I saw some of your previous posts, so I'm glad you're getting closer to your first.I think your rent sounds pretty cheap between you and your fiance now, but I also don't know the COL in your area.Maybe if you found something comparable in price or slightly less, then it could still math out, because you'll be benefiting from appreciation, loan amortization, and potentially a housing expense decrease over the long term even if slightly. 

I would appreciate any insight.

This is an appreciating market and what you are trying to do is unbelievable.  

Any help on this would be greatly appreciated.

I have seen good returns in both cash flow and appreciation in this market.

Or is it something that guests won't appreciate or care about? 

Thank you so much Braden this is very helpful I appreciate it!

I would appreciate any advice.

@Chris Seveney Thank you for the response, and I appreciate the honesty, I hear that in one point they were paying well for house that why I had to ask.

Any guidance would be appreciated.