Borrowing from my aunt

Borrowing from my aunt

Astoria, NY · Member since 2013 · 40 posts · 4 votes

Hey guys,

I looked for a similar thread and couldn't find one. If a similar question has already been answered, feel free to point me in that direction :)

Basically, my aunt wants to partner up on REI. However, I think it would be better to get a loan from her instead of partnering together as investors. She wants to put in the money and just receive a RIO, and that's completely fine as far as I'm concerned. However, I would want control over the asset if I'm putting in the sweat equity. If I decide to sell or refinance down the road, I wouldn't want to have to convince a partner to agree with me. I would want to just be able to do it. I apologize if this is a really long question.

Here's what I'm thinking. Is this realistic? Is this a good strategy? Keep in mind, I'm keeping the numbers simple in this example.

Let's say I borrow $20,000 from her for a 10 year loan at 6.5%. I haven't pitched these numbers to her so if these are good…bad…whatever, I'd love to know what you guys think :)

From what I understand, a traditional mortgage lender will see this as a red flag as I'm essentially borrowing money in order to borrow money. So I may be better off finding someone who will do seller financing (I'm willing to make a lot of phone calls). I can also negotiate the mortgage rate with the seller if I take this route?

I read  Brandon Turner's eBook and I love his strategy. Let's say I find a house that's worth $100k, I purchase it for $80k, and put $20k down. I try to charge 1% - 2% of the value in rent each month ($1k - $2k per mo). But I understand it's difficult to even get 1% per month now-a-days?

Am I correct in thinking that I would pay my aunt $227.10 per month for 10 years. She would receive a total of $27,251.30 or a 36.26% ROI. This would be a good deal for her, right? She just wants to put the money in. She isn't interested in putting in the research or sweat equity and, again, that's fine.

That means I would pay my aunt $227.10 per month and I'd pay the seller, if I get a current mortgage at 3.554%, $270.90 per month. That's a total of $498 per month excluding taxes, repairs, etc. That's really going to cut into my cash flow, but if I can implement Brandon's strategy and increase the value by 10% within the first 12 months via minor repairs, I can build equity.

Am I calculated this correctly? I think I'm getting thrown off somewhere. I think I'm getting thrown off because I'm talking about seller financing and borrowing the down payment.

Year 1: the house is worth $100,000. But I pay it at $80,000. I put $20,000 of my aunt's money down, leaving $60,000 to pay the owner. That means I already have $20,000 in equity because I bought at a discount.

Year2: the house is worth $110,000 because I increased the value by 10% via minor repairs. This means I have $30,000 in equity.

What's my next move? What would make this a good strategy? Or is this entire strategy flawed?

Thanks guys. Again, sorry if this is a really long and convoluted question.

0Reply
40 views

3 Replies

Jump to latestLatest
  • Investor · Dallas, TX · Member since 2014 · 2k+ posts · 1k+ votes
    12y

    @Nik Parks 

    Slow down a bit.  You're kinda all over the place.  :)

    First, don't blow the partner idea out of the water. You can absolutely do it in a way that leaves you as the decision maker and makes your aunt a silent partner. If you do that, I would suggest you split the profits 50/50. You talk about your aunt not wanting to put in any "sweat equity" as though that makes her entitled to less. Well, let's look at this from another perspective. What money are you putting in the deal? It doesn't sound like you're putting in anything. No lender would give you a loan on that deal. You would have no skin in the game, nothing that you're risking. Your aunt is willing to pony up real assets. She deserves a return that acknowledges the level of risk she is assuming. A Hard Money Lender (HML) would probably require you to put 30% down and then still charge you 12 - 15% interest with a 6-12 month balloon payment requirement.

    There are a lot of things you address, such as whether your aunt is looking for long-term gain or cash flow.  Do you know what your aunt's goals are?  Do you know what she needs?  If you don't, then you need to go talk to your aunt.  Actually, you need to listen to your aunt.  You need to find out what she wants and needs and what her goals are.  Once you do that, come back here and ask the question in terms of....here's what my aunt is willing to do and here's what she needs.  Here's what I need.  Is there a way you can structure a plan to meet everyone's needs?

    I really love your passion, but you won't be in this business very long, if you don't approach everything from the standpoint of creating win/win situations for everyone involved.

  • Astoria, NY · Member since 2013 · 40 posts · 4 votes
    12y

    I don't think she's less entitled by any means. I stated that it's completely fine that she doesn't want to put in any sweat equity :) It's easy for things to get misconstrued when non-verbal communication is involved so perhaps my thread came across the wrong way.

    I completely agree with you, everybody needs to come out ahead in this scenario. I would never conduct business any other way. If my thread came across any other way, it did not accurately represent my intentions.

    I appreciate your input and these are great questions to ask her. Do you have any information on having a silent partner? I'd love to learn more about that.

    The reason I was thinking of getting a loan from her instead of partnering up is because:

    1.) I've always heard that family and business don't mix well. This leads me to believe a buy and hold strategy could get sticky.

    2.) One of the most appealing aspects of REI is the control you have over your asset. I don't really want to share the control with a partner. That may be a bit too idealistic if I don't have the cash?

    Thanks again!

  • Rental Property Investor · Brookline, MA · Member since 2013 · 1k+ posts · 777 votes
    12y

    1) Business and family work fine together.  Just put everything down in writing.  Writing, put everything down in it... :)  I've borrowed successfully from my parents for years.  The nice part about borrowing from family is that they (generally) aren't going to try and hit you with outrageous interest rates.

    Each new deal goes down in writing.  All of the details.  When no one has any more questions, find a couple people you haven't talked to yet and see what questions they have.  Then put those answers in writing.  

    2) If you don't want to share, make sure there is a clear entry, hold/carry/rehab, and exit strategy for the deal.  If you have a great deal in the works, and your aunt is your partner, make sure the details are:

    1. In writing

    2. Clearly understood by ALL parties

    For your situation I would propose this to your aunt:

    -50/50 profit split.  
    -Your aunt has no power over the Real Estate asset in the deal.
    -She puts in 100% of ALL cash needed to purchase AND close AND rehab the deal.  When the flip is complete, your aunt gets all of her money back FIRST, then you split the remaining profits 50/50.  

    Example:

    100k to purchase and close

    30k rehab

    210k sale prie

    10k closing costs

    210 - 10 - 30 - 100 = 70k profit

    When this contract is severed, your aunt walks away with a check for 175k and you get one for 35k.  Everyone should be happy.  Do this several times in a row and your whole family, and their neighbors, will be banging down your door to invest.

    Make sure you are always striving towards a win/win situation for everyone in the deal.  There is a soft skills side of real estate as well.  You need to read your aunt and see how much she wants to be involved in the important decision making portions of the deal.  Maybe she just wants to pound nails, or move furniture, or pick out colors BUT she might want to have her hand in the financial details from day 1.

    Have that conversation with her from the first moment you think about going into business together.  Ask her direct questions.  You don't want to get to the end of what you thought was a successful deal only to find out she doesn't want to reinvest because you shut her out of the most important part of the the deal, important to her...

    Happy Investing.  Remember you aunt is a boon!!

Join the conversationCreate a free account to reply, vote on answers and follow this thread.