However, this experiment in crowd-sourcing has resulted in a sort of local semi-celebrity status, with numerous mentions in area magazines, blogs, and whatnot.

I'd rather stay in my local area before going into other markets but understand that I might just need to go to other markets. 

Payment is expected immediately to stay in good faith with your Lease Agreement.If Payment is an issue please call me to discuss Payment details.If rent is not received on or before the 10th day of the month, a 3-Day Eviction Noticed will be served due to breach of contract.

Or those to stay away from?

M2M only without exception if you want to stay in control.

I have been trying to get closer to work, but if it makes more sense for my financial world (particularly REI) to stay here, I'm willing to do that.

There are numerous sites out there you can use to help you to figure this out as well: zillow, trulia, redfin, realtor.com etc. 

If you choose CL I would suggest you renew your post every 3 days to stay on top of the search.Happy Leasing!

Thus the most important factor in keeping these costs down are getting quality tenants who will stay in the home for long periods of time and take care of the property while they live there.  

All professionals I've spoken to say stay away because it's a SFR.