Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here

Join Over 3 Million Real Estate Investors

Create a free BiggerPockets account to comment, participate, and connect with over 3 million real estate investors.
Use your real name
By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions.
The community here is like my own little personal real estate army that I can depend upon to help me through ANY problems I come across.
Rehabbing & House Flipping
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

Updated over 5 years ago, 04/16/2019

User Stats

15,745
Posts
10,941
Votes
Will Barnard
Pro Member
  • Developer
  • Santa Clarita, CA
10,941
Votes |
15,745
Posts

The Occupants from Hell!

Will Barnard
Pro Member
  • Developer
  • Santa Clarita, CA
ModeratorPosted

I am currently dealing with some occupants (who are no more than squatters) and getting them out so I can get in and start the rehab has been a daunting process. Typically, I get them out with cash for keys and it is never easy, but usually effective.

In this case, I purchased the property (practically stole it on price and terms)Feb 28th of this year and am still working on getting these morons out. I offered them $6k! for keys and they did not take it. I started eviction and they have used every tactic in the book to cause delays and extend the process. On the final hour before the summary judgement hearing, one of the two occupants filed for BK causing another 45 day or so delay. Unfortunately in CA, the laws, for some stupid reason, reside with occupants and not the legal owners. (I wont even get started on politics here!)

The good news is that I was able to have summary judgement against one of the occupants and already filed for the Sherriff to remove her from the premises. Should be within the next week or so for that. The kicker is that once it happens, her boyfriend still has rights to be there (until he is finally evicted) so I am quite sure she will just come right back. When that happens, I will make damn sure I make their lives as miserable as possible for the problems they have caused me. How can I do that legally you might ask? I will have periodic visits to the property and when I see she is there, I will call the Sherriff and inform them that she is illegally trespassing on my property and I want her removed/arrested. I will do this as many times as it takes until they get the point or until summary judgement against him occurs. Either way, screw them both!!! :roll:
What comes around goes around and theirs is coming.

***Update as of today 1-31-16: 5 years and 32 thread pages later, this is still ongoing. The following link was created by a BP Member in support of my situation found on page 32 of this thread. https://www.gofundme.com/OccupantsfromHell

This was approved by the heads of BP to be live in this thread. ***

User Stats

15,745
Posts
10,941
Votes
Will Barnard
Pro Member
  • Developer
  • Santa Clarita, CA
10,941
Votes |
15,745
Posts
Will Barnard
Pro Member
  • Developer
  • Santa Clarita, CA
ModeratorReplied
Originally posted by Calvin Lamb:
Wow. I am a N. CA resident with 1 deal under my belt here but stories like this are why I am considering another market for my next deal.

Good luck to you Will.

In all fairness, my particular situation is pretty much a first and even more rare than rare so don't let it discourage you from investing here in CA or anywhere for that matter, just protect yourself the best you can and do your homework the best you can.

There is just no simple or viable way to avoid getting hit by a meteorite!

User Stats

1
Posts
0
Votes
Valerie Chin
  • Hudson, FL
0
Votes |
1
Posts
Valerie Chin
  • Hudson, FL
Replied

my last tenant ripped out all of the wiring from the attic, during the 60 days it took to get her out, I can't prove it, but I noticed you may have not served your tenant like I did, the company I hired served her, and any unknown occupant that resides with her at the same time, it was on her lease that no unknown occupants were allowed to stay, I find the nicer you are to some renters, the more spiteful they behave, and I know now how disgusted -----you begin to feel. But don't give up and follow suit if they do any damages, even if you don't get awarded, you can prove with pictures--- the fact of vandalization to your home. Shame on them, karma will be their result......we all reap what we sow... Just follow the law and don't get yourself in trouble. I wound up giving the keys to the police to check the wiring and all the places where she may have sold the copper. The police wound up arressting at least 3 people for trying to break in while it was empty......So sow good smart moves especially right now....they want to aggravate you so much that you will lose it.....and just Don't stoop to their level, that's how they win. Just follow the law, and learn, and know that at least you are nothing like them. Make it hard to rent for them again, by placing them in any bad tenant registry or a small claims court judgement for the damages. Good luck........but don't let them win by getting under your skin........anyone who would destroy another person's property is nothing but a loser anyway, but you don't want them to say you gave them aggravation while they were living there....I had 3 bad tenants in a row here in Florida, I never believed the other landlords who said I was too nice and had sucker written on my forehead, but now I know why most tenants I interviewed said there were nothing but slumlords out there.........not true....what was true was what the realtors all told me, that I was too nice and believed ever sorry *** story they gave me.....My home was so gorgeous, If I showed you the before and after pictures......OMG.....don't think I'll ever want to be a landlord again....flip homes yes, but I'm burnt out...and this never happened in NY, so I feel for you......But God sees everything.....so just do what you can within the law ....they'll get theirs eventually

CV3 Financial logo
CV3 Financial
|
Sponsored
Fix & Flip | DSCR | Construction Loans Up to 90% LTV - Up to 80% Cash Out - No Income Verification - No Seasoning Requirements

User Stats

42
Posts
33
Votes
Richard Redding
  • Investor
  • Round Rock, TX
33
Votes |
42
Posts
Richard Redding
  • Investor
  • Round Rock, TX
Replied

I'd say you're determined to see it to thru to the end in the court system. I can respect that.

I'm interested about whether you'll be seeking revenge (the legal type). Earlier someone posted about reporting him to the IRS and the disability people. After you win in court, those sound viable.

One other thought, perhaps you could get him arrested for something else. Or perhaps he could 'win' a trip. But if you got him out of the property for few days, you could change the locks, tow his car, haul away his property, install a new aggressive temporary tenant, etc. Check with your attorney, but seems even in the CA legal system your claim to the place is at least as valid as his. And with the situation reversed, his attorney would need more money for the more complicated situation...money which we believe your occupant does not have.

I'm not an attorney, obviously, but just sayin.....

User Stats

4,302
Posts
3,988
Votes
Jerry W.
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Thermopolis, WY
3,988
Votes |
4,302
Posts
Jerry W.
Pro Member
  • Investor
  • Thermopolis, WY
ModeratorReplied

Will Barnard just a few thoughts off the top of my head. Be sure to run them past your attorney before you try any of them. One if the guy claimed to be married, you need to try to check his disability to see if he listed it in applying for it, any false statement might void it. Next, the judge might allow an independant property inspection company to do an inspection on the house to protect your interest, that way if it is damaged you have evidence and can notify law enforcement in case of actual vandalism. also allways counterclaim for money even if you cannot collect. You can allways forgive the debt, file a legal 1099 and send a copy to the agency he gets disability from, it may make him ineligible. Depending on his disability you can hire an investigator to follow him to get evidence its not real. If you get a judgement but choose not to forgive it, do the work to report it to credit companies so it dogs his record. Do depositions or interrogatories to find out his sources of income, and bank accounts to collect from, however disability usually cannot be garnished unless it is coomingled with nonexempt money. Finally listen to your attorney, he is an expert on this. This is not an eviction it is a contested case to see who is the legal owner. A court might grant you possession if you post a superseades bond but the cost will be high to do that. You also have an action against the seller. They would have used a warranty deed I assume so they have an opbligation to get you clear title, possibly interplead them. I have done similar cases, one where the GF claimed she married the deceased owner while on a vacation to a common law state, and a palimoney claim from a GF who lived in California. We won both but they took forever, and were expensive. Good luck!

  • Jerry W.
  • User Stats

    3,864
    Posts
    3,545
    Votes
    Rick H.#4 Marketing Your Property Contributor
    • Lender
    • Greater LA/Orange County area, CA
    3,545
    Votes |
    3,864
    Posts
    Rick H.#4 Marketing Your Property Contributor
    • Lender
    • Greater LA/Orange County area, CA
    Replied

    @Will - read this long thread and, geez, welcome to 'advanced real estate investing 501'. We met a few weeks ago at Bruce Norris event. Sorry I was so distracted with other competing or attention. Here's a little bit of "outside the casket" thinking for you.

    Let me offer another strategy to consider. If this is truly an investment property and you do not intend to use as your principal residence, perhaps you'd consider taking the profit and leave the possession to the next buyer. The plan that I would employ is to sell the property to another buyer and let hem deal with the squatters' equitable title and possessory claims.

    Since listing and selling would require interior inspections, as would most auction services, I would consider letting it go (or causing it) to foreclosure sale on the outstanding mortgage. Lots of trustee sale buyers desperate to find any product and willing to pay higher than you could sell net of a retail sale. Coupled on tip of this is the appreciation that you have benefitted from during the lengthy protracted legal battle.

    Now, the objective is to let the property go to sale and claim the surplus funds per CC 2924(j, k). If you have any doubt about claiming, record a performance trust deed junior to your lender's TD for an option or similar claim to the equity. The surplus should inure to you.

    The lesson may be obvious to you but not others: One of the unfortunate aspects of successful real estate investing is that we encounter the 'garage sale of civilization' (term appropriated from Cantu) and we get to deal with their bad behavior.

    The primary consolation of being the "squattee" here is that you'll make money and the parasite squatters will have to find a new host.

    User Stats

    15,745
    Posts
    10,941
    Votes
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    10,941
    Votes |
    15,745
    Posts
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    ModeratorReplied

    Hey Rick, it was great meeting you in person at the Norris event.
    As far as your suggestions, they have already been examined and are not possible in this situation due to the fact that neither the first or second lender may foreclose as the judge has an order to stay foreclosure.

    User Stats

    365
    Posts
    75
    Votes
    Charles Morgan
    • Investor
    • El Paso/Socorro, TX
    75
    Votes |
    365
    Posts
    Charles Morgan
    • Investor
    • El Paso/Socorro, TX
    Replied

    It's been a month since the last update. I really hope you have good news. By the way, can you post the names so we will be prepared if they come our way?

    User Stats

    15,745
    Posts
    10,941
    Votes
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    10,941
    Votes |
    15,745
    Posts
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    ModeratorReplied

    Court date is in a couple weeks. No news to give as nothing has or can happen until court date.

    User Stats

    628
    Posts
    251
    Votes
    Don Hines
    • Investor
    • Little Rock, AR
    251
    Votes |
    628
    Posts
    Don Hines
    • Investor
    • Little Rock, AR
    Replied

    WOW
    I don't get in here as often as I used to. I am shocked to see this thread is still alive and you are still batteling the situation. Stay after them!!
    Don

    User Stats

    15,745
    Posts
    10,941
    Votes
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    10,941
    Votes |
    15,745
    Posts
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    ModeratorReplied

    Anybody ever wonder if Murphy's Law was real or not? My situation with this house proves it does exist - what can happen, will!

    I was suppose to start the trial this Friday, and I ended up in court yesterday for an ex parte hearing filed by opposing counsel. Apparently, the judge is leaving this court as of this Friday and thus, can not hear this case as it will likely go into the following Monday, so yet again, the case has been postponed. The judge did say that these delays have become ridiculous and that he wanted it set for 2 weeks out, of course the court did not have any slots available for another 6 weeks. These occupants have to have some kind of luck as they are now granted another 6 weeks of free room and board on my dime. Argh!!!!

    User Stats

    838
    Posts
    295
    Votes
    Chris Masons
    • Investor
    • Union, NJ
    295
    Votes |
    838
    Posts
    Chris Masons
    • Investor
    • Union, NJ
    Replied

    Good Lord Will! Unbelieveable!! You know things are ridiculous when the judge makes a comment like that.

    I just hope the newly assigned judge can see all the delays and skumbag measures their attorneey has been taking to get all the adjournments for the last year at least???

    You gotta believe that these losers will have no legal defense when they stand face to face and get their day in court.

    Almost there brother......

    Chris

    Chris

    User Stats

    838
    Posts
    295
    Votes
    Chris Masons
    • Investor
    • Union, NJ
    295
    Votes |
    838
    Posts
    Chris Masons
    • Investor
    • Union, NJ
    Replied

    Jeez, I just looked at the date on the first thread post. ALmost 2.5 years????!!!!

    Vacasa logo
    Vacasa
    |
    Sponsored
    We do the work. You get the ROI. We do it all for your vacation rental. All—marketing, pricing, guest requests, housekeeping & more.

    User Stats

    15,745
    Posts
    10,941
    Votes
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    10,941
    Votes |
    15,745
    Posts
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    ModeratorReplied
    Originally posted by Chris Masons:
    Jeez, I just looked at the date on the first thread post. ALmost 2.5 years????!!!!

    Next week it will be 2 years and 7 months of ownership and never been inside or had access or ability to transfer title. What comes around goes around and I am hoping that in which I believe comes true for these jerks.

    User Stats

    3,280
    Posts
    3,064
    Votes
    Michaela G.
    • Investor
    • Atlanta, GA
    3,064
    Votes |
    3,280
    Posts
    Michaela G.
    • Investor
    • Atlanta, GA
    Replied

    Unbelievable!

    But how much has the value gone up since you bought it? You might look back and be happy that you had this forced delay

    User Stats

    1,400
    Posts
    899
    Votes
    Troy Sheets
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Philadelphia, PA
    899
    Votes |
    1,400
    Posts
    Troy Sheets
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Philadelphia, PA
    Replied

    Flabbergasted and speechless don't even come close to covering my reactions to the challenges you're facing! It's ludicrous that you've owned this property for this long and been denied it. I'm impressed with your persistence and positive attitude, thanks for sharing with us!!!

  • Troy Sheets
  • User Stats

    1,083
    Posts
    412
    Votes
    Deborah Burian
    Pro Member
    • Rental Property Investor
    • Oklahoma City, OK
    412
    Votes |
    1,083
    Posts
    Deborah Burian
    Pro Member
    • Rental Property Investor
    • Oklahoma City, OK
    Replied

    @Will Barnard - awww, I listened to your podcast Tuesday and was excited for you that they would finally be gone. Makes my most annoying tenant look like a mere boil on my, ermmm, arm.

  • Deborah Burian
  • User Stats

    252
    Posts
    56
    Votes
    Jim M.
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Charlotte, NC
    56
    Votes |
    252
    Posts
    Jim M.
    • Real Estate Investor
    • Charlotte, NC
    Replied

    Just amazing.

    User Stats

    825
    Posts
    486
    Votes
    Kevin Yeats
    • Lender
    • Fort Pierce, FL
    486
    Votes |
    825
    Posts
    Kevin Yeats
    • Lender
    • Fort Pierce, FL
    Replied

    Take notes.

    Write a book.

    There is a screenplay in this mess someplace.

    Sincerely, my sympathies. This is beyond ridiculous.

    User Stats

    15,745
    Posts
    10,941
    Votes
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    10,941
    Votes |
    15,745
    Posts
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    ModeratorReplied

    Thanks for the support everyone.

    As to the question of value increase, that may be a saving grace, however, the price actually was slightly down after purchase and stagnant for some time. It has been the last year that has assisted in some value increase. In total between the down and the up, I would estimate an upward increase of approx. $20k which does not even come close to covering the legal des, let alone all the holding costs for what will be 3 years. If I break even on the deal, I will throw a party and call it a win!

    User Stats

    350
    Posts
    230
    Votes
    Paul Choate
    Pro Member
    • Attorney
    • Shawnee, OK
    230
    Votes |
    350
    Posts
    Paul Choate
    Pro Member
    • Attorney
    • Shawnee, OK
    Replied

    Will,

    Sorry to hear about all of your problems with this case. I am a bankruptcy attorney by day and one thing you may want to check or have your attorney check is the squatter's bankruptcy filings. One of the problems with lying is keeping your story straight and if this individual used different attorneys then he may have said different things about his situation to different courts. The bankruptcy filings are sworn under oath. If he said he was married on them, then he lied (I am assuming you are correct on this point). If he said he wasn't then he lied on the state court proceedings. Additionally, if he did not disclose the house as an asset he also lied on his bankruptcy schedules.

    This may not help your situation end sooner but it could make the squatter's life much more difficult if you can introduce criminal charges to the mix. Talk to your attorney or call the chapter 7 trustee listed on his case. You may also want to contact the U.S. trustee's office and the F.B.I. who investigates bankruptcy crimes. All of the bankruptcy pleadings are available online at www.pacer.gov. Good Luck! (Don't expect too much, trustees vary greatly in how much they care about this stuff. They aren't going to get any money from him so they may just take a pass on it. But, it might be worth a shot at this point.)

  • Paul Choate
  • User Stats

    350
    Posts
    230
    Votes
    Paul Choate
    Pro Member
    • Attorney
    • Shawnee, OK
    230
    Votes |
    350
    Posts
    Paul Choate
    Pro Member
    • Attorney
    • Shawnee, OK
    Replied

    The reason I think it is possible he did not list it in the bk is you mentioned a 45 day stay coming from the bankruptcy filing. This is generally for renters so I am assuming that he did not list the property as an asset. If he had listed it as his property, the stay should extend even longer unless you filed a motion to lift the stay. This motion can be completed in about 45 days from filing so if that was the case, he may have disclosed it as an asset.

    *please note this is not legal advice. I am just trying to explain what may have happened. I am only licensed in Oklahoma.

  • Paul Choate
  • User Stats

    15,745
    Posts
    10,941
    Votes
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    10,941
    Votes |
    15,745
    Posts
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    ModeratorReplied

    Thanks for the wisdom Paul, I will forward your info and advice to my attorney.

    BiggerPockets logo
    Join Our Private Community for Passive Investors
    |
    BiggerPockets
    Get first-hand insights and real sponsor reviews from other investors

    User Stats

    7,658
    Posts
    4,299
    Votes
    Roy N.
    Pro Member
    • Rental Property Investor
    • Fredericton, New Brunswick
    4,299
    Votes |
    7,658
    Posts
    Roy N.
    Pro Member
    • Rental Property Investor
    • Fredericton, New Brunswick
    ModeratorReplied

    @Will Barnard

    It just occurred to me, you purchased this house 2-days after my son was born. He's now a toddler who loves walking though houses with me! I couldn't imagine waiting this long to get a squatter out of a property!

    It also strikes me that your squatters could have turned this into their own reality TV show had they looked at the opportunity before them ... might have helped with their legal bills? Then again, if they had that level of foresight, they probably wouldn't be squatting.

  • Roy N.
  • User Stats

    15,745
    Posts
    10,941
    Votes
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    10,941
    Votes |
    15,745
    Posts
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    ModeratorReplied

    If anyone was getting a show out of this, it would be me!

    User Stats

    15,745
    Posts
    10,941
    Votes
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    10,941
    Votes |
    15,745
    Posts
    Will Barnard
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Santa Clarita, CA
    ModeratorReplied

    Court upcoming next week, it has been a terribly long and rough road.