Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here

Join Over 3 Million Real Estate Investors

Create a free BiggerPockets account to comment, participate, and connect with over 3 million real estate investors.
Use your real name
By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions.
The community here is like my own little personal real estate army that I can depend upon to help me through ANY problems I come across.
Short-Term & Vacation Rental Discussions
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

Updated about 2 years ago, 10/26/2022

User Stats

46
Posts
10
Votes
Zigmunt Smigaj
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Colorado Springs, Co
10
Votes |
46
Posts

STR Insurance Policy... who do you use?

Zigmunt Smigaj
  • Rental Property Investor
  • Colorado Springs, Co
Posted

I cant find a STR insurance policy that inst 5000-1000 in Florida (Quote from Proper Insurance), this kills a lot of profit. Who do you use and how much is normal for a Florida insurance policy either as a business through a LLC or personally held as a landlord. And if you've encountered issues with either.

User Stats

12,128
Posts
14,536
Votes
John Underwood
Pro Member
#1 Short-Term & Vacation Rental Discussions Contributor
  • Investor
  • Greer, SC
14,536
Votes |
12,128
Posts
John Underwood
Pro Member
#1 Short-Term & Vacation Rental Discussions Contributor
  • Investor
  • Greer, SC
Replied

Foremost had a better policy than Cbiz or Proper for me. They even cover my boat dock. 

  • John Underwood
  • User Stats

    285
    Posts
    245
    Votes
    Marshall Leipprandt
    • Real Estate Agent
    • Miramar Beach, FL
    245
    Votes |
    285
    Posts
    Marshall Leipprandt
    • Real Estate Agent
    • Miramar Beach, FL
    Replied

    @Zigmunt Smigaj My two policies are $6K and $7K annually and they are with Frontline. I got to them through an insurance broker who I work with who shopped out rates. Both of my flood policies are each around $1K annually and are through Neptune.

    Operating in FL, there is no way to get around the cost of insurance with the current status of the industry. 

    I haven't encountered issues with my current providers but was with FedNat a year ago before they sent me cancellation notices. They were dropping policies all across the state so I was left scrambling to line up new carriers last minute which was stressful. I think that is always going to be an option on the table too just because insurance in FL is so fickle.

    Vacasa logo
    Vacasa
    |
    Sponsored
    We do the work. You get the ROI. We do it all for your vacation rental. All—marketing, pricing, guest requests, housekeeping & more.

    User Stats

    1,261
    Posts
    981
    Votes
    Leslie Anne Morris
    • Real Estate Agent
    • Smoky Mountains, TN
    981
    Votes |
    1,261
    Posts
    Leslie Anne Morris
    • Real Estate Agent
    • Smoky Mountains, TN
    Replied

    I use Proper and I was using them in Florida but it was condo insurance/non-beachfront.

    User Stats

    46
    Posts
    10
    Votes
    Zigmunt Smigaj
    • Rental Property Investor
    • Colorado Springs, Co
    10
    Votes |
    46
    Posts
    Zigmunt Smigaj
    • Rental Property Investor
    • Colorado Springs, Co
    Replied
    Quote from @John Underwood:

    Foremost had a better policy than Cbiz or Proper for me. They even cover my boat dock. 


    Thanks I'm reaching out to them now for a quote. So far I'm seeking quotes from Proper, CBIZ, Foremost, and a couple local brokers. None of the national carriers (travelers, Alstate, American Modern, or Statefarm) insure STR or property in FL... very odd. Goes to show the industry is all about the insurance company and not the insured.

    My assumption is the profit of ABNB justifies the premium. 

    This property is in Largo, not beach front, roughly 5-7 miles from any coastline and no history of hurricane damage. Just a plane old SFH with a pool.

    User Stats

    11,500
    Posts
    13,273
    Votes
    Bruce Woodruff
    Pro Member
    #1 Contractors Contributor
    • Contractor/Investor/Consultant
    • West Valley Phoenix
    13,273
    Votes |
    11,500
    Posts
    Bruce Woodruff
    Pro Member
    #1 Contractors Contributor
    • Contractor/Investor/Consultant
    • West Valley Phoenix
    Replied

    I use State Farm, but that's in Arizona. $100 a month on average...

    User Stats

    3,717
    Posts
    2,566
    Votes
    Kerry Baird
    Pro Member
    • Rental Property Investor
    • Melbourne, FL
    2,566
    Votes |
    3,717
    Posts
    Kerry Baird
    Pro Member
    • Rental Property Investor
    • Melbourne, FL
    Replied
    I use Foremost, Proper, and Obie.  Dang nab it, insurance is expensive in Florida!

    User Stats

    3,757
    Posts
    3,106
    Votes
    Kenneth Garrett
    Pro Member
    • Investor
    • Florida Panhandle/Illinois
    3,106
    Votes |
    3,757
    Posts
    Kenneth Garrett
    Pro Member
    • Investor
    • Florida Panhandle/Illinois
    Replied

    You can try Goosehead Insurance.  They are a Florida Insurance Company.  I tried to use Proper, but they stopped issuing policies in my area. 

  • Kenneth Garrett
  • User Stats

    898
    Posts
    805
    Votes
    Dan Maciejewski
    Agent
    • Realtor
    • PInellas County Largo, FL
    805
    Votes |
    898
    Posts
    Dan Maciejewski
    Agent
    • Realtor
    • PInellas County Largo, FL
    Replied
    Quote from @Zigmunt Smigaj:

    I cant find a STR insurance policy that inst 5000-1000 in Florida (Quote from Proper Insurance), this kills a lot of profit. Who do you use and how much is normal for a Florida insurance policy either as a business through a LLC or personally held as a landlord. And if you've encountered issues with either.

    I let all my clients know that insurance in FL is a nightmare, and only getting worse.  It definitely cuts into ROI, but we do have great ADR and occupancy!

    Your costs will vary based on your coverage and how much your building's worth.   I have a lot of clients in the West Central Pinellas area.  A lot of them have had good luck with a broker on Seminole Blvd -- Masi Insurance.  I haven't met him, but he's gotten the best quotes for sure.  I've seen others have quotes of 13k that he's gotten down to  around 7k.  For the average house (500-600k), I'm seeing 3,500-5,500 for STR insurance.

    User Stats

    465
    Posts
    376
    Votes
    Trent Reeve
    • Rental Property Investor
    • Atlanta
    376
    Votes |
    465
    Posts
    Trent Reeve
    • Rental Property Investor
    • Atlanta
    Replied
    Quote from @Zigmunt Smigaj:
    Quote from @John Underwood:

    Foremost had a better policy than Cbiz or Proper for me. They even cover my boat dock. 


    Thanks I'm reaching out to them now for a quote. So far I'm seeking quotes from Proper, CBIZ, Foremost, and a couple local brokers. None of the national carriers (travelers, Alstate, American Modern, or Statefarm) insure STR or property in FL... very odd. Goes to show the industry is all about the insurance company and not the insured.

    My assumption is the profit of ABNB justifies the premium. 

    This property is in Largo, not beach front, roughly 5-7 miles from any coastline and no history of hurricane damage. Just a plane old SFH with a pool.


     just went thru this, closing on my 1st property in Panama City beach today. I was surprised at the high cost. If you want to message me, i will share who i used (just in case sharing would break any rules). 

    User Stats

    7
    Posts
    1
    Votes
    Replied
    Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:

    I use State Farm, but that's in Arizona. $100 a month on average...


    I wasn't aware State Farm supplied STR insurance, but as I'm a longtime loyalist to them on main property and currently in closing process of first STR... getting quote and attempting to be specific on the approximate occupancy of outsiders, fingers crossed they're accustomed to it to some degree here (Oklahoma). $100/month avg seems wildly cheap though, and its potentially bc we're talking about different size/scope of properties? Mine=$600k lakefront, dwelling closer to half that...300-400k.

    User Stats

    11,500
    Posts
    13,273
    Votes
    Bruce Woodruff
    Pro Member
    #1 Contractors Contributor
    • Contractor/Investor/Consultant
    • West Valley Phoenix
    13,273
    Votes |
    11,500
    Posts
    Bruce Woodruff
    Pro Member
    #1 Contractors Contributor
    • Contractor/Investor/Consultant
    • West Valley Phoenix
    Replied
    Quote from @Ryan Sappington:

    It may depend on specific area, but I asked my agent specifically for insurance for a "Short Term Rental, y'know. like an AIRBnB..." and they knew immediately which product to offer me. It's commercial insurance.

    User Stats

    7
    Posts
    1
    Votes
    Replied
    Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:
    Quote from @Ryan Sappington:

    It may depend on specific area, but I asked my agent specifically for insurance for a "Short Term Rental, y'know. like an AIRBnB..." and they knew immediately which product to offer me. It's commercial insurance.

    Awesome, very helpful, thanks! I attempted a very similar approach to say "look, im aiming to have this rented out for a third or up to half the year via AirBNB... and want that factored in for liability sake more than anything, not interested in any supplemental loss of rental income" .... she simply replied "Oh, ok, did not know that... good to know, I can up the liability to $1M to cover you in that regard, and add the 'Home Rental' package to it that is $271 annually". So, doesn't sound commercial IMO, but now I'm even more curious @Bruce Woodruff how much of a variance that is from what yours ended up being.   

    Baselane logo
    Baselane
    |
    Sponsored
    Baselane is the Ultimate All-In-One Banking Platform for REI Built with integrated rent collection & bookkeeping to save time so you can grow your RE business.

    User Stats

    2,099
    Posts
    1,638
    Votes
    Andrew Steffens
    Pro Member
    #2 Short-Term & Vacation Rental Discussions Contributor
    • Tampa, FL
    1,638
    Votes |
    2,099
    Posts
    Andrew Steffens
    Pro Member
    #2 Short-Term & Vacation Rental Discussions Contributor
    • Tampa, FL
    Replied

    I have an agent out of Miami that gets great rates, usually with Citizens but depends on property (distance to water, etc).  PM me if you still need and I will share her contact info!

  • Andrew Steffens
  • [email protected]
  • 813-563-0877
  • User Stats

    93
    Posts
    54
    Votes
    Derick Bonsu
    • Investor
    • Washington, DC
    54
    Votes |
    93
    Posts
    Derick Bonsu
    • Investor
    • Washington, DC
    Replied
    Quote from @Bruce Woodruff:

    I use State Farm, but that's in Arizona. $100 a month on average...

     So jealous. Come to Florida.

    But to answer your question, @Zigmunt Smigaj 5K sounds about normal. I pay a little over 5K. The only way to get around it is to increase your minimum to 30+ Days, but then you're not really doing STR.

    User Stats

    52
    Posts
    39
    Votes
    Kathy Cooper
    • Investor
    • Naples, ME
    39
    Votes |
    52
    Posts
    Kathy Cooper
    • Investor
    • Naples, ME
    Replied

    I'm not in FL but have found Foremost to be half of Proper Ins recently. Yes, apples to apples. Not sure why. Foremost has been a good co. for me so far. Easy to work with. Yes, STR insurance is something to make sure you figure into your numbers...

    User Stats

    54
    Posts
    35
    Votes
    Barrett Bridgewater
    • Surveyor
    35
    Votes |
    54
    Posts
    Replied

    @Marshall Leipprandt have you looked into the possibility of removing the FEMA flood designation off your buildings? There is a potential that your buildings sit above the flood level and would then qualify for removing the flood designation. That would result in removing any lender requirement to purchase flood, and would free you up to decide if you think flood insurance is truly wanted.

    We've had some success on the Panhandle doing this. The FEMA flood maps can be highly inaccurate... which places buildings in flood zones that shouldn't be. Even if it is off by 1inch, that can make a big difference.

    User Stats

    68
    Posts
    40
    Votes
    Dan Slaughter
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Georgia
    40
    Votes |
    68
    Posts
    Dan Slaughter
    Pro Member
    • Developer
    • Georgia
    Replied

    @Marshall Leipprandt. What is the process to remove a structure from the FEMA flood designation? Just received my renewal letter, my house on 30A went from just over $11k to almost $18k. That's a punch in the gut for sure.

  • Dan Slaughter
  • User Stats

    285
    Posts
    245
    Votes
    Marshall Leipprandt
    • Real Estate Agent
    • Miramar Beach, FL
    245
    Votes |
    285
    Posts
    Marshall Leipprandt
    • Real Estate Agent
    • Miramar Beach, FL
    Replied

    @Barrett Bridgewater My current properties are actually not in FEMA designated flood zones, but I elect to have flood insurance simply for peace of mind.

    @Dan Slaughter That is insane! I think @Barrett Bridgewater might have an answer to that question as I have not done it before for my properties. I'm guessing your jump up is the combined increase in cost between your homeowners and flood policies? We've got a fairly large rental property whose flood policy is $1K and the homeowners is just under $7K. Even our "smaller" rental is $1K flood and $6K homeowners, but neither are in FEMA flood zones, we just choose to pay the additional $ for the peace of mind.