Skip to content
×
PRO
Pro Members Get Full Access!
Get off the sidelines and take action in real estate investing with BiggerPockets Pro. Our comprehensive suite of tools and resources minimize mistakes, support informed decisions, and propel you to success.
Advanced networking features
Market and Deal Finder tools
Property analysis calculators
Landlord Command Center
$0
TODAY
$69.00/month when billed monthly.
$32.50/month when billed annually.
7 day free trial. Cancel anytime
Already a Pro Member? Sign in here

Join Over 3 Million Real Estate Investors

Create a free BiggerPockets account to comment, participate, and connect with over 3 million real estate investors.
Use your real name
By signing up, you indicate that you agree to the BiggerPockets Terms & Conditions.
The community here is like my own little personal real estate army that I can depend upon to help me through ANY problems I come across.
Commercial Real Estate Investing
All Forum Categories
Followed Discussions
Followed Categories
Followed People
Followed Locations
Market News & Data
General Info
Real Estate Strategies
Landlording & Rental Properties
Real Estate Professionals
Financial, Tax, & Legal
Real Estate Classifieds
Reviews & Feedback

Updated about 1 year ago, 11/02/2023

User Stats

255
Posts
73
Votes
Kim Hopkins
  • Investor
73
Votes |
255
Posts

Using an LLC as a Guarantor on a Commercial Loan

Kim Hopkins
  • Investor
Posted

Hello!

We are working with a credit union on a loan for a commercial property acquisition. The loan is full recourse. In the past, we've just listed ourselves as individuals (or maybe our trust, I forget) as the guarantor. 

This time, we noticed there is an option to list an LLC as a guarantor. This seems like it might be advantageous as it might add a layer of protection.

If that's the case, what sort of structure for the LLC would be best? Here's the LLCs we already have:

       • About 15 LLCs that each hold one individual property. I'm sure those are out since they each only have ownership in one property.
       • An asset management LLC that has no interest in any properties. That would be ideal for us but I'm guessing the lender wouldn't allow it since it doesn't have interest in any properties
      • A new holding company LLC but it only has an interest in one smaller property we bought last year (our GP interest). 

Are any of these good candidates? If not, is it worth it to set up a new LLC? Does it actually offer more protection? And if so, what ownership should it have?

Yes I know this is a question for my attorney who I've already asked, but he just said "generally the lender will want to see assets in the LLC" so I'm looking for answers here from experienced investors and their best practices. No, I do not consider this legal advice.

Thank you!

Kim

User Stats

377
Posts
178
Votes
Greg Downey
  • Lender
  • Springfield, MO
178
Votes |
377
Posts
Greg Downey
  • Lender
  • Springfield, MO
Replied

@Sarah Downey might chime in here as she is our entity expert in the shop BUT I would ask your lender what EXACTLY they are referencing regarding the "guarantor". If this is simply on the loan applicaiton, I wouldn't consider that worth more than the paper it is written on. Here are the 3 things that it might mean....

This is a limited recourse loan - IE - recourse would be limited to the property AND anything owned within the LLC

This is a FULL recourse loan - IE - the loan can and will be made to your LLC BUT in the case of a default, the will take the property and if necessary reach into your personal assets.

This is NON-recourse loan (you have already identified that this is not the case) - Lender can only take the property in case of default

My guess is that this is a full recourse loan and you are reading MORE into the loan application than what will actually happen with the loan. IE - the LLC will be the borrower and YOU will be the guarantor. Certainly worth asking as you absolutely wan to know BUT I think that the question would be better aimed at the CU.

User Stats

255
Posts
73
Votes
Kim Hopkins
  • Investor
73
Votes |
255
Posts
Kim Hopkins
  • Investor
Replied
Quote from @Greg Downey:

@Sarah Downey might chime in here as she is our entity expert in the shop BUT I would ask your lender what EXACTLY they are referencing regarding the "guarantor". If this is simply on the loan applicaiton, I wouldn't consider that worth more than the paper it is written on. Here are the 3 things that it might mean....

This is a limited recourse loan - IE - recourse would be limited to the property AND anything owned within the LLC

This is a FULL recourse loan - IE - the loan can and will be made to your LLC BUT in the case of a default, the will take the property and if necessary reach into your personal assets.

This is NON-recourse loan (you have already identified that this is not the case) - Lender can only take the property in case of default

My guess is that this is a full recourse loan and you are reading MORE into the loan application than what will actually happen with the loan. IE - the LLC will be the borrower and YOU will be the guarantor. Certainly worth asking as you absolutely wan to know BUT I think that the question would be better aimed at the CU.


It's a full recourse loan but apparently an LLC can sometimes be the guarantor. Not the borrowing entity LLC.

PropStream logo
PropStream
|
Sponsored
Nationwide property data Use our robust, multi-sourced data to find off-market properties and close your next deal.

User Stats

377
Posts
178
Votes
Greg Downey
  • Lender
  • Springfield, MO
178
Votes |
377
Posts
Greg Downey
  • Lender
  • Springfield, MO
Replied

I would call that "limited recourse" if in fact the recourse would be limited to ONLY the LLC. If in fact, it would reach beyond the LLC, to your personal assets, they could call it "chicken noodle soup", but it would effectively be full recourse.

User Stats

56
Posts
62
Votes
Sarah Downey
Pro Member
  • Lender
  • Springfield MO
62
Votes |
56
Posts
Sarah Downey
Pro Member
  • Lender
  • Springfield MO
Replied

Hi Kim,

You should be able to use one of the LLCs mentioned without having to make a new one. Since this is a purchase, it should not matter if the LLC has assets or not. You will just need your basic LLC paperwork (Articles, Operating Agreement with any amendments/addendums, and an EIN letter).

It seems like you are already going the route of having an LLC for each property, though, which helps keep all the assets separated. I am assuming your attorney recommended this method. If you use the Asset Management LLC with no properties currently in it, that would keep things clean. But if you are using that for any other income/expenses, you may not want to throw a property in the mix.

The new holding company LLC with one other property could be an option, too. Maybe you could start putting 3-5 properties in an LLC together instead of creating a new one each time. That could keep your cost and paperwork down.

When starting out, the method of an individual LLC for each property doesn't seem too daunting, but once your portfolio starts to accelerate, it can turn into a lot of paperwork to manage.

I am sure you are feeling that now with 17 LLCs.

Best of luck with your purchase!

  • Sarah Downey
  • [email protected]
  • 417-986-2027
  • User Stats

    1,082
    Posts
    722
    Votes
    John McKee#5 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
    • Investor
    • Fairfax, VA
    722
    Votes |
    1,082
    Posts
    John McKee#5 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
    • Investor
    • Fairfax, VA
    Replied

    I never heard of such a thing. The LLC can be the borrow, but chances are you are the personal guarantor. The LLC asset is the property you are buying and yes it should be a separate LLC.

    User Stats

    5,134
    Posts
    2,126
    Votes
    Ronald Rohde
    Pro Member
    #3 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
    • Attorney
    • Dallas, TX
    2,126
    Votes |
    5,134
    Posts
    Ronald Rohde
    Pro Member
    #3 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
    • Attorney
    • Dallas, TX
    Replied

    You need real assets in the LLC to even be close to substituting a personal guaranty with an LLC.

    I don't think anything you mentioned has enough equity.

  • Ronald Rohde
  • User Stats

    377
    Posts
    178
    Votes
    Greg Downey
    • Lender
    • Springfield, MO
    178
    Votes |
    377
    Posts
    Greg Downey
    • Lender
    • Springfield, MO
    Replied

    @Kim Hopkins, whats the word? You have all of us legal and loan guys on the edge of our seats.

    User Stats

    255
    Posts
    73
    Votes
    Kim Hopkins
    • Investor
    73
    Votes |
    255
    Posts
    Kim Hopkins
    • Investor
    Replied

    LOL! @Greg Downey Well, I owe you all a drink, and my lawyer a nice $525 or whatever for the hour we wasted discussing this. According to the lender, they have no idea why it's an option to put an LLC as a guarantor and they've never had it approved. What a rabbit hole!

    Our broker even said something about this being worse than personally guaranteeing because you would be essentially cross-collateralizing the properties. 

    Back to signing over our house and our first born. J/k. I know they can't take the house. ;) 

    User Stats

    5,134
    Posts
    2,126
    Votes
    Ronald Rohde
    Pro Member
    #3 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
    • Attorney
    • Dallas, TX
    2,126
    Votes |
    5,134
    Posts
    Ronald Rohde
    Pro Member
    #3 Commercial Real Estate Investing Contributor
    • Attorney
    • Dallas, TX
    Replied
    Quote from @Kim Hopkins:

    LOL! @Greg Downey Well, I owe you all a drink, and my lawyer a nice $525 or whatever for the hour we wasted discussing this. According to the lender, they have no idea why it's an option to put an LLC as a guarantor and they've never had it approved. What a rabbit hole!

    Our broker even said something about this being worse than personally guaranteeing because you would be essentially cross-collateralizing the properties. 

    Back to signing over our house and our first born. J/k. I know they can't take the house. ;) 


     I think you just need more sophisticated vendors. Most of what you post could be answered offline, IMO someone with real access and data to your properties, rent rolls, your net worth, etc.

  • Ronald Rohde
  • User Stats

    255
    Posts
    73
    Votes
    Kim Hopkins
    • Investor
    73
    Votes |
    255
    Posts
    Kim Hopkins
    • Investor
    Replied
    Quote from @Ronald Rohde:
    Quote from @Kim Hopkins:

    LOL! @Greg Downey Well, I owe you all a drink, and my lawyer a nice $525 or whatever for the hour we wasted discussing this. According to the lender, they have no idea why it's an option to put an LLC as a guarantor and they've never had it approved. What a rabbit hole!

    Our broker even said something about this being worse than personally guaranteeing because you would be essentially cross-collateralizing the properties. 

    Back to signing over our house and our first born. J/k. I know they can't take the house. ;) 


     I think you just need more sophisticated vendors. Most of what you post could be answered offline, IMO someone with real access and data to your properties, rent rolls, your net worth, etc.


     What kind of vendors are you talking about? I think most of what I post is aimed towards other experienced real estate investors but would be happy to have "vendors" to go to offline if such existed...