about how you look at home (rented or purchased), what does it mean ? but also what goals do you have and what tools do you have to get there?
In "The Wall Street Journal, Complete Real-Estate Investing Guidebook" the first chapter is titled "Why Your Home is Not an Investment Property," and after reading this I have valued home ownership quite a bit less than I had before.
Everyone has to evaluate the pros and cons of home ownership vs. renting, but in my case I see myself renting again when I my kids are out of the house, even though I will continue to invest in rental properties.