-Sell the property and move on (but if I sell it, I imagine I need to find a tenant first to maximize the sales price...)Does anyone have any creative ideas of what I should consider doing with this property? 

My grandfather, along with his twin brother, were home builders who transitioned into building and managing a significant multi-family portfolio, which remains family managed to this day.With my personal family background, as an agent I have largely engaged in the multifamily space working with legacy owners in the sale of their properties - from 6 unit, single building properties to 19+ unit, multi-building properties.

If you mean that a degree in statistics or”gender studies” may not be useful in a career as a sales representative, you might be right.  

The average sales price in Cleveland Heights for MF in the last 6 months is $337k. 

I come from a decade of experience in sales, with a client base and network grounded in entrepeneurs, and executive/partners on Bay St (Canada's Wall St).

Purchase price: $850,000 Cash invested: $500,000 Sale price: $2,250,000 Purchased , knocked down, built new from ground up What made you interested in investing in this type of deal?

Tax-wise, only the rented portion is deductible, and depreciation recapture applies on sale, increasing taxable gains.

Purchase price: $12,000 Sale price: $18,000 Double wide on 2 lots by the lakes that needed completely gutted and rehabbed.

You'll want not just to go off of comp sales, but also potential income / cap rate calculation, and reproduction costs.

Purchase price: $28,500 Cash invested: $178,000 Sale price: $250,000 Bought a 3 unit riddled with drugs or prostitutes from the city at the tax auction, spent a year gutting and consolidating all three units in two structures to a single-family home with an exterior side entry garage.