Below are the numbers for just one home (they are identical) that I ran through the bigger pockets rental calculator.  

Ask if the underwriters will take a copy of their birth certificates as proof of identity. 

yes - the new rule of 90 days came into effect with HVCC - time adjustments have been dropped in favor of homes that are not actually comps - foreclosure that is next door to your totally renovated home that sold in 2 months is now better then the identiacal home with identical work 6 months ago.Now maybe it isn't exactally that but you get the point.

They were four duplexes with identical flour plans in an A area.

He bought some land and then built 3 identical houses, side by side, fully stocked with all appliances, weed wackers, rakes, brooms and lawn mowers, "turn key" homes, and then sold them for $50K each.  

I know that on the same block as my 4 plex, another nearly identical 4-plex recently sold for $192,000.

I came across 2 identical duplexes across the street from one another owned by the same seller.  

Very similar product, actually identical product.

looks like we have very identical backgrounds- accounting and re investing in Arlington.  

Does your advisor think that 2 identical properties, one in pristine condition and the other needing a gut rehab are equal in value?