My vote is always to go with a) what interests you the most and b) what is more in line with your natural grain.

Cheap fix.If your tenant was willing to do a little investigating for you, they could use drops of food coloring to tell you which was leaking.If it's that much water, did you make sure there isn't a leaky pipe in the walls / in the lawn (coming from the water main or some external valve)?  

Walking distance to food store.

Also, the condo we saw was actually a newer condo built above the Whole Foods.

They have good food too. 

We told our tenants they could stay and pay the entire rent or move and we'd increase the rent to fair market value for the place.They stayed another year and then took off with 2 weeks notice and no last month rent, leaving a total mess behind including broken appliances they moved IN with (poor people tend to save EVERYTHING) a decrepit chest high freezer they unplugged half full of food that was impossible to describe as it was covered with maggots by the time we found it, and enough cheap clothing and mismatched shoes to clothe a one legged woman for a year.And these was a family where mom and dad were in their late 50's and dad was still working (the "best" kind of Section 8 family to find). 

Maybe I am a bit biased because I am most comfortable in the suburbs and am not one for city-living, so take this with a grain of salt...I am studying to be a physician and have trained at Niagara Memorial Hospital and I would get into this city and out as quickly as possible.

So will take that with a grain of salt. 

They also put on some luncheons that are good (I mean content and people... food's up to you).

May need to sand lightly because this will raise the grain of the wood.