There are people still moving to TN, which will continue to push pricing up, and while most of the country has seen rents either flatten or go down, most of these markets have done pretty good.Problem is in the short term it may  cause an affordability problem, especially in the smaller markets that don't have enough building.

Each time, we have to start from scratch with the support agents, making them verbatim read our messages with the guest, previous conversations with Airbnb support staff, and then Airbnb's review policy.What can cause a review to get reinstated like this?

What damage could it possibly cause that their security deposit wouldn't be able to handle, worst case scenario? 

(Yes it’s a thing there’s little sidewalk plows/snow throwers that the town will own.)The landlord is definitely responsible for snow removal from the rooftops which if it builds up can cause ice dams or worse collapse your roof.

I at least try to avoid losses caused by the departing tenant.

Its been great while working in the house with the rehab, however I am concerned with a Tennant taking advantage of this: smoking inside, not opening the windows while running it causing a backdraft from other appliances like the water heater which would cause it not able to vent to the outside properly, and I'm sure there are others. 

The main house came vacant and a charity wanted to rent it for a good cause.

So, I can understand exceeding the 5% range but $1800 is 20% which for an average tenant could destabilize them or cause them to need to move.

I would push hard on HOA on what they are doing to treat it When one of my condos had a mouse problem they also went into every unit to treat and charged each homeowner which we were fine with because they also could see if there was a specific homeowner who was the cause and then after treatment go back after them for future incidents

They already caused the harm by losing the 1st deal.