Forums » Commercial Real Estate Investing Forum » NOI basics- experts please help

NOI basics- experts please help Subscribe to NOI basics- experts please help 8 posts by 7 users

Jordan S.

Real Estate Investor
new york, NY
Cash_house1_forum_avatar

118 posts

ok im sure this has been discussed on here numerous times but I am looking at building a multi family portfolio in the NY/NJ area and Id like to know what Im looking for when I research the NOI and expense numbers on a property... is a 10% NOI on the price of a building a decent return after expenses? After taking the mortgage into consideration and only clearing maybe several hundred dollars a month for myself, does it take a reasonably large portfolio to build wealth in this game? Im young and would like to make a nice living now while setting myself up for a strong future... any suggestions/advice from the players would be appreciated

Sponsors:

nationwidepi

Real Estate Investor
Santa Clarita, California
Npi_logo_forum_avatar

952 posts

Assuming you are talking about a commercial multifamily building, the average expected operating expenses may be around 50% of the gross income. Your NOI (Net Operating Income) is not your return so a 10% NOI would be terrible. You should have a 50% NOI, then deduct your debt financing.

There is much more to calculate than just your NOI. You need to know your DSCR (Debt Service Coverage Ratio) banks need a min of 1.2-1.25, you need to know your CROI (cash return on investment), the cap rate (as another evaluation tool), and you need to have studied the demographics of the area you are looking at.

Also remember that you want to pay on the current performance, not the proforma or expected performance of the apartment. Having upsides like a current poor property manager, or high expenses you can lower are good power plays to force appreciation.

Steve S.

Real Estate Investor
Seattle, WA
No_avatar_forum_avatar

30 posts

I think the OP needs to bring more specific information about the deal to get our advice. Technically, NOI should = (income - expenses), but not including the debt service. If your NOI, by that standard, is 10% of the purchase price, then it appears to be 10% cap rate which is potentially a very doable deal. But there are other factors that need to be considered and don't forget to do your due diligence to verify that income and expenses are accurate.

With a 10% cap rate its pretty easy to be significantly cash flow positive.

As nationwide said, a fairly good estimate of what expenses ought to be is 40-50% of the income. So basically if they are collecting X dollars in rent, etc, then cut that amount in half to get a rough estimate of the NOI.

If they report expenses lower than that amount then it might be possible to actually be lower, but verify why. The long term expenses are going to be closer to 50%. All sellers will try to present their numbers as favorably as possible. But you also need to know the area. Some geographical areas have higher expenses due to taxes, high maintenence costs, etc..so you need to know if your area tends to be under or over 50%. But for a rough estimate, use 50%.

Also, when doing your due diligence, make sure to have inspections to find out if there is any deferred maintenance, which is even more likely to be the case if they have historically had low expenses. That would mean that they have postponed taking care of certain expenses that should have been addressed. As you find out what those things are, you have to negotiate the sales price down because otherwise you will soon be faced with those expenses which are over and above what they have been reporting for the past couple years as their normal operating expenses.

Mach


Boonies, Pennsylvania
Snapshot_20081106_3_forum_avatar

305 posts

Just look for ROI.

Unless your super aggressive and have some money to play with I doubt you could get wealth fast in the rental game.

J S.

Real Estate Investor
Atlanta, Georgia
No_avatar_forum_avatar

159 posts

Here's a primer on performing Financial Analysis of multi-unit properties, if you're interested:

[LINK REMOVED BY ADMIN - The point of the forums is to share information, not to plug your website. Please share your article here on the site so we can all read it.]

Ken S.

Real Estate Investor
San Jose, CA
No_avatar_forum_avatar

12 posts

Originally posted by "SteveSchow"

Also, when doing your due diligence, make sure to have inspections to find out if there is any deferred maintenance, which is even more likely to be the case if they have historically had low expenses. That would mean that they have postponed taking care of certain expenses that should have been addressed. As you find out what those things are, you have to negotiate the sales price down because otherwise you will soon be faced with those expenses which are over and above what they have been reporting for the past couple years as their normal operating expenses.

Let's say there is a certain amount of expenses that have been deferred, and you do negotiate the price down. Obviously, these are still issues you may want to address. What would be the most common ways of taking care of this with OPM?

J S.

Real Estate Investor
Atlanta, Georgia
No_avatar_forum_avatar

159 posts

You could have the seller provide cash back (in escrow) specifically for the purpose of making these repairs. Or you could potentially get the lender to provide a " rehab loan" where the LTV is based on the ARV of the property, and roll the rehab costs into the loan.

Andres G.

Real Estate Investor
Miami Beach, FL
098_forum_avatar

33 posts

All very good responses which you should take into consideration. I would like to add one thing. A 10% cap rate may or may not be a good deal depending on the are or the market cap. In commercial real estate deals are valued primarily through the income approach vs comparable analysis which is prevalent in residential real estate.

A commercial appraiser will look at closed transactions in a particular area to determine the market cap rate. If you are purchasing in sub market (neighborhood or area within a city) in which the market cap rate is 12% then you are overpaying and vice versa if the market cap sits at 8%. During your preliminary analysis or your due diligence period you should call 2 or 3 appraisers and ask them to give you an estimate of the market cap in the area of your potential investment. This question should come in passing, call tell them you are shopping for an appraiser for a deal you are getting serious about, small talk (ask about the area what they know how they feel about it) and then just casually ask the market cap.

A final note, if you truly want to make a LOT of money investing in commercial have a specific strategy for each property you acquire. Determine its current market value, determine your game plan for management. How will you increase income? How can you decrease expenses? The beauty of commercial real estate is that it is very easy to manipulate the value of a building by simply managing a property efficiently.

[EDITED BY MODERATOR - Solicitation removed]