Originally posted by @Arn Cenedella:
@Account Closed
There’s no correct answer to this, just having a discussion.
There are pros and cons points and counter-points to every perspective.
It appears your preference for REITs is more about liquidity issues than vetting issues, which I understand.
I would suggest illiquidity can be an advantage as it prevents investors from making sudden moves when times get bad.
For a recent example, let’s pick Covid. Stock investors who sold after the initial collapse of the market (Spring 2020) now regret that decision. Those who just sat tight, held their stocks have been handsomely rewarded as the market went to all-time highs. Same with real estate - those that panic sold Spring 2020 would also now regret that decision.
Having illiquid investments prevents investors from making emotional (short term knee jerk) decisions.
The one property v multiple property issue cuts both ways. Many investors want to invest in a specific property in a specific location - they prefer to know what they are buying as opposed to not knowing what specific properties they will own thru a REIT.
At the end of the day, each investor needs to sort thru those issues for themselves. It’s not a black and white thing, it’s not an either or thing, it can be a both and thing.
"I would suggest illiquidity can be an advantage as it prevents investors from making sudden moves when times get bad.
For
a recent example, let’s pick Covid. Stock investors who sold after the
initial collapse of the market (Spring 2020) now regret that decision.
Those who just sat tight, held their stocks have been handsomely
rewarded as the market went to all-time highs. Same with real estate -
those that panic sold Spring 2020 would also now regret that decision."
But this is exactly one of the benefits of liquidity I love. The Covid crash in 3rd week of march 2020 was bonanza for me. I loaded up on things I had on my shopping list and got them for historic discounts. I hadn't had a buy opportunity like that in years. The panic sellers are a blessing for me.
What I missed though, was loading up on some REITs I wanted in 2020.