Investing in a rental in New Haven, ct. smart choice?

Investing in a rental in New Haven, ct. smart choice?

Member since 2021 · 6 posts · 2 votes

Hi, 

My name is Camila. I am interested in getting my first rental property in the New Haven or West Haven area of CT. The goal is to rent it to out to college students or long term tenants. I would love to connect with any investors or property managers in the area who are currently doing this!

1Reply
105 views

Most Popular Reply

Attorney · Rutherford, NJ · Member since 2015 · 132 posts · 168 votes
5y

Thanks @Jonathan Greene—@Cami Danielle I think New Haven is a fairly tough market (and, right now, overpriced). I’ve owned several 2, 3, and 4 families there, and sold most (though still own one). I sold because the market there is nuts right now: everything going for way more than it has been trading at over the last few years. I’m about to list my remaining property.

The thesis of m my investments there has been the idea that Yale and the other universities in New Haven have a vested interest in making sure New Haven is OK (or, ideally, nice), meaning that they will invest money in the community and expand their footprint to do so. Yale, in particular, has more money than some small countries, so they certainly have the financial means to invest in the city. That premise is generally true, but more particularly right around Yale and the other universities. Housing in those areas is very nice, and super pricey.

Farther away, housing is much less nice (and much cheaper) but your chances of renting to college students is very low. Mostly, you’ll be renting to local residents (some of whom may be employed by the university), but they’re not paying the rents that students are. The Yale “bubble” is still centered quite closely around Yale, and that’s also true of the other schools there. Outside of those bubbles, New Haven struggles a lot with poverty, crime and homelessness and the city is far from straightforward to work with.

I’ve struggled at essentially every property with rent collection except for properties where I had all Section 8 tenants. I made money via appreciation (and ultimately did well), but the rental income was, at best, treading water.

If you’re up for the management challenge, buy right, and have a longer term horizon, I think you can do OK but it may be worthwhile to wait for the market to cool down a bit. I also wouldn’t count on doing great cash flow-wise, even if it looks on paper that it’s a good deal... you’re going to struggle with collections and evictions, in my experience. Unless you live there and are up for it, you’re going to need to find a great property manager. 

See this reply in the discussion

8 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Real Estate Consultant · IN · Member since 2021 · 139 posts · 85 votes
    5y

    Hi @Cami Danielle

    I have read that college rentals can be very profitable! Many investors are scared to get into them as college kids can potentially be harmful to a property. Here is a helpful article I read on BP:

    https://www.biggerpockets.com/...

    Hope this helps! Good luck!

  • Member since 2021 · 6 posts · 2 votes
    5y

    Thanks that really helps ! 

  • Jonathan GreeneBusiness Member
    Real Estate Consultant · Madison, NJ · Member since 2016 · 6k+ posts · 7k+ votes
    5y

    @John Errico will be able to weigh in on New Haven. He went to school there, invested there, and still has holdover units there.

  • Attorney · Rutherford, NJ · Member since 2015 · 132 posts · 168 votes
    5y

    Thanks @Jonathan Greene—@Cami Danielle I think New Haven is a fairly tough market (and, right now, overpriced). I’ve owned several 2, 3, and 4 families there, and sold most (though still own one). I sold because the market there is nuts right now: everything going for way more than it has been trading at over the last few years. I’m about to list my remaining property.

    The thesis of m my investments there has been the idea that Yale and the other universities in New Haven have a vested interest in making sure New Haven is OK (or, ideally, nice), meaning that they will invest money in the community and expand their footprint to do so. Yale, in particular, has more money than some small countries, so they certainly have the financial means to invest in the city. That premise is generally true, but more particularly right around Yale and the other universities. Housing in those areas is very nice, and super pricey.

    Farther away, housing is much less nice (and much cheaper) but your chances of renting to college students is very low. Mostly, you’ll be renting to local residents (some of whom may be employed by the university), but they’re not paying the rents that students are. The Yale “bubble” is still centered quite closely around Yale, and that’s also true of the other schools there. Outside of those bubbles, New Haven struggles a lot with poverty, crime and homelessness and the city is far from straightforward to work with.

    I’ve struggled at essentially every property with rent collection except for properties where I had all Section 8 tenants. I made money via appreciation (and ultimately did well), but the rental income was, at best, treading water.

    If you’re up for the management challenge, buy right, and have a longer term horizon, I think you can do OK but it may be worthwhile to wait for the market to cool down a bit. I also wouldn’t count on doing great cash flow-wise, even if it looks on paper that it’s a good deal... you’re going to struggle with collections and evictions, in my experience. Unless you live there and are up for it, you’re going to need to find a great property manager. 

  • Member since 2021 · 6 posts · 2 votes
    5y

    @John Errico thanks that was super helpful. If you have any recommendations for property managers who are working the New Haven/West Haven area please let me know! 

  • New to Real Estate · Member since 2020 · 34 posts · 12 votes
    3y
    Quote from @John Errico:

    Thanks @Jonathan Greene—@Cami Danielle I think New Haven is a fairly tough market (and, right now, overpriced). I’ve owned several 2, 3, and 4 families there, and sold most (though still own one). I sold because the market there is nuts right now: everything going for way more than it has been trading at over the last few years. I’m about to list my remaining property.

    The thesis of m my investments there has been the idea that Yale and the other universities in New Haven have a vested interest in making sure New Haven is OK (or, ideally, nice), meaning that they will invest money in the community and expand their footprint to do so. Yale, in particular, has more money than some small countries, so they certainly have the financial means to invest in the city. That premise is generally true, but more particularly right around Yale and the other universities. Housing in those areas is very nice, and super pricey.

    Farther away, housing is much less nice (and much cheaper) but your chances of renting to college students is very low. Mostly, you’ll be renting to local residents (some of whom may be employed by the university), but they’re not paying the rents that students are. The Yale “bubble” is still centered quite closely around Yale, and that’s also true of the other schools there. Outside of those bubbles, New Haven struggles a lot with poverty, crime and homelessness and the city is far from straightforward to work with.

    I’ve struggled at essentially every property with rent collection except for properties where I had all Section 8 tenants. I made money via appreciation (and ultimately did well), but the rental income was, at best, treading water.

    If you’re up for the management challenge, buy right, and have a longer term horizon, I think you can do OK but it may be worthwhile to wait for the market to cool down a bit. I also wouldn’t count on doing great cash flow-wise, even if it looks on paper that it’s a good deal... you’re going to struggle with collections and evictions, in my experience. Unless you live there and are up for it, you’re going to need to find a great property manager. 


     Hi! Has this changed since? Can I reach out?

  • Member since 2023 · 1 post · 0 votes
    3y

    Looked into same idea…. Rentals for students a great idea, better is the foreign exchange students.  But make sure that the zoning will accommodate a boarding house v. Multi family. If the neighbors to your property bring it to the attention of the city(West Haven).  The zoning board can impose fines. 
    also need to adjust lease agreements to reflect tenants status. 
    in the end, with how lenders reflect potential rental income v mtg (dscr) harder to qualify the loan. 
    I’m sure that someone else has figured this out, if so, please share so that we all can benefit..

  • Flipper/Rehabber · NYC · Member since 2019 · 11 posts · 0 votes
    2y
    Quote from @Cami Danielle:

    Hi, 

    My name is Camila. I am interested in getting my first rental property in the New Haven or West Haven area of CT. The goal is to rent it to out to college students or long term tenants. I would love to connect with any investors or property managers in the area who are currently doing this!


     Hi Cami, Did you end up investing in New Haven? 

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.