Las Terrenas in the Samana peninsula is a good choice but I have a small thing for Bayahibe, close to la Romana.You can find property that are half the price of Punta Cana's and that you can rent around 80% of the year.

You need some descent reserves to be a larger landlord, because you don't get a choice when the AC unit goes out, or the hot water heater floods the upstairs unit that then floods the downstairs unit.  

If you’re okay with not making much monthly profit and focusing on long-term gains, brick could be a solid choice.

That makes sense making the move to a MF is a great choice more doors more cash flow. 

Make smart choices by guessing your money flow, asking local pros for advice, and looking closely at the house.

I also know their level of service went drastically down and would not be my top choice currently.2.

There are lots of choices.

I am not advocating one over the other, it is a personal choice, as much as indicating likely reality  Good luck

Better yet, if no other easy choice, force your lender to the negotiating table.  

Just go to Airbnb and search for a place to stay and you will see how decked out all the homes are and how many are available and hence, how startlingly low some of the rates are for such nice houses.It can be done but if cash flow is a top priority it would not be my top choice right now.