I look forward to becoming a more active member of this awesome community!

He wanted to list at 159,900 and I thought 139,900 was a more accurate price.

I should note that the home was fully renovated -- had it been a more worn-in property, I could've probably gotten a better deal. 

No one complains about "that guy from Apartment A who parties until 1 AM" or "the girl from unit 45 has a boyfriend who keeps parking in my spot." 

It will more likely prompt a attack as opposed to protect you from one.Based on the fact that you state "they clear a decent profit most months" indicates it is a ongoing struggle and would be better to liquidate and move to a more secure and higher quality investment.

At that time I will run the info through the calculators for a more complete analysis.

It may be worth looking into different companies or finding a more transparent means of communication.

The older you are, the more prudent it typically is to go with the safe  option, while the younger you are a more aggressive approach will typically be the best option. 

If you are unsure, don't do the deal or get a more experienced investor's opinion or partner up.

My husband has a more business approach, and while he fixes everything else involving our properties, on this issue, he says it's not our property, not our tenants (can't control them).