Skip to content
Private Lending & Conventional Mortgage Advice

User Stats

36
Posts
18
Votes
Jim Doyle
Pro Member
18
Votes |
36
Posts

30 year fixed or 5/6 ARM in current market May 2024 market conditions

Jim Doyle
Pro Member
Posted May 8 2024, 21:35

Looking to purchase my first home and was initially going to go the traditional fixed rate mortgage without buying down points with the assumption rates will go down in the next year or 2 and I will just refinance. I was getting interest rates that were slightly over 7% for a fixed, and I recently learned about the 5/6 ARM through my local credit bureau who I had financed my car through many years back. They came in a 6.375%, no loan origination fee, etc. and said I can refinance at anytime with no prepayment penalties, seems almost too good to be true. Is there anything I'm missing? If I will refinance before the 5 year fixed period expires, without any penalties, I'm having a hard time understanding why I'd want to go forward with a fixed rate currently. Any thoughts on the below? This quote is as of May 2024.

User Stats

1,903
Posts
1,044
Votes
Jason Wray
Pro Member
  • Banker
  • Nationwide
1,044
Votes |
1,903
Posts
Jason Wray
Pro Member
  • Banker
  • Nationwide
Replied May 8 2024, 21:43

Jim,

Take the 5/6 ARM its fixed for 5 years and rates will drop prior to the 5 years allowing you to refinance and lock into a 20 or 30 year fixed rate. Average home owner refinances their mortgage within 3-5 years so a 30 year fixed at these rates is just a bad decision with rates expected to trend down. FED cannot avoid cutting rates they dropped in December and January and a CPI index report crushed everything that was really all hedged data.

User Stats

3,556
Posts
3,552
Votes
Robin Simon#1 Private Lending & Conventional Mortgage Advice Contributor
  • Lender
  • Austin, TX
3,552
Votes |
3,556
Posts
Robin Simon#1 Private Lending & Conventional Mortgage Advice Contributor
  • Lender
  • Austin, TX
Replied May 9 2024, 06:21

I think you are correct in your thinking - a lot of lenders right now are pricing 30-year fixed rate and 5-year ARMs essentially the same, with only the slightest benefit to the ARM option - generally because there is a very low probability priced in that rates will be higher in 5 years. If you are getting significantly lower on the ARM option - probably a good bet

BiggerPockets logo
BiggerPockets
|
Sponsored
Find an investor-friendly agent in your market TODAY Get matched with our network of trusted, local, investor friendly agents in under 2 minutes